• Have something to say? Register Now! and be posting in minutes!

In honor of the World Cup going on right now, let's play a game of What-If...............The College Football Cup

EvilMonkeyInTheCloset

Active Member
188
134
43
Joined
May 24, 2026
Location
Iowa
Hoopla Cash
$ 1,000.00
Fav. Team #1
Fav. Team #2
Fav. Team #3
Since it's World Cup time in the United States, I'm gonna pose a What-If where CFB's national champion was decided by a World Cup style tournament, as opposed to the current mess of a system we have now. So first thing is first. Lettuce go over the ground rules for the season, the postseason, and then we'll unveil the new conference layout.

****Assume everything is starting with a fresh slate for the upcoming 2026 season and the college athletics powers that be, and their families, were forced at gunpoint to make these changes..............and they actually caved in and did the right thing for all of college athletics and agreed to these changes!!! ........................................here's how it would look:


2026-27 College Football Season-
- 11 game seasons with Week 1 starting the last week of August (8/29 this year); this year's regular season would run 12 weeks from 8/29 to 11/14

- Week 0 would now be a week earlier (8/22/26); no more than FOUR games to be played by Major conferences, no more than THREE games by Mid-Major conferences. All games must be neutral non-conference matchups

- There will now be 8 "power" conferences, now considered to be Major conferences, or more affectionately known as the "Big 8". There will be 6 Mid-Major conferences referred to as the "G6".

- The 8 Major conferences will be comprised of either 9 or 10 teams. The G6 conferences will vary in size from 9-12 based on regionality and conference fit.

- Schools will either play 8 or 9 conference games depending on the conference size, with the ultimate goal being to play every other team in the conference (with much fewer exceptions)

- For Major conference schools, they must schedule at least ONE other "Big 8" school in their non-conference every year (this will help to preserve non-conference rivalries)

- No more conference championship games, with the one exception being CUSA. The Army-Navy game will also take place on this Saturday (which would be 11/21 for the 2026 season)

- Every team will have one BYE week factored into their schedules. The week of the CUSA championship game and the Army-Navy game will serve as a BYE week between the regular season and postseason for all other teams

(Postseason):
- Under the World Cup format, 48 teams will qualify for this new postseason tournament

- All 14 conference champions automatically qualify; 34 other at-large bids will be determined based on a number of qualifiers and tiebreakers

- There will be 12 groups of 4 teams, paired randomly after the qualifying teams are divided into 4 tiers of 12. The top 12 teams (Tier 1) from the regular season will all be separated into their own pods/groups. There will also be ONE Tier 2, 3 and 4 team in each Group as well.

- Group Stage play will run for the next 3 weeks, from Black Friday (11/27/26) to mid-December (12/12/26).
.....- In this round robin format, each team will play 3 games within their Group
.....- The top 3 teams based on their tier rankings will host all teams in a given week once
.....- The intent is meant to allow teams the opportunity to host a postseason contest for that 12th game revenue that would otherwise be lost due to the reduction of games/weeks in the regular season, but also give incentive to teams EARNING the right to host a Group Stage game
.....- This also means the top 3 teams will play one home game, and 2 neutral games, while the Tier 4 team will have to play three road games
.....(Ex: Week 1- Team 4 at Team 1, Team 2 vs Team 3; Week 2- Team 4 at Team 2, Team 1 vs Team 3; Team 4 at Team 3, Team 1 vs Team 2)
.....- A win in Group Stage is worth 3 pts. A loss is (obviously) worth 0 pts. Any game that goes to Overtime automatically guarantees both teams at least 1 pt
.....- The top two teams in each group based on points, and various tiebreakers if needed, will advance to the 24-team Knockout Stage

- Knockout Stage play will begin the following week with eight Round of 24/First Round games (this year Thurs, 12/17 - Sat, 12/19)
.....- Knockout Stage is a straightforward 24-team single elimination playoff. No host games for this tournament.
.....- Top 8 teams based on tiebreakers will receive a bye into the Round of 16/Second Round
.....- Knockout Stage dates and venues:
.....- Round of 24 (Thurs, 12/17/26 - Sat, 12/19/26); Gator Bowl, ReliaQuest Bowl, Music City Bowl, Texas Bowl
.....- Round of 16 (Thurs, 12/24/26 - Sat, 12/26/26); Citrus Bowl, Alamo Bowl, Holiday Bowl (now at Levi Stadium in San Francisco), Las Vegas Bowl
.....- Quarterfinals (Fri, 1/1/27*), Rest week to follow; Rose Bowl, Cotton Bowl, Fiesta Bowl, Peach Bowl
.....- Semifinals (Sat, 1/16/27); Sugar Bowl, Orange Bowl
.....- NCG Cup Finals (Sat, 1/23/27); Las Vegas, NV in 2027

