Another trade question

[SteelersPride]

I have an offer on the table of. 1PPR.

I give: Tyrone Tracy

I get:Cedric Tillman

We start 2 rb and 2 flex
But i have mixon, barkley, jonathan taylor and chase brown.

WR lacks.big time since losing rashee rice

Heres my team. I can post his if needed.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

you kind of answer this question in your post... you are deep enough in RB that Tracy is only a flex on bye weeks... if that...

and tillman might be one of your starting WRs...

kind of a no brainer... and value seems fine... you aint getting much for a RB on the giants, no matter how well he is playing... he aint saquon good, where player trumped team...

 

[cwalke3408]

Schedule maybe tough but he's been getting 10 targets a game
Easy yes for me

 

[TKOSpikes]

I wouldn't. Not this week at least. Tillman on a bye and Tracy has a beauty matchup. And that schedule ain't pretty.

 

[SteelersPride]

you kind of answer this question in your post... you are deep enough in RB that Tracy is only a flex on bye weeks... if that...

and tillman might be one of your starting WRs...

kind of a no brainer... and value seems fine... you aint getting much for a RB on the giants, no matter how well he is playing... he aint saquon good, where player trumped team...

I am agreeing for sure but looking for opinions counter if out there lol

Schedule maybe tough but he's been getting 10 targets a game
Easy yes for me

Thank you!!

I wouldn't. Not this week at least. Tillman on a bye and Tracy has a beauty matchup. And that schedule ain't pretty.

So no from you ROS?

 

[TREFF]

well you know me, I side with the RB almost always, and easily in this case, as I don't buy TIllman being that good

 

[Schmoopy1000]

I assume this isnt a Keeper league.

Player for player in a vacuum I would say no.
I think tracy is just gonna start ramping up & probably in the end surpass some of your other RBs going forward.

but as far as depth & need (non keeper) I would say go ahead. Just know your trade partner is going to be a happy camper.

 

[SteelersPride]

I assume this isnt a Keeper league.

Player for player in a vacuum I would say no.
I think tracy is just gonna start ramping up & probably in the end surpass some of your other RBs going forward.

but as far as depth & need (non keeper) I would say go ahead. Just know your trade partner is going to be a happy camper.

U think tracy is going to
Outscore mixon, barkley, or taylor?

 

[TKOSpikes]

So no from you ROS?

We've already talked about the schedule. I'm not saying it's a bad deal, but you're handing a RB roster spot for this week with a big red bow (not sure if that matters for your team/standings)... for a bye week WR who is facing tough secondaries ROS.

I'd be more keen on finding a bigger get at WR, even if that means holding Tracy and moving one of the others. Brown's huge game could be a nice sell high. Or maybe you don't need Taylor and his big name can net you a stud.

 

[SteelersPride]

well you know me, I side with the RB almost always, and easily in this case, as I don't buy TIllman being that good

Only thing is I dont have enough spots to start them all

 

[SteelersPride]

We've already talked about the schedule. I'm not saying it's a bad deal, but you're handing a RB roster spot for this week with a big red bow (not sure if that matters for your team/standings)... for a bye week WR who is facing tough secondaries ROS.

I'd be more keen on finding a bigger get at WR, even if that means holding Tracy and moving one of the others. Brown's huge game could be a nice sell high. Or maybe you don't need Taylor and his big name can net you a stud.

Ideas here huh….. hmm i like this angle. Thank you. Maybe ill
Explore an alternative

 

[Schmoopy1000]

U think tracy is going to
Outscore mixon, barkley, or taylor?

well I am not guaranteeing anything, but he just took over as a workhorse & not a committee guy. So his early stats while splitting time with Singletary could be misleading. I had picked up Tracy in my league at the perfect time & havent regretted it yet.
To be honest. I havent been following Mixon, but I did see Brown (I also have Brown) in your flex position, & with the Bengals picking up Herbert in a trade. I am unsure what that means yet. Will Brown go back to splitting time now?
Also Tracy does have good matchups all the way until week 15 when they play the ravens.
Now with all that said. Again I dont know much on Mixon. Just saying dont be surprised if you see Tracy beefing your trade partners team.
BTW. Barkley is an all star & I would have never been talking of him LOL
Also BTW as I write this I looked up Mixon. Definitely looking studly. If he continues to get 20+ touches. Never give away a workhorse. They are rare.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

We've already talked about the schedule. I'm not saying it's a bad deal, but you're handing a RB roster spot for this week with a big red bow (not sure if that matters for your team/standings)... for a bye week WR who is facing tough secondaries ROS.

I'd be more keen on finding a bigger get at WR, even if that means holding Tracy and moving one of the others. Brown's huge game could be a nice sell high. Or maybe you don't need Taylor and his big name can net you a stud.

i did not take into account that cleveland has their bye this week... that does kind of ruin this trade IMO... tillman is not good enough to wait for... even if it is only a week and even if the giants have not had their bye yet either....

but here is the tricky part Tracy has his bye week 11, if you wait after week 10, you are not gonna get good value for him...

 

[TREFF]

Only thing is I dont have enough spots to start them all

For now.. never know next week with RB's.. he could be your RB1 in a snap of the fingers

 

[TKOSpikes]

i did not take into account that cleveland has their bye this week... that does kind of ruin this trade IMO... tillman is not good enough to wait for... even if it is only a week and even if the giants have not had their bye yet either....

but here is the tricky part Tracy has his bye week 11, if you wait after week 10, you are not gonna get good value for him...

That's why I suggested an alternate route.

Something like Taylor for Amon Ra is miles better than the hope of Tillman vs the Steelers twice, Broncos, Chiefs and Chargers.

 

[MilkSpiller22]

That's why I suggested an alternate route.

Something like Taylor for Amon Ra is miles better than the hope of Tillman vs the Steelers twice, Broncos, Chiefs and Chargers.

idk... with 2 flexes, i would rather keep my top RBs... and the problem is that this is also a 3 WR league without flex...

dont think teams would want to give up their WR1 for a RB1... maybe they will... but i think trading Tracy or Brown is the way to go... at least the easier way to go...

 

[cwalke3408]

I guess it's up to you to decided if the talent is legit or not.
- 2nd year player (3rd Rd guy coming off of injury in SR season). 6'4 4.54 40-time
- No more Watson throwing the ball & no more Cooper taking all the targets
- Upgrades to one the most friendly QBs for fantasy (40 attempts a game / 10 targets)
- Tough matchups for the season but volume will be there

 

[TKOSpikes]

idk... with 2 flexes, i would rather keep my top RBs... and the problem is that this is also a 3 WR league without flex...

dont think teams would want to give up their WR1 for a RB1... maybe they will... but i think trading Tracy or Brown is the way to go... at least the easier way to go...

I guess it's a moot point since the trade was offered to him. Without knowing other teams' needs, or this Tillman owner's roster, hard to say.

I'd be making sure Barkley is okay before I do anything.

 

[SteelersPride]

For now.. never know next week with RB's.. he could be your RB1 in a snap of the fingers

I agree. All my others r knicked up. But 3/4 are top rbs. Tillmans recent form Makes him my best wr.

 

[broncosmitty]

Only own Tracy in one league, but it’d take more than Tillman to get him from me. And he’s my fourth RB.

Lots of WRs out there. Can’t say that about RB.