proposed interesting trade

[MilkSpiller22]

Someone just offered me:

I receive: Justin Blackmon, antonio Brown, sam bradford, le'veon bell

I give up: Cam newton AJ green and throw in brian Hoyer and Kris durham as roster ballances

My team if i accept this trade

QB: Terrelle pryor/sam bradford(start one)
RB: Arian foster, Lamar miller, montee ball, chris ivory, leveon bell(start 2+ flex)
WR: Antonio Brown, Justin Blackmon, Eddie Royal, Aaron dobson, Marlon Brown(start 2+flex)
TE: Tyler Eifert
K: matt bryant
D: ravens


1/2PPR...




Should i accept??
note: Lamar miller has his bye and right now i am starting Montee ball or chris Ivory...

Poll is added: if i get 55% or higher by 5:00 PM Eastern then i will accept...


I posted this on the wrong board first, Posting the thread again here on the correct board...

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Can people explain their votes??

 

[TKOSpikes]

At first glance I would say no way. I wouldn't trade AJ for Blackmon and Bell (although it's extremely close). I wouldn't trade Newton for Bradford and Brown (or however you want to pair them up)... HOWEVER, looking at your RB's, I think you should make this deal. You kind of need Bell, with Miller not being consistent and Ivory and Ball being non factors.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

At first glance I would say no way. I wouldn't trade AJ for Blackmon and Bell (although it's extremely close). I wouldn't trade Newton for Bradford and Brown (or however you want to pair them up)... HOWEVER, looking at your RB's, I think you should make this deal. You kind of need Bell, with Miller not being consistent and Ivory and Ball being non factors.

Thats where i am... I am clearly giving up the 2 best players in the deal... but my depth is killing me!!! this trade downgrades my WR1 and QB but upgrades the whole rest of my team... The question is how much of a downgrade is Cam newton to Pryor or Bradford(we dont penalize for turnovers)

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Should i counter offer and ask for vick instead of bradford?? is it worth the possibility of losing the first offer??

 

[TKOSpikes]

we dont penalize for turnovers

that helps.

Should i counter offer and ask for vick instead of bradford?? is it worth the possibility of losing the first offer??

can't answer that one, that's an individual thing specific to your league.

 

[TREFF]

Given your roster, I'd say yes

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Given your roster, I'd say yes

Is that saying that you would normally say no??

 

[TREFF]

Normally is have to give it hard thought. . given your need at RB.. it's an easy yes for me.

 

[wilwhite]

I agree with Treff. The 1/2 PPR makes Antonio Brown a little better. And if you had the post-trade team right now, it would be crazy to trade Bell, Blackmon and Antonio away for Green because it would decimate your team, even if you also got the iffy Dam upgrade over Bradford.

Also an easy yes for me.

 

[Sox33OSU]

To put things into perspective for you a little more -

- AJ Green currently has 1 more point this year in standard leagues than A. Brown, and Brown has had a bye.
- Jax is throwing more than running and will be trailing in every game this year. In his first game back, Blackmon received 9 targets. That number shouldn't drop at all. It's also been noted he put in some huge effort during his 4 game suspension to get in top-notch physical shape, and people have noticed around the league.
- Le'Veon Bell instantly becomes your desperately needed RB2.

Overall, I like this trade any way you slice it.