Hypothetical

[jeffro151]

Team A is trying to trade:
Cam Newton
Lesean McCoy

Team B offers:
Brandon Marshall
Danny Woodhead

Team C offers:
AJ Green
CJ Spiller

Which one do you accept if you are Team A? I am not Team A, BTW.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Depends on Team As back up QB... But assuming he has one then i think both trades are equal... Aj vs marshall is a total wash, the question is would you rather take Spiller's potential or Woodheads productivity... I think if i had to choose i would pick spiller over Woodhead only because of the potential of HUGENESS...

 

[jeffro151]

Depends on Team As back up QB... But assuming he has one then i think both trades are equal... Aj vs marshall is a total wash, the question is would you rather take Spiller's potential or Woodheads productivity... I think if i had to choose i would pick spiller over Woodhead only because of the potential of HUGENESS...

Team A has Kaepernick has their other QB. Team A is 8-2 and has already secured a playoff spot.

 

[Eastbay]

Team A should keep who he has....

 

[jeffro151]

Team A should keep who he has....

I agree, if I was Team A, I wouldn't be trading those.

 

[GreenNickle]

Team A shouldn't make the trade it makes zero mathematical sense.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Was not making the trade an option to the hypothetical??

 

[jeffro151]

Was not making the trade an option to the hypothetical??

Team A proposed his players to Team B in a trade, but the league vetoed it.

I (Team C) proposed Green & Spiller for Team A's players, and Team A got all pissed off because he said my players were a joke.

 

[Sam Sportboy]

Team A proposed his players to Team B in a trade, but the league vetoed it.

I (Team C) proposed Green & Spiller for Team A's players, and Team A got all pissed off because he said my players were a joke.

Well, the trades look pretty even to me but the upside of Spiller over Woodhead would give a slight edge to the Green/Spiller side. Go tell team A to pound sand and kick his ass.

 

[wilwhite]

but the league vetoed it

Sounds like a joyless league anyway.

 

[SFNL]

B would be a great trade in my league

 

[richig07]

B

 

[cdumler7]

I would rather have C as I think Spiller will get healthier over the next couple of weeks and finally has his starting quarterback back this week. Also not a Danny Woodhead fan as his production seems to be all over the place (I guess same could be said of Spiller). In all honesty I would never make the trade in the first place. Cam in the playoffs is who I would rather have than Kaep and the Eagles seem to have things going pretty well so I see McCoy finishing strong.

 

[Barilko]

if i was A i would be packaging some one else besides Shady

what is A really after i suppose a Stud Wr..so go get it without McCoy

as is i would want more and think A is failing if he makes the trade

and YES the veto is ridiculous ...find a better league....