Our First College Football Draft QF 1 UK vs Hall

[TheRobotDevil]

UK
OFFENSE
QB - Robert Griffin III - Baylor
RB - Billy Sims - Oklahoma
FB - Keith Byars - Ohio St.
WR - Tavon Austin - West Virginia
WR - Mike Hass - Oregon St.
WR - DeAndre Hopkins - Clemson
TE - Jason Witten - Tennessee
OT - Tony Boselli - USC
OG - Will Shields - Nebraska
C - Mark Stepnoski - Pittsburgh
OG - Steve Wisniewski - Penn St.
OT - Dean Steinkuhler - Nebraska

DEFENSE
DE - Reggie White - Tennessee
DT - Aaron Donald - Pittsburgh
DT - Tony Casillas - Oklahoma
DE - Steve Emtman - Washington
LB - Randy Gradishar - Ohio St.
LB - Rey Maualuga - USC
LB - Zach Thomas - Texas Tech
CB - Deion Sanders - Florida St
CB - Mel Renfro - Oregon
CB - Fred Smoot - Mississippi St.
SS - Taylor Mays - USC
FS - Tyrann Mathieu - LSU

VS

HALL
OFFENSE
QB - Charlie Ward - Florida St.
RB - Marcus Allen - USC
RB - Marshall Faulk - San Diego St.
WR - Randy Moss - Marshall
WR - Calvin Johnson - Georgia Tech
AP - Raghib Ismail - Notre Dame
TE - Kellen Winslow Sr. - Missouri
OT - Willie Roaf - Louisiana Tech
OG - Randall McDaniel - Arizona St.
OG/OT - Aaron Taylor - Notre Dame
OL - Dwight Stephenson - Alabama
OT - Michael Oher - Mississippi

DEFENSE
DE - Alan Page - Notre Dame
DT - Glenn Dorsey - LSU
DT - Rich Glover - Nebraska
DL - Ross Browner - Notre Dame
LB - Jack Ham - Penn St.
LB - Mike Singletary - Baylor
LB - George Webster - Michigan St.
CB - Dre Bly - North Carolina
CB - Dave Brown - Michigan
CB - Mike Haynes - Arizona St.
S - Eric Berry - Tennessee
S - Sean Taylor - Miami

 

[TheRobotDevil]

First to 6

UK - 6
Hall - 5

Voted - UK, Shane, Sushi, Femur, Devil, Hall, Meebs, Stakes, Ducey, Milk, Ritz

 

[UK Cowboy]

UK

 

[SteelersPride]

hall

 

[femurov]

UK

 

[CitySushi]

Super close again but I’m gonna lean UK

 

[UK Cowboy]

hall

If you want to vote you have to participate Bro

 

[Shanemansj13]

Very tough matchup. I lean UK

 

[TheRobotDevil]

UK

 

[Hall]

UK has some nice pieces on D, but overall his secondary would struggle with the amount of weapons Ward has at his disposal.

Voting Hall.

 

[Stakesarehigh]

Same thing as the last vote with UK. Super solid defense but I lean a little more towards O in college.

Going with Hall

 

[UK Cowboy]

UK has some nice pieces on D, but overall his secondary would struggle with the amount of weapons Ward has at his disposal.

Voting Hall.

You really see your secondary as stronger than mine?

 

[Hall]

Same thing as the last vote with UK. Super solid defense but I lean a little more towards O in college.

Going with Hall

I do too, but also like my defense better. But I recognize I probably have some underappreciated pieces.

 

[Hall]

You really see your secondary as stronger than mine?

Deion is obviously the best piece. But I like mine overall yes.

Both Safety's are better and our #2's are comparable. Brown was a boss in College and Eric and Sean Taylor's careers speak for themselves.

Mays has a great college career but hes not the type of safety that was gonna allow Tyrann to roam and make plays. Gonna get stretched deep by Moss, Rocket, and Mega.

 

[UK Cowboy]

Deion is obviously the best piece. But I like mine overall yes.

Both Safety's are better and our #2's are comparable. Brown was a boss in College and Eric and Sean Taylor's careers speak for themselves.

Mays has a great college career but hes not the type of safety that was gonna allow Tyrann to roam and make plays. Gonna get stretched deep by Moss, Rocket, and Mega.

If we are going off their college career Mays is as good as any safety in the draft. I think Charlie Ward was a good college QB but not a great fit with those WRs. Either way great team and good luck

 

[Hall]

Mays was a 4x AA but do you know one of those years was a Consensus AA and the other 3 were only voted by one or two outlets? Nothing to do with the school he played at? He's not in the same realm as Eric (2x Tatum, 1x Thorpe, 2x UNANIMOUS AA) and really not close to Sean Either and thats just from the eye test when they were in college let alone the accolades.

 

[Hall]

You did a good job drafting aswell man.

 

[UK Cowboy]

Mays was a 4x AA but do you know one of those years was a Consensus AA and the other 3 were only voted by one or two outlets? Nothing to do with the school he played at? He's not in the same realm as Eric (2x Tatum, 1x Thorpe, 2x UNANIMOUS AA) and really not close to Sean Either and thats just from the eye test when they were in college let alone the accolades.

Couldn't disagree more. Deion at FSU was the undisputed GOAT cover corner of all time. The fact that he could Cover one of your WRs with no help would free up Mays to double the other side. Also, Deion, Renfro and Mays have all been clocked 4.3 or better. Honey Badger was a great college player and Smoot was an AA as well. I also think I have arguably the best DL in the draft to compliment it

 

[Nosferatu]

Couldn't disagree more. Deion at FSU was the undisputed GOAT cover corner of all time. The fact that he could Cover one of your WRs with no help would free up Mays to double the other side. Also, Deion, Renfro and Mays have all been clocked 4.3 or better. Honey Badger was a great college player and Smoot was an AA as well. I also think I have arguably the best DL in the draft to compliment it

I loved this pick.

DE - Steve Emtman - Washington

 

[Shanemansj13]

If we are going off their college career Mays is as good as any safety in the draft. I think Charlie Ward was a good college QB but not a great fit with those WRs. Either way great team and good luck

Yeah kinda my line of thinking, I didnt get the Ward pick when you have two Big deep threats. Ward was a good passer but I also wouldnt be much of a threat for airing it deep, at least with much accuracy