Forward pass or Fumble?

[Scooby-Doo]

Let me preface this by saying the Cardinals were thoroughly outplayed and this play did not decide the game. Cards got pounded and deserved to lose.

I watched this play and was thoroughly perplexed. No booth review even though it was ruled a turnover. Looked like a spiral to me.

 

[Judge Fudge]

Let me preface this by saying the Cardinals were thoroughly outplayed and this play did not decide the game. Cards got pounded and deserved to lose.

I watched this play and was thoroughly perplexed. No booth review even though it was ruled a turnover. Looked like a spiral to me.

Honestly......

It looks like a shovel pass like alot of qb's are doing lately. I counted 1 per team on the Saints/hakws game

We had a bad vantage point. The only way that we can see if this was a fumble is if the Rusher got his hand on the ball. There is no indisputable proof because thee OL is in the way

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Time for Carson to hang em up

 

[Broncos6482]

That is a pass.

We had a similar play in the Broncos/Chargers game. Rivers hand is hit as he's throwing, ball goes forward, Denver recovers. Ruled a fumble on the field. In replay, it was EXTREMELY close. Looked like Rivers lost control just as his arm was starting forward. The announcers both thought the call would stand because it was just too close to tell.

Nope. Play reversed, incomplete pass. It worked out though, because Rivers threw a pick 6 a couple of plays later. Ball don't lie.

 

[Hank Kingsley]

Just like Dez caught that fucking ball, Palmer threw that ball.....

 

[Hank Kingsley]

That is a pass.

We had a similar play in the Broncos/Chargers game. Rivers hand is hit as he's throwing, ball goes forward, Denver recovers. Ruled a fumble on the field. In replay, it was EXTREMELY close. Looked like Rivers lost control just as his arm was starting forward. The announcers both thought the call would stand because it was just too close to tell.

Nope. Play reversed, incomplete pass. It worked out though, because Rivers threw a pick 6 a couple of plays later. Ball don't lie.

Almost exactly the same but Palmer had his arms wrapped up a bit.

Can't remember the game but there was another weird one where the receiver looked like his first foot tapped but it didn't and then he was knocked OB. And the replays clearly showed it, but nobody challenged?

Might have been Olsen in the same game? Led to a TD too.

 

[shopson67]

Just like Dez caught that fucking ball, Palmer threw that ball.....

So, Palmer fumbled?

 

[Hank Kingsley]

So, Palmer fumbled?

Nope. Just another fuck up by the refs.

 

[shopson67]

Nope. Just another fuck up by the refs.

They were correct on Dez's drop. If the player is going to the ground while making the reception, he has to retain control through contact with the ground. Dez didn't.

 

[Hank Kingsley]

They were correct on Dez's drop. If the player is going to the ground while making the reception, he has to retain control through contact with the ground. Dez didn't.

Dez caught that fucking ball as much as Beasley did 2 games ago and they let it slide. Control, 3 steps and a dive.

 

[shopson67]

Dez caught that fucking ball as much as Beasley did 2 games ago and they let it slide. Control, 3 steps and a dive.

Dez' steps were as he was falling forward, completely different if he was upright and running. Momentum was taking him to the ground.

I can't speak to the Beasley example as I didn't see it.

 

[RobToxin]

No potato salad option = invalid poll.

 

[Hank Kingsley]

Dez' steps were as he was falling forward, completely different if he was upright and running. Momentum was taking him to the ground.

I can't speak to the Beasley example as I didn't see it.

Sounds like you didn't see Dez either.

2 feet down, 3rd step the lunge (just like Beasley). Ball control all the way till hit's ground. HE wasn't fallin he was diving.

Either way, it didn't decide the game and he should have just taken the yards.

But he caught that fucking ball....

 

[CowboyB]

Let me preface this by saying the Cardinals were thoroughly outplayed and this play did not decide the game. Cards got pounded and deserved to lose.

I watched this play and was thoroughly perplexed. No booth review even though it was ruled a turnover. Looked like a spiral to me.

I dream of a week where we don't have to hear crying from Cardinals fans.

 

[shopson67]

Sounds like you didn't see Dez either.

2 feet down, 3rd step the lunge (just like Beasley). Ball control all the way till hit's ground. HE wasn't fallin he was diving.

Either way, it didn't decide the game and he should have just taken the yards.

But he caught that fucking ball....

Just to refresh your memory...

Did Dallas Cowboys wide receiver Dez Bryant catch it?

His momentum is to the ground, whether he dives or not. Doesn't control the ball when he hits the ground. Incomplete.

 

[CowboyB]

Bruce Arians Weekly Cry baby session. I like how in this one he says "I am not going to cry about it..." and then cries about it for 10 minutes straight.


Arizona Cardinals postgame press conference

 

[Hank Kingsley]

Just to refresh your memory...

Did Dallas Cowboys wide receiver Dez Bryant catch it?

His momentum is to the ground, whether he dives or not. Doesn't control the ball when he hits the ground. Incomplete.

I don't need reminders, I know the play intimately.

He caught that fucking ball.

 

[Podunkparte]

Obviously, the result of a play like this depends solely on who the QB is...

Brady: Forward pass

Anyone else: Fumble

 

[shopson67]

I don't need reminders, I know the play intimately.

He caught that fucking ball.

...and then dropped it, making it an imcomplete pass.

 

[Scooby-Doo]

I dream of a week where we don't have to hear crying from Cardinals fans.

If that's a dream of yours, you have huge issues that you may want to seek help for.