Good compilation of all playoff umpire challenges so far

[Mays-Fan]

Safe call confirmed in first World Series challenge | MLB.com

Shows three important things, IMHO:

1) On balance, the umps do a darn good job, even without replay. Balls and strikes notwithstanding.

2) It's worth it to have replay. Nice to know every field call is right, eventually.

3) Posey is slower than I thought.

 

[msgkings322]

Safe call confirmed in first World Series challenge | MLB.com

Shows three important things, IMHO:

1) On balance, the umps do a darn good job, even without replay. Balls and strikes notwithstanding.

2) It's worth it to have replay. Nice to know every field call is right, eventually.

3) Posey is slower than I thought.

You are the only person on earth who can say this. He can only be faster than most of us think.

But he's not. He's like Molina slow.

 

[Mays-Fan]

You are the only person on earth who can say this. He can only be faster than most of us think.

But he's not. He's like Molina slow.

Must be I think pretty slow.

 

[Mays-Fan]

...and the umpires decide there is not enough evidence to overturn the call.

Posey is out.

Again.