- The First and Second Rounds of the Knockout Stage will be played at four bowl game venues each week, hosting two playoff games over the course of that weekend, instead of just the one. This also allows for a few more bowl games for the teams that did not qualify for the Group Stage of the College Football Cup. (Ex: 9 Alabama vs 24 TCU / 16 South Florida vs 17 Boise State, both at the Gator Bowl that week), (1 Oregon vs 16 South Florida / 8 BYU vs 9 Alabama, both at the Holiday Bowl that week)

- Speaking of bowl games, minor bowls will still be played for non-Cup qualifying teams with bowl eligibility still at 6 wins, as that would now mean you finished your regular season ABOVE .500
 

EvilMonkeyInTheCloset

Active Member
188
134
43
Joined
May 24, 2026
Location
Iowa
Hoopla Cash
$ 1,000.00
Fav. Team #1
Fav. Team #2
Fav. Team #3
Now let's meet the new conference layout under this College Football Cup proposal:

Major Conferences (“the Big 8”)-

ACC-

Maryland
West Virginia
Virginia
Virginia Tech
East Carolina
North Carolina
North Carolina State
Duke
Wake Forest

South Atlantic Conference-
South Carolina
Clemson
Georgia
Georgia Tech
Florida
Florida State
Miami
UCF
USF

Big East-
Boston College
Connecticut
Syracuse
Penn State
Pittsburgh
Rutgers
Cincinnati
Louisville
Notre Dame

Big Ten-
Ohio State
Michigan
Michigan State
Indiana
Purdue
Illinois
Northwestern
Wisconsin
Minnesota
Iowa

Gateway Conference-
Iowa State
Missouri
Nebraska
Kansas
Kansas State
Oklahoma
Oklahoma State
Colorado
Utah
BYU

SEC-
Alabama
Auburn
Mississippi
Mississippi State
Kentucky
Tennessee
Vanderbilt
Memphis
Arkansas
LSU

SWC-
Texas
Texas A&M
Texas Tech
Texas Christian
Baylor
Houston
SMU
New Mexico
Arizona
Arizona State

Pac 10-
Boise State
Washington
Washington State
Oregon
Oregon State
California
Stanford
UCLA
USC
UNLV

Mid-Major Conferences (“G6”)-

AAC-

Massachusetts
Buffalo
Delaware
Army
Navy
Temple
James Madison
Liberty
Old Dominion
Marshall

CUSA-
(North)

Appalachian State
Charlotte
Coastal Carolina
Georgia Southern
Georgia State
Kennesaw State

(South)
Florida Atlantic
Florida International
Jacksonville State
UAB
South Alabama
Troy

MAC-
Ohio
Akron
Bowling Green
Kent State
Miami, OH
Toledo
Ball State
Central Michigan
Eastern Michigan
Western Michigan

Mississippi River Athletic Conference-
Northern Illinois
North Dakota State
Missouri State
Middle Tennessee State
Western Kentucky
Tulsa
Arkansas State
Southern Mississippi
Tulane

MWC-
Hawaii
Fresno State
San Diego State
San Jose State
Sacramento State
Nevada
Utah State
New Mexico State
Wyoming
Air Force
Colorado State

Sun Belt-
UL-Lafayette
UL-Monroe
Louisiana Tech
North Texas
Rice
Sam Houston State
Texas State
UTEP
UTSA


*also the G6 conferences would be subject to change and break into more conferences if other FCS schools continue to jump up to the FBS level
 

EvilMonkeyInTheCloset

Active Member
188
134
43
Joined
May 24, 2026
Location
Iowa
Hoopla Cash
$ 1,000.00
Fav. Team #1
Fav. Team #2
Fav. Team #3
Here's what a Group Stage pairing would hypothetically look like using last year's standings as a guide:

Group A-
1Indiana*
Michigan
SMU
New Mexico

Group B-
8Alabama*
Texas
Washington
East Carolina

Group C-
11Notre Dame*
Iowa
North Texas*
Arizona State

Group D-
10Miami
Georgia Tech
South Florida
TCU

Group E-
9Texas A&M
Utah
Western Michigan*
Minnesota

Group F-
7Oklahoma*
Duke*
Illinois
Old Dominion

Group G-
12BYU
Vanderbilt
San Diego State*
Louisville

Group H-
3Georgia*
Tulane*
James Madison*
North Carolina State

Group I-
5Mississippi
USC
Pittsburgh
Iowa State

Group J-
4Texas Tech*
Virginia
Boise State
Jacksonville State

Group K-
6Oregon*
Houston
UNLV
Tennessee

Group L-
2Ohio State
Arizona
Kennesaw State*
Missouri



*-denotes hypothetical conference champion using the conferences listed in the previous post
 

wazzu31

Never go full Husky
31,726
10,176
1,033
Joined
Apr 26, 2013
Location
Sumner
Hoopla Cash
$ 1,000.00
Fav. Team #1
Fav. Team #2
Fav. Team #3
Instead, the losers of the playoffs should go just dominate the World Cup. The average SEC football team would qualify for the World Cup
 

