D1 Playoff Tie-breaker Poll

[Bandit]

@Bandit
@TREFF
@leftypower
@Yellow Fuzzies
@obxyankeefan
@TKOSpikes
@SteelersPride
@broncosmitty
@Chef99
@The Foot
@Barilko
@Trudem
@MilkSpiller22
@HaroldSeattle
@Ram Tough

Right now the tie-breaker to make the playoffs in D1 and for seeding is head-to-head. I propose that we change that tie-breaker to the same thing as the regular MBBRL league which is breakdown (or overall W-L as Obx calls it in his recaps). It's a simple choice, either leave the tie-breaker as it is now (head-to-head) or change it to breakdown. This change would be effective this year since it doesn't effect roster decisions or the draft in any way.

 

[TREFF]

@Bandit
@TREFF
@leftypower
@Yellow Fuzzies
@obxyankeefan
@TKOSpikes
@SteelersPride
@broncosmitty
@Chef99
@The Foot
@Barilko
@Trudem
@MilkSpiller22
@HaroldSeattle
@Ram Tough

Right now the tie-breaker to make the playoffs in D1 and for seeding is head-to-head. I propose that we change that tie-breaker to the same thing as the regular MBBRL league which is breakdown (or overall W-L as Obx calls it in his recaps). It's a simple choice, either leave the tie-breaker as it is now (head-to-head) or change it to breakdown. This change would be effective this year since it doesn't effect roster decisions or the draft in any way.

I just think its cool you tagged yourself

 

[MilkSpiller22]

if we had divisions, I would have a strong opinion in favor for H2H... But without divisions, one game should not decide anything...

 

[Bandit]

I just think its cool you tagged yourself

Nobody tags themselves like @Bandit

 

[TKOSpikes]

Not sure I follow... What is this, "playoffs" word?

 

[Trudem]

if we had divisions, I would have a strong opinion in favor for H2H... But without divisions, one game should not decide anything...

This is where I land.

 

[TREFF]

I really don't care, I just like to fall on the side of the dissent.

 

[Trudem]

I just dont like the fact that a playoff spot could be determined by a bad BYE week. I understand we all have them but sometimes you cant fill all the holes

 

[TREFF]

I just dont like the fact that a playoff spot could be determined by a bad BYE week. I understand we all have them but sometimes you cant fill all the holes

I think that's like the #3 tie breaker though, isnt it?

 

[Barilko]

@Bandit i voted @Bandit cause i had to

 

[Bandit]

Have to bump this because we only have 7 votes for changing to breakdown and we need at least one more to have a majority: @obxyankeefan @The Foot @Ram Tough @Chef99 @broncosmitty

 

[leftypower]

I just dont like the fact that a playoff spot could be determined by a bad BYE week. I understand we all have them but sometimes you cant fill all the holes

Well, with larger rosters that wouldn't be as big a problem would it ?

 

[SteelersPride]

Well, with larger rosters that wouldn't be as big a problem would it ?

and thats the point of larger rosters in dynasty

 

[Trudem]

Well, with larger rosters that wouldn't be as big a problem would it ?

I agree

I originally didnt want to rock the boat in the roster vote but I have since changed my mind. being flexible is what allows these leagues to survive and grow!

 

[broncosmitty]

Breakdown, head to head, total points, coin flip, doesn't matter to me.

 

[Chef99]

Been a little behind...voted head to head, but is this an official rules change by the commish?

 

[TREFF]

Been a little behind...voted head to head, but is this an official rules change by the commish?

If voted in, which it appears as though might happen, no idea where our missing votes are, but hopefully some closure soon.
But its just pertaining to tie breakers for playoffs and such, nothing that would affect rosters or any moves made thus far

 

[broncosmitty]

If voted in, which it appears as though might happen, no idea where our missing votes are, but hopefully some closure soon.
But its just pertaining to tie breakers for playoffs and such, nothing that would affect rosters or any moves made thus far

I haven't voted.

 

[Chef99]

I haven't voted.

Perhaps you should?

 

[broncosmitty]

Perhaps you should?

Perhaps.