Is Miguel Cabrera the best hitter ever

[TrustMeIamRight]

Miguel Cabrera

He has a legitimate chance at winning back to back Triple Crowns. There isn't a player in the same ballpark at the plate as Cabrera right now.

He hits the ball to all fields, hits for power to all fields, hits for average and has an unbelievable eye at the plate. The crazy thing is -- he actually looks better in 2013 than he did in 2012 and he JUST turned 30.

The sky is the limit for this guy and I am sure glad he is on the Tigers.

 

[bravesfan]

He's the best hitter in baseball right now

 

[romeo212000]

Dude has a chance to be one of the best there ever was.

 

[powerchord86]

He's good. And stuff..

 

[tygerphan4ever]

I beg of you not to smash me for this, but dammit, this is just one of the most wicked, cruel, and vicious people I've ever seen. If Miggy's not the best, then who is??

signed-- clueless Tiger fan.

 

[Nosferatu]

IMO he is the best hitter on the planet right now, of all time? No


Signed Twins fan

 

[tygerphan4ever]

IMO he is the best hitter on the planet right now, of all time? No


Signed Twins fan

Gotcha.. thank you, sir.

 

[obxyankeefan]

I beg of you not to smash me for this, but dammit, this is just one of the most wicked, cruel, and vicious people I've ever seen. If Miggy's not the best, then who is??

signed-- clueless Tiger fan.

Other players that might dispute this by team:

Baltimore/ St.louis Browns George Sisler
Boston Ted Williams Jimmie Foxx
New York Babe Ruth Lou Gehrig Joe DiMaggio Mickey Mantle
Chicago Frank Thomas Joe Jackson
Detroit Ty Cobb Hank Greenberg
Kansas City George Brett
Minnesota Rod Carew
Oakland Nap Lajoie
Seattle Ichiro
Atlanta Hank Aaron
Chicago Ernie Banks Cap Anson
Cincinnati Pete Rose
Pittsburgh Roberto Clemente Honus Wagner Lloyd Waner Arky Vaughn
St. Louis Albert Pujols Stan Musial Rogers Hornsby
San Diego Tony Gwynn
San Francisco Willie Mays Barry Bonds



Not saying that all these players are better then Miggy, but they are all up there.

 

[RoboticDreams]

I beg of you not to smash me for this, but dammit, this is just one of the most wicked, cruel, and vicious people I've ever seen. If Miggy's not the best, then who is??

signed-- clueless Tiger fan.

You're a fraud. I want everyone hear to know that. I hated people like you at ESpin, that had multiple member names and would talk to themselves and like their own comments.

I hope you get found out and banned.

 

[steveringo]

He just turned 30... Let's give him some room.... Obviously, if he keeps it up, he'll be considered among the above mentioned greats....

I love his bbr similarity scores: through age 29 - Frank Robinson, Hank Aaron, Ken Griffey, Albert Pujols, Mel Ott, Juan Gonzalez, Al Kaline, Duke Snider, Mickey Mantle....

 

[Shanemansj13]

Ty Cobb .366
Ted Williams .344
Tony Gwynn .338
Stan Musial .330
Joe Dimaggio .324

Power+Avg

Lou Gehrig .340
Babe Ruth .342
Jimmie Foxx .325

Current Players

Joe Mauer .322
Albert Pujols .321
Miguel Cabrera .321

Just a few names. It is hard to say. But Miguel is easily the best right now by far.

 

[tygerphan4ever]

You're a fraud. I want everyone hear to know that. I hated people like you at ESpin, that had multiple member names and would talk to themselves and like their own comments.

I hope you get found out and banned.

Don't you talk to me like that. This has always been my name, so don't you get smart with me-- YOU FAT WHORE!!

 

[tygerphan4ever]

Other players that might dispute this by team:

Baltimore/ St.louis Browns George Sisler
Boston Ted Williams Jimmie Foxx
New York Babe Ruth Lou Gehrig Joe DiMaggio Mickey Mantle
Chicago Frank Thomas Joe Jackson
Detroit Ty Cobb Hank Greenberg
Kansas City George Brett
Minnesota Rod Carew
Oakland Nap Lajoie
Seattle Ichiro
Atlanta Hank Aaron
Chicago Ernie Banks Cap Anson
Cincinnati Pete Rose
Pittsburgh Roberto Clemente Honus Wagner Lloyd Waner Arky Vaughn
St. Louis Albert Pujols Stan Musial Rogers Hornsby
San Diego Tony Gwynn
San Francisco Willie Mays Barry Bonds



Not saying that all these players are better then Miggy, but they are all up there.

 

[Shanemansj13]

If I had to pick one. I would go with Lou Gehrig

 

[Chef99]

Other players that might dispute this by team:

Baltimore/ St.louis Browns George Sisler
Boston Ted Williams Jimmie Foxx
New York Babe Ruth Lou Gehrig Joe DiMaggio Mickey Mantle
Chicago Frank Thomas Joe Jackson
Detroit Ty Cobb Hank Greenberg
Kansas City George Brett
Minnesota Rod Carew
Oakland Nap Lajoie
Seattle Ichiro
Atlanta Hank Aaron
Chicago Ernie Banks Cap Anson
Cincinnati Pete Rose
Pittsburgh Roberto Clemente Honus Wagner Lloyd Waner Arky Vaughn
St. Louis Albert Pujols Stan Musial Rogers Hornsby
San Diego Tony Gwynn
San Francisco Willie Mays Barry Bonds



Not saying that all these players are better then Miggy, but they are all up there.

Ty Cobb .366
Ted Williams .344
Tony Gwynn .338
Stan Musial .330
Joe Dimaggio .324

Power+Avg

Lou Gehrig .340
Babe Ruth .342
Jimmie Foxx .325

Current Players

Joe Mauer .322
Albert Pujols .321
Miguel Cabrera .321

Just a few names. It is hard to say. But Miguel is easily the best right now by far.

Nice lists. I think you two have pretty much covered the bases.

 

[RoboticDreams]

You're a fraud. I want everyone here to know that. I hated people like you at ESpin, that had multiple member names and would talk to themselves and like their own comments.

I hope you get found out and banned.

Don't you talk to me like that. This has always been my name, so don't you get smart with me-- YOU FAT WHORE!!

Now that's a little better trolling. Are you trying to sound gay or are you just a fag?

Possibly a woman?

 

[tygerphan4ever]

Can I tell you what I think, without you beaging the livin hrll outta me?? I say like this

Tyrud Cobb
Babe Ruth
Louis Gehrig
Rogers Hornsby
Henry Aaron
Miguel Cabrera

 

[geneh_33]

Now that's a little better trolling. Are you trying to sound gay or are you just a fag?

Possibly a woman?

Are you kidding? This person is laughable. Please.

 

[geneh_33]

Can I tell you what I think, without you beaging the livin hrll outta me?? I say like this

Tyrud Cobb
Babe Ruth
Louis Gehrig
Rogers Hornsby
Henry Aaron
Miguel Cabrera

You post like one of those idiots over on Sports lolz

 

[RoboticDreams]

Are you kidding? This person is laughable. Please.

Yeah, you should look at all of his/her/it's posts. It's disgusting and makes me nauseous.