Pro Football HOF

[Kreton]

The First Cut 2014

This is the list of finalists. If you had vote for 6 guys to get in, which 6 do you pick?

 

[broncosmitty]

Tim Brown, Eddie DeBartolo, Kevin Greene, Marvin Harrison, Jimmy Johnson and Tagliabue. I think.

 

[Mebert]

Michael Strahan
Derrick Brooks
Walter Jones
Will Shields
Marvin Harrison
John Lynch

My list is very heavy on players I actually got to watch.

 

[Naughtymax]

Derek Brooks DPOY, 5 All-Pro designations, all-decade team for 2000-2009.
Tim Brown - I do not understand how this guy is kept out. 9 1000 yard seasons, fifth all-time in receptions and yards.
Michael Strahan. No-brainer
Kevin Greene - I again don't understand how this guy is kept out. 3rd all-time in sacks.
Jerome Bettis - 6th all-time in yards, ring, good guy. Borderline, but how do you keep a top-10 RB
stats guy out?
Andre Reed - again, borderline like Bettis, but if you put Lynn Swann and John Stallworth in, how can you keep Reed out? He's better in every way except having the all-time best D on the other side of the ball. If you don't think the 15-20th best WR of all time belongs in the hall vote against him.

 

[Naughtymax]

Harrison has plenty of time to get in and that's why he's off my list. I'm OK with him in (should happen) and Bettis waiting another year.

 

[gvsulaker82]

Strahan
Shields
Brown
J. Johnson
Brooks
Haley

 

[Stomp]

Andre Reed
Eddie Debartolo
Jimmy Johnson
Joe Jacoby
Michael Strahan


And use the last vote to try and vote one of the many that don't belong out I'd start with Lynn Swann

 

[Wazmankg]

Walter Jones
Tagliabue
Marvin Harrison
Don Coryell
Steve Atwater
Will Shields

Forgot Strahan, so that's 7

 

[jayfan]

If I could only vote for 1 this year:

Andre Reed