I got offered this trade….

[Shanemansj13]

PPR league

So Dak gets hurt but I do have Cousins.

I get: Justin Herbert
Tyler Allegier

He gets: Michael Thomas
Damien Harris

I am thinking about countering but also just thinking about declining and rolling with Kirk

 

[Shanemansj13]

My Roster

 

[Shanemansj13]

His Roster

 

[MilkSpiller22]

i wouldnt mind losing either Thomas or Harris... so i would take the trade... But maybe try to swap out Allgier for either Mostert or WHite

 

[leftypower]

Seasonal league ? What QB's are on waivers for Cousin's bye ? Personally, I think Kirk is as good or better than Dak anyway - but that's just my opinion. On the surface you give up two starters for one (never good IMO). Now with Dak out of the picture for numerous weeks, I'm not sure what Lamb has to offer during - probably WR2/3 at best. As it stands today, with Tee ailing, (in the short term) you're left with Thomas, Lamb, M. Jones and Woods (who didn't show-up last week either. Think I'd pass unless he kicks in a usable WR to boot.

 

[averagejoe]

 

[Coily1]

Roster hurts enough as it is. Lamb takes a hit with Rush throwing him the ball instead of Dak. Your first instinct was correct- roll with Cousins.

 

[Shanemansj13]

Seasonal league ? What QB's are on waivers for Cousin's bye ? Personally, I think Kirk is as good or better than Dak anyway - but that's just my opinion. On the surface you give up two starters for one (never good IMO). Now with Dak out of the picture for numerous weeks, I'm not sure what Lamb has to offer during - probably WR2/3 at best. As it stands today, with Tee ailing, (in the short term) you're left with Thomas, Lamb, M. Jones and Woods (who didn't show-up last week either. Think I'd pass unless he kicks in a usable WR to boot.

Yes, seasonal with one keeper but we could be changing platforms and doing 0-2 keepers but I agree, Cousins is good enough. It's not worth what I am giving up. If I tried to ask for a WR2 that would be the only win for me in this scenario. He has Allen already, he is just trying to gain a premium on his bad pick.

I was thinking about offering same trade but substitute Allegier for Gabe Davis or Mooney..

 

[Stakesarehigh]

Why does he have Allen AND Herbert

 

[Shanemansj13]

Why does he have Allen AND Herbert

Not sure if it autodrafted or maybe he left draft when Herbert was in his queue. Shit, maybe his plan was to trade one lol.

Either way I declined and said I need a better WR included, he is trying to gain a fortune on an unnecessary pick. It's not like this is a dynasty or anything.

 

[wildturkey]

Not sure if it autodrafted or maybe he left draft when Herbert was in his queue. Shit, maybe his plan was to trade one lol.

Either way I declined and said I need a better WR included, he is trying to gain a fortune on an unnecessary pick. It's not like this is a dynasty or anything.

The guy is dumb enough to have Allen and Herbert so counter by asking for Gabe Davis instead of Allgaier. If/when he declines, shoot for one of Mooney, London, Dotson

 

[tlance]

PPR league

So Dak gets hurt but I do have Cousins.

I get: Justin Herbert
Tyler Allegier

He gets: Michael Thomas
Damien Harris

I am thinking about countering but also just thinking about declining and rolling with Kirk

I think you are fine with Kirk.

But this trade is a win for you on value.

Michael Thomas is on a serious high after his 4th quarter Sunday, but there are legit reasons he wasn’t drafted until the middle rounds.

I would lean towards yes, but then you probably need to unload either Dak or Cousins (or both).

 

[SteelersPride]

The guy is dumb enough to have Allen and Herbert so counter by asking for Gabe Davis instead of Allgaier. If/when he declines, shoot for one of Mooney, London, Dotson

London or mooney imho…. Way above dotson

 

[Shanemansj13]

So the guy texted me this morning saying he wants to workout a deal for Herbert. I really have all leverage here bc this guy is desperate.

I don't mind giving him Cousins back.

@wildturkey I am going your route. I am offering him Cousins & Thomas for Herbert & Gabe Davis

 

[MilkSpiller22]

So the guy texted me this morning saying he wants to workout a deal for Herbert. I really have all leverage here bc this guy is desperate.

I don't mind giving him Cousins back.

@wildturkey I am going your route. I am offering him Cousins & Thomas for Herbert & Gabe Davis

that makes no sense for him though... he may be desperate but, you are not helping him out....

you gotta do a little better...


If you want to throw in cousins, he must be basically a throw in... I agree you need to get Herbert for a discount though... but you still have to make it worthwhile for him...

 

[MilkSpiller22]

So the guy texted me this morning saying he wants to workout a deal for Herbert. I really have all leverage here bc this guy is desperate.

I don't mind giving him Cousins back.

@wildturkey I am going your route. I am offering him Cousins & Thomas for Herbert & Gabe Davis

He is also desperate for a RB... that is why he was asking for Harris from you...

I would see if you threw in harris to that deal i think he would take it...

so Harris and Thomas for Herbert and Gabe Davis....

 

[Shanemansj13]

He is also desperate for a RB... that is why he was asking for Harris from you...

I would see if you threw in harris to that deal i think he would take it...

so Harris and Thomas for Herbert and Gabe Davis....

Yeah that definitely makes more sense. I cancelled the other offer but I don't even know if he accepts this but we will see

 

[SJ76]

You’ll be deep at QB but you’re WRs gonna be big ???

 

[Shanemansj13]

He said no to Gabe.

Counter Darnell Mooney or Drake London? Is it even worth it at this point...

 

[Schmoopy1000]

He said no to Gabe.

Counter Darnell Mooney or Drake London? Is it even worth it at this point...

he would have been crazy to give up Herbert & Gabe.