Re-Vote for MVPs/Cy Young Awards

[soxfan1468927]

Would anyone be interested in going season by season starting in 1901 and voting for MVP and Cy Young Awards? We could cast ballots for top 5 in MVP and top 3 in Cy Young and tally up the yearly winners. I'm always up for historical baseball projects like this and figured if we could get a minimum of 10 ballots per year that would be enough of a sample.

Anyone could join in at anytime and it could cause some great baseball discussions. If there is enough interest I don't mind keeping the tally and calculating the winners. Let me know what you think.

 

[ImSmartherThanYou]

Dude, do you really need to ask me that question? Of course I would.

When the Fanatic went down, one of the things I was most upset about was the loss of the Fanatic Hall of Fame. If this awards thing works, I'd love to go back and recreate that here.

 

[StanMarsh51]

Dude, do you really need to ask me that question? Of course I would.

When the Fanatic went down, one of the things I was most upset about was the loss of the Fanatic Hall of Fame. If this awards thing works, I'd love to go back and recreate that here.

+1

 

[JR Hart]

let the voting begin

 

[Swangin]

present

 

[Omar 382]

no doubt about it

 

[The Cubs fan]

This sounds like an awesome idea.

 

[soxfan1468927]

Awesome, so that's 7 posters so far and I'll check back tomorrow to see if anyone else wants in. I'm thinking to gain interest at first, it may be better to start with last year and go backwards. People may lose interest after voting for Babe Ruth for the 15th time. Going backwards would give allow for more debate on seasons we actually have seen.

 

[soxfan1468927]

let the voting begin

JR Hart is here now?!?!

 

[navamind]

I'd love to.

 

[JR Hart]

JR Hart is here now?!?!

Did you miss me?

 

[navamind]

Did you miss me?

I did a little. We disagree on a lot of things, but I always thought you were a knowledgeable baseball fan.

 

[ImSmartherThanYou]

Awesome, so that's 7 posters so far and I'll check back tomorrow to see if anyone else wants in. I'm thinking to gain interest at first, it may be better to start with last year and go backwards. People may lose interest after voting for Babe Ruth for the 15th time. Going backwards would give allow for more debate on seasons we actually have seen.

I agree. Start with the most recent and work backwards.

 

[soxfan1468927]

Did you miss me?

Absolutely, I found your stances much different than mine, but I rarely heard you resort to name calling or any petty tactics in your arguments. It's good to have you here.

 

[luvthemeagl1]

Dude, do you really need to ask me that question? Of course I would.

When the Fanatic went down, one of the things I was most upset about was the loss of the Fanatic Hall of Fame. If this awards thing works, I'd love to go back and recreate that here.

this.

 

[da55bums]

Would anyone be interested in going season by season starting in 1901 and voting for MVP and Cy Young Awards? We could cast ballots for top 5 in MVP and top 3 in Cy Young and tally up the yearly winners. I'm always up for historical baseball projects like this and figured if we could get a minimum of 10 ballots per year that would be enough of a sample.

Anyone could join in at anytime and it could cause some great baseball discussions. If there is enough interest I don't mind keeping the tally and calculating the winners. Let me know what you think.

NO...most of them are dead and it can't be changed.