The Max MLB Draft : CHAT

[Nosferatu]

Lineup (9) Max 1800 Home Runs
Lineup (9) Max five .300 avg hitters
Rotation (5) Max 750 Wins
Bullpen (FOUR) Max 600 Saves

Every player that had their first game prior to 2005 is eligible.


In order for you to use a pitcher as a starter he must have at least 50% of his games as a starter, same for the relievers, must have at least 50% of his games be out of the pen.

 

[Nosferatu]

IN?
UK
Ducey
500
Milk
Femur
Shane
Sushi
Stakes
Hall
Mookie

 

[Hall]

Picking 6 bullpen?

Whenever I think you like them too much...it jumps up to a whole new level!

 

[Nosferatu]

@MookieMonstah50
@Hall
@CitySushi
@Stakesarehigh
@broncosmitty
@blstoker
@ehb5

 

[CitySushi]

Picking 6 bullpen?

Whenever I think you like them too much...it jumps up to a whole new level!

LOL, first time I agree with you here. 4 max for BP.

 

[Nosferatu]

Picking 6 bullpen?

Whenever I think you like them too much...it jumps up to a whole new level!

It was simply to give us an even number. I reckon we could do 18

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Still think that we should move up the window so we don’t include dead ball era. It’s pretty much cheating imo.

Even if that means we increase the hr max to 2000

 

[CitySushi]

@MookieMonstah50
@Hall
@CitySushi
@Stakesarehigh
@broncosmitty
@blstoker
@ehb5

 

[Stakesarehigh]

Still think that we should move up the window so we don’t include dead ball era. It’s pretty much cheating imo.

Even if that means we increase the hr max to 2000

Yep

 

[Nosferatu]

LOL, first time I agree with you here. 4 max for BP.

Ya know, one day he's going to say something positive! We might all be drafting from an old folks home but it's gonna happen!!!

 

[Nosferatu]

Still think that we should move up the window so we don’t include dead ball era. It’s pretty much cheating imo.

Even if that means we increase the hr max to 2000

But if we limit .300 avg guys that should be good enough.

 

[Shanemansj13]

Still think that we should move up the window so we don’t include dead ball era. It’s pretty much cheating imo.

Even if that means we increase the hr max to 2000

Having a max # of .300 hitters solves that

 

[MilkSpiller22]

But if we limit .300 avg guys that should be good enough.

Having a max # of .300 hitters solves that

Umm no it doesn’t. Not at all. Power hitters generally don’t hit .300. And any hitter pre 1930 that will be taken all has .300 or better. So what are you accomplishing?? Nothing!!

 

[Shanemansj13]

Umm no it doesn’t. Not at all. Power hitters generally don’t hit .300. And any hitter pre 1930 that will be taken all has .300 or better. So what are you accomplishing?? Nothing!!

Increasing the homerun total and cutting out pre 1930 does nothing too so why not keep pre

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Increasing the homerun total and cutting out pre 1930 does nothing too so why not keep pre

There is a difference between a ty Cobb and a tony Gwynn. We know the type of player tony Gwynn is. His lack of home runs would be accounted for. But TY cobb’s Lack of home runs is like saying let’s take one of the best power hitters of his time and get him for nothing.

If we are doing pre 1930 then there is no reason to not do post 2005 and current. I mean it’s just as much of a mystery and just as much cheating.

 

[Hall]

Ya know, one day he's going to say something positive! We might all be drafting from an old folks home but it's gonna happen!!!

I went a whole like MEga Draft complementing picks and no response to those. Might as well stick with what works.

 

[Nosferatu]

Umm no it doesn’t. Not at all. Power hitters generally don’t hit .300. And any hitter pre 1930 that will be taken all has .300 or better. So what are you accomplishing?? Nothing!!

Sure they do...

Mays .302
Aaron .305
Musial .331
Ruth .342
Pujols .300
Gehrig .340

If we make it .290 that would include Mantle, Bonds, Arod

 

[Nosferatu]

I went a whole like MEga Draft complementing picks and no response to those. Might as well stick with what works.

I must have been dead for those...

 

[Nosferatu]

There is a difference between a ty Cobb and a tony Gwynn. We know the type of player tony Gwynn is. His lack of home runs would be accounted for. But TY cobb’s Lack of home runs is like saying let’s take one of the best power hitters of his time and get him for nothing.

If we are doing pre 1930 then there is no reason to not do post 2005 and current. I mean it’s just as much of a mystery and just as much cheating.

I honestly have no idea your point...

 

[Hall]

I honestly have no idea your point...

That Gwynn has more HR than Cobb, but Cobbs slugging was 60 points higher and lead the league in Slugging 8 times.