POLL Poll: Which QB do you prefer Going into Next Season

[Fountain City Blues]

The following numbers are rate numbers over their careers so as to avoid tipping as much as possible:

Legitimately curious about this one

QB A:

62.4% Completion

7.1 YPA

7.3 AY/A

6.12 ANY/A

91.2 Passer Rating

4.0 TD%

1.4 INT%

Age: 28

Sack %: 9.2

QB B:

61.3% Completion

6.5 YPA

6.6 AY/A

6.08 ANY/A

87.5 Passer rating

4.6 TD%

2.0 INT%

Age: 26

Sack %: 3.9

 

[Fountain City Blues]

Added a no preference option.

 

[FaCe-LeE-uS]

Hate voting based off stats when we all know there is a lot more to it. But I'll bite...

 

[Fountain City Blues]

Hate voting based off stats when we all know there is a lot more to it. But I'll bite...

There is one thing I intentionally left out in order to isolate something. You are correct. I encourage everyone to vote blind anyways, however.

 

[FaCe-LeE-uS]

There is one thing I intentionally left out in order to isolate something. You are correct. I encourage everyone to vote blind anyways, however.

Spoiler

Alex Smith (KC yrs) vs. Derek Carr

 

[Fountain City Blues]

Spoiler

Alex Smith (KC yrs) vs. Derek Carr

Spoiler: Spoiler

One is in the poll, the other is not.

 

[Ricky Roma]

Player B, and again...it ain't even close.

 

[FaCe-LeE-uS]

Spoiler: Spoiler

One is in the poll, the other is not.

Missed the age part...

 

[Clayton]

Spoiler

I'm going to guess Tyrod Taylor vs Derek Carr just because I've seen their stats enough

My answer is that they'd both be fine backup QBs. Player A's sack % is a huge issue although if you have a great team then he could be a solid game manager. I just dont think game managers are needed in todays nfl.

 

[FaCe-LeE-uS]

Spoiler

I'm going to guess Tyrod Taylor vs Derek Carr just because I've seen their stats enough

My answer is that they'd both be fine backup QBs. Player A's sack % is a huge issue although if you have a great team then he could be a solid game manager. I just dont think game managers are needed in todays nfl.

 

[SteelersPride]

Player B, and again...it ain't even close.

another one where u dont even know what ur talking about

 

[Fountain City Blues]

Missed the age part...

Just for fun though:

Spoiler: Spoilers on Spoilers

Alex Smith as a Chief

65.1 Completion
.
7.2 Y/A

7.5 AY/A

6.52 ANY/A

94.8 Passer Rating

4.2 TD%

1.4 INT%

Ages 29-33 seasons

7.3 Sack %

 

[Ricky Roma]

another one where u dont even know what ur talking about

Floor is yours....go ahead and educate us about these two players. You failed miserably to make any point in the other thread, so you can lose here too.

 

[SteelersPride]

Floor is yours....go ahead and educate us about these two players. You failed miserably to make any point in the other thread, so you can lose here too.

respond to my point, your claim is teams want a vick like player, yet there is no clamoring for lamar jackson..........you failed to respond, you just keep spewing things like hes athletic and is more of a thrower, which is false anyways.....its your MO, we all know it, we've all seen it time and time again, you deflect and spew crap..........i'll wait for u to tell me why there is no clamoring for jackson whose the closes thing to vick there has been.......since everyone wants a michael vick

 

[Ricky Roma]

respond to my point, your claim is teams want a vick like player, yet there is no clamoring for lamar jackson..........you failed to respond, you just keep spewing things like hes athletic and is more of a thrower, which is false anyways.....its your MO, we all know it, we've all seen it time and time again, you deflect and spew crap..........i'll wait for u to tell me why there is no clamoring for jackson whose the closes thing to vick there has been.......since everyone wants a michael vick

You are biblically fucking stupid. I've already made, and proven my point. What you babble about is irrelevant.

And congrats...by your own reasoning, given that you said nothing about Carr/Taylor in response, you admit that you 'spew crap and deflect.'

So again.....go ahead and educate us about these two players.

 

[SteelersPride]

You are biblically fucking stupid. I've already made, and proven my point. What you babble about is irrelevant.

And congrats...by your own reasoning, given that you said nothing about Carr/Taylor in response, you admit that you 'spew crap and deflect.'

So again.....go ahead and educate us about these two players.

your point was irrelevant dear god here you go again, you continue to deflect.

 

[SteelersPride]

@There is A Moose at 3rd party here, has ricky explained to us why teams clamor for a vick like qb, and made a good argument how vick and tyrod taylor are alike

 

[Ricky Roma]

your point was irrelevant dear god here you go again, you continue to deflect.

...'says' the talking turd who STILL can't back up his 'u dont even know what ur talking about' stupidity via Carr/Taylor. One last chance.....

Go ahead and educate us about these two players.

 

[SteelersPride]

...'says' the talking turd who STILL can't back up his 'u dont even know what ur talking about' stupidity via Carr/Taylor. One last chance.....

Go ahead and educate us about these two players.

dude, answer the original question, you still havent .........when you answer, maybe i will....

 

[Ricky Roma]

dude, answer the original question, you still havent .........when you answer, maybe i will....

Failed to back up your babble, and ran and sought backup like a little girl. You are no challenge.