Got this offer I'm declining, need help on a counter.

[HaroldSeattle]

I trade Mixon and Jacobs
for
Kamara and Cooper

12 team redraft PPR money league.

Won't do that trade because I'd be trading both my starting RBs and that would leave a hole in my lineup.

His Roster:



My roster:



He really wants Jacobs, this isn't his first offer for Jacobs.

 

[TKOSpikes]

He’s got nothing for you. Unless he’s willing to subtract Mixon from that equation, and sub in Cooks or Deebo.

 

[broncosmitty]

I wouldn't counter.

 

[HaroldSeattle]

Any thoughts of asking for Swift and Cooper or one of his other WRs for Jacobs? Too much? Not enough? I worked some trades with they owner last season. He's a fair guy and willing to over pay a bit if he wants a player.

 

[SmokingMonkey]

Any thoughts of asking for Taylor and Cooper or one of his other WRs for Jacobs? Too much? Not enough? I worked some trades with they owner last season. He's a fair guy and willing to over pay a bit if he wants a player.

he has taylor?

if you meant swift, a hell to the no

 

[HaroldSeattle]

he has taylor?

if you meant swift, a hell to the no

Yeah I meant Swift. LOL at the "hell to the no" Think your right, hard to know how it goes with the Lions backfield between Swift and K. Johnson.

 

[SmokingMonkey]

Yeah I meant Swift. LOL at the "hell to the no" Think your right, hard to know how it goes with the Lions backfield between Swift and K. Johnson.

and Peterson!

i think Swift will have the passing game work, but not sure what that all amounts to if people are thinking Hockenson takes a step forward and Golladay and Marv are healthy

I like swift, but HATE his landing spot, and not sure there's many RBs that could go to Detroit that I'd still be happy with for fantasy. I'm not a Patricia fan, think he brings the whole team down, even if he doesn't interfere with the offense

 

[broncosmitty]

Any thoughts of asking for Swift and Cooper or one of his other WRs for Jacobs? Too much? Not enough? I worked some trades with they owner last season. He's a fair guy and willing to over pay a bit if he wants a player.

Swift seems like he'll be third in carries on his own team.


And willing to bet the Lions are bottom third in rushing. That defense isn't going to be good.

 

[HaroldSeattle]

He just told me if Kamara wasn't there at the 1.06 Jacobs would of been his pick. Checking to see if I throw in a bench player if he'd be interested.

 

[TREFF]

hes got nothing, including Kamara, that would persuade me to deal Mixon or Jacobs, let alone both

 

[HaroldSeattle]

hes got nothing, including Kamara, that would persuade me to deal Mixon or Jacobs, let alone both

Well you might be right, but Kamara usually get drafted by 1.06 and those two don't so some obviously disagree.

 

[HaroldSeattle]

hes got nothing, including Kamara, that would persuade me to deal Mixon or Jacobs, let alone both

I like my roster so not pressed to make a move, but hard not to tinker.

 

[femurov]

I like my roster so not pressed to make a move, but hard not to tinker.

Yeah... you gotta find something you really like to make a move. Fun to play what if, but be prepared that he probably won't do it.

 

[tlance]

I wouldn't counter.

I wouldn’t either.

Mixon and Jacobs could each end up out producing Kamara.

I would still draft Kamara first, but I wouldn’t want to give an asset to make this upgrade that might not end up being an upgrade at all.

 

[Barilko]

Well if ya still love Kamara maybe Jacobs straight up

offer a few other combos for kamara coop that dont involve Mixon.... eventually when ya dont work it out tell him who cares about the diff in the 1st round draft spots

if ya still like K then evetually it gets to K for J if he wants him that bad....

 

[HaroldSeattle]

Well if ya still love Kamara maybe Jacobs straight up

offer a few other combos for kamara coop that dont involve Mixon.... eventually when ya dont work it out tell him who cares about the diff in the 1st round draft spots

if ya still like K then evetually it gets to K for J if he wants him that bad....

We are at a impasse so no deal. I do still like Kamara but I own him in a few leagues already, so maybe it’s best not to get over invested. Also this is the only league I own Jacobs and I like to give all RBs a spin. It never hurts to see what may be possible and that was mostly what I was doing. I made a few deals with this owner in the past, good guy and we may revisit at some point.

 

[Barilko]

Good call. I just landed Jacobs in my work league 1st time owner as well