Jennerpeach

Active Member
75
127
33
Joined
Jun 2, 2026
Location
Georgia
Hoopla Cash
$ 1,000.00
Fav. Team #1
Fav. Team #2
Fav. Team #3
Since it's World Cup time in the United States, I'm gonna pose a What-If where CFB's national champion was decided by a World Cup style tournament, as opposed to the current mess of a system we have now. So first thing is first. Lettuce go over the ground rules for the season, the postseason, and then we'll unveil the new conference layout.

****Assume everything is starting with a fresh slate for the upcoming 2026 season and the college athletics powers that be, and their families, were forced at gunpoint to make these changes..............and they actually caved in and did the right thing for all of college athletics and agreed to these changes!!! ........................................here's how it would look:


2026-27 College Football Season-
- 11 game seasons with Week 1 starting the last week of August (8/29 this year); this year's regular season would run 12 weeks from 8/29 to 11/14

- Week 0 would now be a week earlier (8/22/26); no more than FOUR games to be played by Major conferences, no more than THREE games by Mid-Major conferences. All games must be neutral non-conference matchups

- There will now be 8 "power" conferences, now considered to be Major conferences, or more affectionately known as the "Big 8". There will be 6 Mid-Major conferences referred to as the "G6".

- The 8 Major conferences will be comprised of either 9 or 10 teams. The G6 conferences will vary in size from 9-12 based on regionality and conference fit.

- Schools will either play 8 or 9 conference games depending on the conference size, with the ultimate goal being to play every other team in the conference (with much fewer exceptions)

- For Major conference schools, they must schedule at least ONE other "Big 8" school in their non-conference every year (this will help to preserve non-conference rivalries)

- No more conference championship games, with the one exception being CUSA. The Army-Navy game will also take place on this Saturday (which would be 11/21 for the 2026 season)

- Every team will have one BYE week factored into their schedules. The week of the CUSA championship game and the Army-Navy game will serve as a BYE week between the regular season and postseason for all other teams

(Postseason):
- Under the World Cup format, 48 teams will qualify for this new postseason tournament

- All 14 conference champions automatically qualify; 34 other at-large bids will be determined based on a number of qualifiers and tiebreakers

- There will be 12 groups of 4 teams, paired randomly after the qualifying teams are divided into 4 tiers of 12. The top 12 teams (Tier 1) from the regular season will all be separated into their own pods/groups. There will also be ONE Tier 2, 3 and 4 team in each Group as well.

- Group Stage play will run for the next 3 weeks, from Black Friday (11/27/26) to mid-December (12/12/26).
.....- In this round robin format, each team will play 3 games within their Group
.....- The top 3 teams based on their tier rankings will host all teams in a given week once
.....- The intent is meant to allow teams the opportunity to host a postseason contest for that 12th game revenue that would otherwise be lost due to the reduction of games/weeks in the regular season, but also give incentive to teams EARNING the right to host a Group Stage game
.....- This also means the top 3 teams will play one home game, and 2 neutral games, while the Tier 4 team will have to play three road games
.....(Ex: Week 1- Team 4 at Team 1, Team 2 vs Team 3; Week 2- Team 4 at Team 2, Team 1 vs Team 3; Team 4 at Team 3, Team 1 vs Team 2)
.....- A win in Group Stage is worth 3 pts. A loss is (obviously) worth 0 pts. Any game that goes to Overtime automatically guarantees both teams at least 1 pt
.....- The top two teams in each group based on points, and various tiebreakers if needed, will advance to the 24-team Knockout Stage

- Knockout Stage play will begin the following week with eight Round of 24/First Round games (this year Thurs, 12/17 - Sat, 12/19)
.....- Knockout Stage is a straightforward 24-team single elimination playoff. No host games for this tournament.
.....- Top 8 teams based on tiebreakers will receive a bye into the Round of 16/Second Round
.....- Knockout Stage dates and venues:
.....- Round of 24 (Thurs, 12/17/26 - Sat, 12/19/26); Gator Bowl, ReliaQuest Bowl, Music City Bowl, Texas Bowl
.....- Round of 16 (Thurs, 12/24/26 - Sat, 12/26/26); Citrus Bowl, Alamo Bowl, Holiday Bowl (now at Levi Stadium in San Francisco), Las Vegas Bowl
.....- Quarterfinals (Fri, 1/1/27*), Rest week to follow; Rose Bowl, Cotton Bowl, Fiesta Bowl, Peach Bowl
.....- Semifinals (Sat, 1/16/27); Sugar Bowl, Orange Bowl
.....- NCG Cup Finals (Sat, 1/23/27); Las Vegas, NV in 2027

