Jimmy G or Cam Newton This year Only

[redseat]

WEEI is talking with Michael Irving and the question was asked, "For THIS YEAR, who would you rather have at QB? Cam Newton or Jimmy G"

Now I got back home before I heard Irving's answer (dude takes forever to answer a question)

So what say you?

(Assuming both were healthy)

 

[redseat]

@Carnzo
@BigKen
@NWPATSFAN
@nefansince75
@NEhomer

 

[NEhomer]

I'd take Ryan Leaf over this asshole we're stuck with but hell yes, I'd have preferred to keep Jimmy~

 

[Carnzo]

Tough one but between the two I'll go with Cam.
He looked lousy last week but the running ability puts him on top.

 

[YankeeRebel]

@Carnzo
@BigKen
@NWPATSFAN
@nefansince75
@NEhomer

Seeing as I was not invited i'll go with Jared Lorenzo

 

[Debbie Does]

Jimmy G. was trained in the Patriot system, and would have continued learning and probably would have done well. Cam Neutron is not a disciplined QB and doesn't belong in a disciplined system.

Add a Brady option. Yeah, for this year, Brady may still be the best of the three. But, his string is at an end, and whoever he plays for needs to look for a franchise quarterback ASAP.

 

[redseat]

Seeing as I was not invited i'll go with Jared Lorenzo

Haha. I suck at remembering peoples names on here.

 

[Carnzo]

Hey @sonnyblack65 what do you think?

 

[Hank Kingsley]

Tough one but between the two I'll go with Cam.
He looked lousy last week but the running ability puts him on top.

I agree.

Being trained in the Patriots system only means the one in place at that time. Cam is in a new system.

I think if Garoppolo was there this year he'd be fucked like Brady was last year.

They have nothing to work with and at least Cam can run.

 

[YankeeRebel]

Haha. I suck at remembering peoples names on here.

Which is why our team currently has Lorenzo as our QB.

 

[YankeeRebel]

I agree.

Being trained in the Patriots system only means the one in place at that time. Cam is in a new system.

I think if Garoppolo was there this year he'd be fucked like Brady was last year.

They have nothing to work with and at least Cam can run.

Which is a once time fix not sure that is the solution. Jimmy G looked good in NE but could they have kept him with our prior cap issues?

 

[Hank Kingsley]

Which is a once time fix not sure that is the solution. Jimmy G looked good in NE but could they have kept him with our prior cap issues?

If they had found a way to keep him, he's still have nothing to work with today. Almost less than sweet fuck all.

The whole trade was a piss party anyway.

I also think Brady was destined to leave ASAP after the Butler SB fiasco. But JG was already gone.

I might be more inclined to try Ryan or a Rosen project over Garoppolo coming back.

 

[YankeeRebel]

If they had found a way to keep him, he's still have nothing to work with today. Almost less than sweet fuck all.

The whole trade was a piss party anyway.

I also think Brady was destined to leave ASAP after the Butler SB fiasco. But JG was already gone.

I might be more inclined to try Ryan or a Rosen project over Garoppolo coming back.

I thought Jimmy G looked good when he played here, and is also a very mobile QB that offers touch and accuracy over Cam IMO.

Butler fucked himself and TB should know that, you cannot go out get drunk and show up late not any team in this era would that be okay.

 

[Hank Kingsley]

Garopollo doesn't look that frisky this year and he too has had a fucked knee.

Accuracy doesn't matter if you have nobody to throw to.

I've never heard what Butler did, had to be heinous because it cost them that game. Just needed one play from him.

 

[YankeeRebel]

Garopollo doesn't look that frisky this year and he too has had a fucked knee.

Accuracy doesn't matter if you have nobody to throw to.

I've never heard what Butler did, had to be heinous because it cost them that game. Just needed one play from him.

Ohh I think any WR is more apt to catch a well thrown ball bx one that is off target or lacks any real touch.
My understanding of the Butler incident was as I explained it.

 

[Hank Kingsley]

Ohh I think any WR is more apt to catch a well thrown ball bx one that is off target or lacks any real touch.
My understanding of the Butler incident was as I explained it.

No argument. They still have nothing though.

Harry is a huge disappointment.

I wouldn't waste my time bringing in a big $ QB.

 

[YankeeRebel]

No argument. They still have nothing though.

Harry is a huge disappointment.

I wouldn't waste my time bringing in a big $ QB.

Yeah BB needs to stop drafting WRs.

I think we should go to a 4 TE set with one pass catching RB, he does pretty good with drafting TEs

 

[sonnyblack65]

Hey @sonnyblack65 what do you think?

Tough one Carnzo , but for just this year, I think Cam is the better of 2 evils because of his mobility and rushing tds. Let's see what Belichick thinks, obviously he likes Kittles over Gronk for TE

Rob Ninkovich believes Bill Belichick took shot at Rob Gronkowski with George Kittle praise

Did Bill Belichick take a shot at Rob Gronkowski with his praise for 49ers tight end George Kittle? Rob Ninkovich thinks so.

sports.yahoo.com

 

[Hank Kingsley]

Yeah BB needs to stop drafting WRs.

I think we should go to a 4 TE set with one pass catching RB, he does pretty good with drafting TEs

That might actually give the QB time to look downfield...

I thought Malcolm Mitchell was a great pick, but sadly his knee became an issue.

 

[YankeeRebel]

That might actually give the QB time to look downfield...

I thought Malcolm Mitchell was a great pick, but sadly his knee became an issue.

MM Did have potential.