Tatis Jr. or Soroka should be NLROY

[Mistaken4193]

Not Pete Alonso. Other than HRs Alonso has been average. But he plays for the Muts so he will win.


WAR:
Tatis- 4.2
Soroka- 4.5
Alonso-3.7

Stats:

Tatis- .317 22HR 53RBIs

Alonso- .258 38HR 85RBIs

Soroka 10-2 2.32ERA

 

[Chewbaccer]

I’d give it to Tatis Jr. He missed about a month and is still putting up those numbers

 

[Rock Strongo]

Not Pete Alonso. Other than HRs Alonso has been average. But he plays for the Muts so he will win.


WAR:
Tatis- 4.2
Soroka- 4.5
Alonso-3.7

Stats:

Tatis- .317 22HR 53RBIs

Alonso- .258 38HR 85RBIs

Soroka 10-2 2.32ERA

petes .363 OBP and .589 slugging is really nice too. but look at the K's. tatis has 22 fewer K's than alonso, in 33 fewer games (tatis fans at a higher rate). tatis only has 30 walks to alonsos almost 60. pete has a better walk rate.

tatis is .63 RBI/game
alonso is .72 RBI/game

both are great young hitters, but i think tatis missing a month ultimately hurts him.

 

[Rock Strongo]

btw, vlad jr should get more love. for a guy who came up at what, 19?

hes played 90 games

93 hits
only 64 k's

37 walks are low, but hes gotten markedly better in the 2nd half.

29 games
37 hits
.330/.390/.563
9 doubles
5 HR/27 RBI
17 k's/11 walks

 

[Mistaken4193]

I’d give it to Tatis Jr. He missed about a month and is still putting up those numbers

I would too. I wish they would give 2 separate Rookie of the Years. 1 for pitchers and 1 for everyday players

 

[kburjr]

NL has introduced a new generation of stars this year.

I'll add Keston Hiura

56 games played

63 hits

.303/.372/.587

OPS+ 142

13 doubles 2 triples 14 home runs

 

[Rock Strongo]

NL has introduced a new generation of stars this year.

I'll add Keston Hiura

56 games played

63 hits

.303/.372/.587

OPS+ 142

yeah, he may be too little too late tho, and his defense. hes got what 12 errors? he got called up for good too late IMO to count.

 

[kburjr]

yeah, he may be too little too late tho, and his defense. hes got what 12 errors? he got called up for good too late IMO to count.

yeah. He won't get the counting stats. I was just looking forward


Edit: 10 errors

That can be fixed by hard work

 

[kburjr]

yeah, he may be too little too late tho, and his defense. hes got what 12 errors? he got called up for good too late IMO to count.

BTW, Tatis, Jr has 18 errors

 

[tducey]

Tatis would be my choice for the award as well.

 

[molsaniceman]

NL has introduced a new generation of stars this year.

I'll add Keston Hiura

56 games played

63 hits

.303/.372/.587

OPS+ 142

13 doubles 2 triples 14 home runs

aquino 8 homers in 39 at bats 1.45 ops

 

[Cedrique]

Yordan Alvarez is still pretty freaking amazing too

 

[mr.hockey4242]

NL has introduced a new generation of stars this year.

I'll add Keston Hiura

56 games played

63 hits

.303/.372/.587

OPS+ 142

13 doubles 2 triples 14 home runs

Huira is a stud at the plate. Just a legit all around hitter from what I’ve seen.

His defense is abysmal tho

 

[kburjr]

Huira is a stud at the plate. Just a legit all around hitter from what I’ve seen.

His defense is abysmal tho

He'll end up a corner OF after Braun is done. Can always find a glove

 

[Rod Freakin' Dangerfield]

 

[navamind]

Not Pete Alonso. Other than HRs Alonso has been average. But he plays for the Muts so he will win.


WAR:
Tatis- 4.2
Soroka- 4.5
Alonso-3.7

Stats:

Tatis- .317 22HR 53RBIs

Alonso- .258 38HR 85RBIs

Soroka 10-2 2.32ERA

"take away the thing he's among the best in the league at, he's average!"

can't argue with any of those three right now though IMO. Bryan Reynolds also merits some discussion (.338/.412/.542, 148 OPS+, 3.9 WAR).

 

[basement bias]

Tatis bc he played with the local Tincaps

 

[navamind]

petes .363 OBP and .589 slugging is really nice too. but look at the K's. tatis has 22 fewer K's than alonso, in 33 fewer games (tatis fans at a higher rate). tatis only has 30 walks to alonsos almost 60. pete has a better walk rate.

tatis is .63 RBI/game
alonso is .72 RBI/game

both are great young hitters, but i think tatis missing a month ultimately hurts him.

I think that missed month is also a blessing for Tatis stat line. He's sporting a .410 BABIP and he's striking out a hair under 30%. I don't think anyone's had a .400+ BABIP over the last 15 years or so, so I have my doubts he'd be able to sustain that. I think that batting average will come down sooner or later. Don't get me wrong, I think he's going to be a great player. I just think he's overachieving.

 

[Chewbaccer]

"take away the thing he's among the best in the league at, he's average!"

can't argue with any of those three right now though IMO. Bryan Reynolds also merits some discussion (.338/.412/.542, 148 OPS+, 3.9 WAR).

Alonso is just another Adam Dunn type. Except Adam Dunn was 21 when he debuted instead of 24.

Really, 23 should be the cutoff age for ROTY. You're really screwing the player over if you hold them in the minors that long.

 

[molsaniceman]

Fernando Tatis Jr. (back) is expected to be placed on the 10-day injured list on Thursday.
The club had been hopeful that he would be able to return to the lineup after a couple of days of rest, but that no longer appears to be the case. The star rookie shortstop did not travel with the team to Philadelphia and will undergo further tests on his ailing back on Thursday before a final determination is made. Luis Urias will continue to fill in at shortstop in his absence.