Sickness, G.O.A.T. Up

[blstoker]

Hey, Sickness, as promised, I got the list for my G.O.A.T. passers list up on the general board (and anyone else who would like to take a look).

http://www.sportshoopla.com/forums/nfl-football-forum-message-board-general-discussion/138889-top-107-a.html


Here is the list of the QBs that played for the 9ers (as far as I know) and where they finished.

Joe Montana - 1
Steve Young - 12
John Brodie – 31
Billy Kilmer - 36
Jeff Garcia – 38
Jim Plunkett - 54
Earl Morrall - 61
Steve DeBerg - 62
Jeff Kemp - 89
Norm Snead - 91
Trent Dilfer - 100

 

[NinerSickness]

Interesting stuff. I'll bet that took a heck of a long time.

Did you look at any other statistic against the average or just completions & completion percentage? Did you look at yard per attempt?

 

[blstoker]

Interesting stuff. I'll bet that took a heck of a long time.

Did you look at any other statistic against the average or just completions & completion percentage? Did you look at yard per attempt?

I did not include yards per attempt. I started this so long ago that I am not sure at this point what my reasoning was in leaving it out. Unfortunately, now that I'm done with it, I'm not sure I want to take the time to put it in. Maybe, I'll do that when I revisit it next year and guys like Aaron Rodgers come onto the list.

 

[TobyTyler]

Hey, Sickness, as promised, I got the list for my G.O.A.T. passers list up on the general board (and anyone else who would like to take a look).

http://www.sportshoopla.com/forums/nfl-football-forum-message-board-general-discussion/138889-top-107-a.html


Here is the list of the QBs that played for the 9ers (as far as I know) and where they finished.

Joe Montana - 1
Steve Young - 12
John Brodie – 31
Billy Kilmer - 36
Jeff Garcia – 38
Jim Plunkett - 54
Earl Morrall - 61
Steve DeBerg - 62
Jeff Kemp - 89
Norm Snead - 91
Trent Dilfer - 100

I didn't even realize that Snead and Morrall played for the 49ers. I think your ratings of Tarkenton and Brees are way too high.