keeping a catcher

[MilkSpiller22]

we keep 10 players

we start C,C,1B,2B,3B,SS,CI,MI,5OF,DH, 9pitchers= 23 players

we have no bench, but unlimited DL...

we do an auction with a 260 dollar budget... standard 5X5 Rotisserie league... 12 team league



Would you keep either Brian McCann at 11 units or Evan Gattis at 15 units,

which of the 2 would you rather keep if you would keep either??

remember that it is a 2 Catcher league...

 

[TKOSpikes]

Yeah, I would keep them both at those prices. They should get more ab's than a regular catcher. Power is there and so should rbi. Depending on who you're throwing back of course. But I see them as top 10 options at the C spot.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Yeah, I would keep them both at those prices. They should get more ab's than a regular catcher. Power is there and so should rbi. Depending on who you're throwing back of course. But I see them as top 10 options at the C spot.

I own McCann, but I don't own Gattis... But I am thinking about making a trade for Gattis... Debating on whether it is worth it or not...

I plan on only keeping one catcher(especially if they both are 10 units or more)... Just thinking who I would rather keep, as I know I could get Gattis from the owner who has him...

 

[obxyankeefan]

Didn't Atlanta trade Gattis? I would have to think about the stadium of where he got traded and what the lineup is around him.

I would keep McCann.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Didn't Atlanta trade Gattis? I would have to think about the stadium of where he got traded and what the lineup is around him.

I would keep McCann.

He went to Houston, and will likely be the left fielder- which means more playing time and less wear and tear...

 

[Chef99]

He went to Houston, and will likely be the left fielder- which means more playing time and less wear and tear...

If you can live with the strikeouts, Gattis is gonna hit some monster HRs in that matchbox. They are building a lineup over there in Houston.

 

[obxyankeefan]

If you can live with the strikeouts, Gattis is gonna hit some monster HRs in that matchbox. They are building a lineup over there in Houston.

 

[Chef99]

Milk, did you ever make that trade for Gattis? Man, I would be all over that.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Milk, did you ever make that trade for Gattis? Man, I would be all over that.

not yet...pre season trading window doesn't open yet... Just preplanning my plans...

 

[TREFF]

What are your rules on eligibility? Sounds like Gattis, who should already have C/OF eligibility is also going to be manning 1st base this season. Granted he's not as valuable at either OF or 1B, but the flexibility comes in handy when needed and definitely ads to his value. In a 2 C league, I'd be stoked to have them both