- The First and Second Rounds of the Knockout Stage will be played at four bowl game venues each week, hosting two playoff games over the course of that weekend, instead of just the one. This also allows for a few more bowl games for the teams that did not qualify for the Group Stage of the College Football Cup. (Ex: 9 Alabama vs 24 TCU / 16 South Florida vs 17 Boise State, both at the Gator Bowl that week), (1 Oregon vs 16 South Florida / 8 BYU vs 9 Alabama, both at the Holiday Bowl that week)

- Speaking of bowl games, minor bowls will still be played for non-Cup qualifying teams with bowl eligibility still at 6 wins, as that would now mean you finished your regular season ABOVE .500
Are you going to have the CFB challenge this year?
 

EvilMonkeyInTheCloset

Active Member
188
134
43
Joined
May 24, 2026
Location
Iowa
Hoopla Cash
$ 1,000.00
Fav. Team #1
Fav. Team #2
Fav. Team #3
@EvilMonkeyInTheCloset .... .......well are ya?
Winona Ryder Movie GIF by filmeditor
 

Duckboy33

Well-Known Member
2,680
1,136
173
Joined
Oct 8, 2016
Hoopla Cash
$ 3,284.76
Fav. Team #1
Fav. Team #2
Fav. Team #3
Ok then, let's play out group play with WhatIf spots:

Group A:
Indiana 14 Michigan 7
SMU 23 New Mexico 17

Indiana 45 SMU 31
Michigan 34 New Mexico 18

Michigan 44 SMU 38
Indiana 59 New Mexico 17

Indiana wins the group. Michigan advances. New Mexico is eliminated.

SMU score differential is -14
 
Last edited:

Duckboy33

Well-Known Member
2,680
1,136
173
Joined
Oct 8, 2016
Hoopla Cash
$ 3,284.76
Fav. Team #1
Fav. Team #2
Fav. Team #3
Group B:

Alabama 27 Texas 10
ECU 41 Washington 16

Alabama 34 ECU 31
Washington 37 Texas 35

Washington 21 Alabama 20
Texas 39 ECU 3

Washington wins the group. Alabama advances. ECU is eliminated.

Texas score differential is +17
 

Duckboy33

Well-Known Member
2,680
1,136
173
Joined
Oct 8, 2016
Hoopla Cash
$ 3,284.76
Fav. Team #1
Fav. Team #2
Fav. Team #3
Group C:

Notre Dame 34 Iowa 23
Arizona State 31 North Texas 29

Notre Dame 55 North Texas 34
Arizona State 34 Iowa 20

Notre Dame 41 Arizona State 34
North Texas 48 Iowa 17

Notre Dame wins the group. Arizona State advances. Iowa is eliminated.

North Texas score differential is +8
 

Duckboy33

Well-Known Member
2,680
1,136
173
Joined
Oct 8, 2016
Hoopla Cash
$ 3,284.76
Fav. Team #1
Fav. Team #2
Fav. Team #3
Group D:

Miami FL 44 Georgia Tech 38
USF 31 TCU 13

USF 25 Miami FL 24
Georgia Tech 51 TCU 13

TCU 72 Miami FL 36
Georgia Tech 32 USF 28

Georgia Tech wins the group. USF advances. Miami FL is eliminated.

TCU score differential is -20
 

EvilMonkeyInTheCloset

Active Member
188
134
43
Joined
May 24, 2026
Location
Iowa
Hoopla Cash
$ 1,000.00
Fav. Team #1
Fav. Team #2
Fav. Team #3
Group C:

Notre Dame 34 Iowa 23
Arizona State 31 North Texas 29

Notre Dame 55 North Texas 34
Arizona State 34 Iowa 20

Notre Dame 41 Arizona State 34
North Texas 48 Iowa 17

Notre Dame wins the group. Arizona State advances. Iowa is eliminated.

North Texas score differential is +8
Try again please.
 

Wamu

whats-a-matta-u?
82,283
48,958
1,033
Joined
Jul 14, 2014
Location
Colorado
Hoopla Cash
$ 420.04
Fav. Team #1
Fav. Team #2
Fav. Team #3
Group C:

Notre Dame 34 Iowa 23
Arizona State 31 North Texas 29

Notre Dame 55 North Texas 34
Arizona State 34 Iowa 20

Notre Dame 41 Arizona State 34
North Texas 48 Iowa 17 <---------------------:laugh3:

Notre Dame wins the group. Arizona State advances. Iowa is eliminated.

North Texas score differential is +8

:laugh3:
 
Top