MILK LINEUP 1. Luke Appling (R) - SS - 1933 - White Sox 2. Rogers Hornsby (R) - 2B - 1933 - Cardinals 3. Mickey Mantle (B) - CF - 1958 - Yankees 4. Albert Pujols (R) - 1B - 2008 - Cardinals 5. Carl Yastrzemski (L) - LF - 1983 - Red Sox 6. Roberto Clemente (R) - RF - 1958 - Pirates 7. Home Run Baker (L) - 3B - 1908 - Athletics 8. Jorge Posada (B) - C - 2008 - Yankees 9. Sam Crawford (L) - RF - 1908 - Tigers BENCH Wally Berger (R) - OF - 1933 - Braves Paul Waner (L) - PF - 1933 - Pirates Joe Tinker (R) - MI - 1908 - Cubs Gil Hodges (R) - CI - 1958 - Dodgers Sherm Lollar (R) - C - 1958 - White Sox ROTATION 1. Warren Spahn (L) - 1958 - Braves 2. Ed Walsh (R) - 1908 - White Sox 3. Max Scherzer (R) - 2008 - Tigers 4. Phil Niekro (R) - 1983 - Braves 5. Cliff Lee (L) - 2008 - Indians BULLPEN CL. Joe Nathan (R) - 2008 - Twins LH. Gary Lavelle (L) - 1983 - Giants RH. Burleigh Grimes (R) - 1933 - Dodgers RP. Jeff Reardon (R) - 1983 - Nationals RP. Rube Marquard (L) - 1908 - Giants RP. Dave Smith (R) - 1983 - Astros VS MEEBS LINEUP 1. Ichiro Suzuki (L) - RF - 2008 - Mariners 2. George Brett (L) - 3B - 1983 - Royals 3. Alex Rodriguez (R) - SS - 2008 - Yankees 4. David Ortiz (L) - DH/1B - 2008 - Red Sox 5. Andre Dawson (R) - CF/RF - 1983 - Nationals 6. Todd Helton (L) - 1B - 2008 - Rockies 7. Ryne Sandberg (R) - 2B - 1983 - Cubs 8. Goose Goslin (L) - LF - 1933 - Twins 9. Smoky Burgess (L) - C - 1958 - Pirates BENCH Rick Ferrell (R) - C - 1933 - Orioles Larry Gardner (L) - CI - 1908 - Red Sox Ben Chapman (R) - PR - 1933 - Yankees Topsy Hartsel (L) - OF - 1908 - Athletics Hughie Jennings (R) - MI - 1908 - Orioles ROTATION 1. Walter Johnson (R) - 1908 - Nationals 2. Steve Carlton (L) - 1983 - Phillies 3. Addie Joss (R) - 1908 - Indians 4. Vida Blue (L) - 1983 - Athletics 5. Red Faber (R) - 1933 - White Sox BULLPEN CL. Jose Valverde (R) - 2008 - Diamondbacks LH. Bobby Shantz (L) - 1958 - Athletics RH. Lindy McDaniel (R) - 1958 - Cardinals RP. Turk Farrell (R) - 1958 - Phillies RP. Hank Aguirre (L) - 1958 - Tigers RP. Clint Brown (R) - 1933 - Indians
One of the closest games in recent memory, I gotta lean Meebs but this one much like Shane could go either way.
This is tough but it will be probably be one of those matchups where it is 8-2 in voting but really much closer. I lean Meebs