The Gardner Minshew Thread

[Godstree]

Thank you, you you very much.....

 

[eaglesnut]

Word is, the Eagles are looking for wentz insurance.

I already said Foles would be back.

You're months late...

but also months early...

 

[Godstree]

I already said Foles would be back.

You're months late...

but also months early...

Sorry, I only troll the shit ass poster that roots for the eagles. I missed it.

 

[eaglesnut]

Sorry, I only troll the shit ass poster that roots for the eagles. I missed it.

Iggloo is the smartest guy in Texas.

 

[SteelersPride]

I hate to say anything negative about him but if he wasn’t colorful he’d be labeled an Alex Smith or a Teddy two gloves quarterback.

so what alex smith was a very good quarterback. Minshew has been surprisingly accurate, and manipulates the pocket well. ALOT of teams want alex smith level.

 

[wazzu31]

so what alex smith was a very good quarterback. Minshew has been surprisingly accurate, and manipulates the pocket well. ALOT of teams want alex smith level.

Sure, but you have never heard a single person say I want Alex Smith starting for my team in the playoffs.

 

[SteelersPride]

Sure, but you have never heard a single person say I want Alex Smith starting for my team in the playoffs.

hes been hurt. How many qb's does anyone say i want for my team for the playoffs. I mean honestly if im choosing
there what 5?

and in the PLAYOFFS is someone nuts for suggesting taking brady, bledsoe, wilson, ben over mahomes? guys who have got it done ......

most teams 20+ teams would kill for a matt ryan. is anyone saying i want matt ryan to be my playoff qb?

poor analogy

 

[wazzu31]

hes been hurt. How many qb's does anyone say i want for my team for the playoffs. I mean honestly if im choosing
there what 5?

and in the PLAYOFFS is someone nuts for suggesting taking brady, bledsoe, wilson, ben over mahomes? guys who have got it done ......

most teams 20+ teams would kill for a matt ryan. is anyone saying i want matt ryan to be my playoff qb?

poor analogy

Hmm? The Rams would’ve killed for Matt Ryan last year. Alex Smith is a game manager, nothing wrong with that but you generally don’t have a sensation like the Stache has become because he is colorful. Being colorful helps you be more than you are or being dull hinders you like how Rivers isn’t ever really considered a top guy even though I’d put him ahead of Rodgers and Big Ben.

 

[Schmoopy1000]

Hmm? The Rams would’ve killed for Matt Ryan last year. Alex Smith is a game manager, nothing wrong with that but you generally don’t have a sensation like the Stache has become because he is colorful. Being colorful helps you be more than you are or being dull hinders you like how Rivers isn’t ever really considered a top guy even though I’d put him ahead of Rodgers and Big Ben.

The Bears would kill for an Alex Smith.

 

[SteelersPride]

Hmm? The Rams would’ve killed for Matt Ryan last year. Alex Smith is a game manager, nothing wrong with that but you generally don’t have a sensation like the Stache has become because he is colorful. Being colorful helps you be more than you are or being dull hinders you like how Rivers isn’t ever really considered a top guy even though I’d put him ahead of Rodgers and Big Ben.

and some years a team would kill for alex smith, the bears for instance. Over rodgers and ben? crazy talk

 

[wazzu31]

The Bears would kill for an Alex Smith.

Of course. I didn’t mean for this to turn into a negative thread. Alex Smith isn’t bad, I’m just saying the Stache is a much more colorful Alex Smith

 

[wazzu31]

and some years a team would kill for alex smith, the bears for instance. Over rodgers and ben? crazy talk

Philip Rivers? Yes, over both.

 

[thedddd]

Those saying he's just a flash thing and won't be as good as x are missing the point. The NFL is an entertainment league pure and simple. There's a place for him as long as people talk about him.

Hell, Cam sucks balls anymore but the league also loves a good villain or heel.

Literally.

 

[thedddd]

The Bears would kill for an Alex Smith.

Same with the Broncos.

 

[Southieinnc]

Iggloo is the smartest guy in Texas.

For some strange reason I'm going to just let this one go.....

 

[Iggloo]

For some strange reason I'm going to just let this one go.....

In the land of the blind, the one-eyed man is king!

 

[SteelersPride]

Philip Rivers? Yes, over both.

Yikes

 

[LambeauLegs]

Is Gardner Minshew the next Tom Brady? Bears' D better in '19?

 

[eaglesnut]

Is Gardner Minshew the next Tom Brady? Bears' D better in '19?

If he was 6'4

 

[wazzu31]

Yikes

Big Ben? Had the worst QB rating in the history of the Super Bowl and had superior talent his entire career is head and shoulders better than Rivers?