If Big Ben, Brady & Dalton all retired at the same time

[mrschaney]

and Dak won a playoff game. Something the soulless ginger has never done. Luckily the Bengals are almost done with him and maybe you can make some improvements.

Is that all that matters, winning one playoff game?
Even Tebow had done that, and where is he now, hosting some game show!
More to greatness than winning 1 playoff game.

 

[Mangler]

If Big Ben, Brady, & Dalton all retired at the same time


No one would miss Dalton.

 

[mrschaney]

Hall of Fame, class of 20??

 

[Wamu]

Is that all that matters, winning one playoff game?
Even Tebow had done that, and where is he now, hosting some game show!
More to greatness than winning 1 playoff game.

"more to greatness than winning 1 playoff game"


You truly don't understand that Dalton has never won a playoff game do you?

 

[Wamu]

If Big Ben, Brady, & Dalton all retired at the same time


No one would miss Dalton.

That's not true. mrschaney will miss Dalton.

 

[mrschaney]

Where is Steeler's Pride?
At least he tries to put up educated arguments. He doesn't have much luck, but the kid tries.

 

[Guy Incognito]

OK, who supplied MrsChaney with the Philadelphia Horse Shit?

Hey, don't be trying to upgrade Skyline Chili to the level of horse shit.

 

[Psych-Ward]

 

[mrschaney]

"more to greatness than winning 1 playoff game"


You truly don't understand that Dalton has never won a playoff game do you?

That hasn't always been his fault. One year, he was basically the only starter left playing, he had all backup receivers. One year against the Steelers, he lost due to poor officiating. There really should be an * next to his playoff record.

 

[mrschaney]

Sonny Jurgensen was orders of magnitude better than Dalton. He's the greatest ginger QB.

Thanks for proving my point...............Dalton has better stats than Sonny, and Sonny is in the Hall of fame, what?
what?

 

[mrschaney]

Maybe the real question here is, should the NFL be looking at add an asterisks next to Andy Dalton's name where his playoff won-loss record is concerned? Due to injuries of teammates, poor officiating, collusion, etc. I think this is something that should be looked into by Roger.

 

[Shanemansj13]

Is that all that matters, winning one playoff game?
Even Tebow had done that, and where is he now, hosting some game show!
More to greatness than winning 1 playoff game.

Fun fact for ya. Winning matters...well maybe not in Cincy if they are going to keep Dalton lol

 

[Shanemansj13]

 

[mrschaney]

 

[night]

They would all be inducted into the Hall of Fame, first ballot.
FACT

Are you sure about Brady?

 

[mrschaney]

Jeremy Hill and Burfict maybe, but never RED ROCKET

 

[Wamu]

That hasn't always been his fault. One year, he was basically the only starter left playing, he had all backup receivers. One year against the Steelers, he lost due to poor officiating. There really should be an * next to his playoff record.

Oh so what you're saying is those losses weren't the QB's fault. Dalton shouldn't be blamed. Got it.

-injuries are never a valid excuse (come playoff time all teams are injured)
-blaming the officials (another lame excuse from you)

So that's 2 of his 4 losses. The other 2 games who's to blame? You sure have your cincinnati bungles Homer Goggles fastened to your head tightly.

 

[Shanemansj13]

What JJ thinks of the soul-less ging

 

[mrschaney]

Oh so what you're saying is those losses weren't the QB's fault. Dalton shouldn't be blamed. Got it.

-injuries are never a valid excuse (come playoff time all teams are injured)
-blaming the officials (another lame excuse from you)

So that's 2 of his 4 losses. The other 2 games who's to blame? You sure have your cincinnati bungles Homer Goggles fastened to your head tightly.

Do we ever look at a Center, punter, wr. etc and say, well they never won a playoff game?

 

[Shanemansj13]