tOfficial 2000 to Present Mock Draft Thread

[Ritzarmy]

Stafford or Ryan

Really you don't think Brees can do another 4-5 years?

 

[JMedlock5186]

I agree, Stafford is the best of the lot. RG3 is to fragile and will likely be out of the league in a few years. Ryan is good but i have never been sold on him. Brees is old and wont help you in this type of league for very long

 

[JMedlock5186]

Really you don't think Brees can do another 4-5 years?

no. I think that he is getting up there and at best maybe 2

 

[UK Cowboy]

I'm wondering if Jameis Winston or Marcus Mariota might not be bad picks in a 5 year league as a backup QB

 

[Nosferatu]

I'm not so sure Stafford is better than Ryan...

 

[JMedlock5186]

I'm wondering if Jameis Winston or Marcus Mariota might not be bad picks in a 5 year league as a backup QB

they cant be picked in this draft though

 

[Clayton]

Who would you guys choose for a QB in a dynasty league Brees, Stafford, RG3, or Ryan?

Ryan easily. RG3 second on the hopes he'd stay healthy. Stafford is a product of Megatron. Brees is getting up there in age

I know Ryan is also a product of the people around him but he has at least been pretty good with those pieces compiling a great home record and has a playoff win

 

[Ritzarmy]

Then Stafford is looking like my QB with the last pick in the draft. He will be used to throwing to my #1 WR Megatron.

 

[UK Cowboy]

I agree, Stafford is the best of the lot. RG3 is to fragile and will likely be out of the league in a few years. Ryan is good but i have never been sold on him. Brees is old and wont help you in this type of league for very long

I always look at QB's one way....trade them straight up and what do you have. I know I will be rained down on by Seachicken fans, but if you switched Russell Wilson with Matthew Stafford, there's no way the Seahawks aren't better and the Lions worse. Anyone who thinks Wilson is better than Stafford is either a Homer or has 0.00 football IQ

 

[UK Cowboy]

Ryan easily. RG3 second on the hopes he'd stay healthy. Stafford is a product of Megatron. Brees is getting up there in age

I know Ryan is also a product of the people around him but he has at least been pretty good with those pieces compiling a great home record and has a playoff win

I would bet that 32 NFL GM's would take Stafford over Ryan, including Atlanta's

 

[JMedlock5186]

Statistically Ryan is better, but I prefer Stafford

 

[JMedlock5186]

Clayton is OTC

 

[Clayton]

I would bet that 32 NFL GM's would take Stafford over Ryan, including Atlanta's

Former Bears GM has literally the exact same grade on both QBs for what thats worth.

7.9 Matt Ryan

A good, but not special player. He is tough minded and smart, but his arm talent is not elite. He needs a good cast around him. When he is not supported with talented receivers, a solid line and a good running game, you see his flaws.

7.9 Matt Stafford

Stafford, in my eyes, not only did not win games for the Lions this year, but also LOST them for his team. Carelessness with the ball, inaccurate throws, and poor mechanics will prevent him from ever turning into an elite QB. Calvin Johnson masks a lot of his faults.

 

[JMedlock5186]

I think honestly that both of them are not so great without solid supporting cast.

 

[JMedlock5186]

Nos is OTC

 

[Ritzarmy]

Former Bears GM has literally the exact same grade on both QBs for what thats worth.

7.9 Matt Ryan

A good, but not special player. He is tough minded and smart, but his arm talent is not elite. He needs a good cast around him. When he is not supported with talented receivers, a solid line and a good running game, you see his flaws.

7.9 Matt Stafford

Stafford, in my eyes, not only did not win games for the Lions this year, but also LOST them for his team. Carelessness with the ball, inaccurate throws, and poor mechanics will prevent him from ever turning into an elite QB. Calvin Johnson masks a lot of his faults.

Its a good break down on both but their weaknesses wont show in this dynasty draft.

Ryan needs to be surrounded with a good cast of players he would have Megatron, Harvin, Foster, Clady and Staley.

Stafford- Megatron masks a lot of his faults well he will still have Megatron plus a better team around him.

 

[UK Cowboy]

I'm not so sure Stafford is better than Ryan...

Who would you take for your Vikings? I bet Norv would wet his shorts for Stafford. I have to tell you, as a Cowboys fan, you guys just hired the HC that I've wanted for Dallas for the last 5-6 years. Zimmer is going to do a fantastic job, and the Vikings will be contenders year in and year out. It will be interesting to see what the Vikings do at QB. I don't see anyone at 8 except maybe Carr that fits Norv's style. Mettenberger or Savage at the top of round 2, or trading that pick for Mallett would be nice fits. I bet Zimmer takes Donald at 8

 

[Ritzarmy]

I think honestly that both of them are not so great without solid supporting cast.

Which is exactly the point in a dynasty draft he will have a solid supporting cast. Unless Nos is drafting then you just have a less supportive team which we call the Vikings

 

[JMedlock5186]

Who would you take for your Vikings? I bet Norv would wet his shorts for Stafford. I have to tell you, as a Cowboys fan, you guys just hired the HC that I've wanted for Dallas for the last 5-6 years. Zimmer is going to do a fantastic job, and the Vikings will be contenders year in and year out. It will be interesting to see what the Vikings do at QB. I don't see anyone at 8 except maybe Carr that fits Norv's style. Mettenberger or Savage at the top of round 2, or trading that pick for Mallett would be nice fits. I bet Zimmer takes Donald at 8

They could possibly trade back a few spots to gain another pick from the teams looking to trade into the top ten. I think they could still land Donald around 12-14

 

[JMedlock5186]

Which is exactly the point in a dynasty draft he will have a solid supporting cast. Unless Nos is drafting then you just have a less supportive team which we call the Vikings

Wow below the belt.