Rodgers and Brady are the two best QBs of all time...

NEhomer · Jan 16, 2017

I compare it to Tiger and Jack.

Rodgers has played the game at a higher level than Brady for periods of time but overall, Brady's more consistent year to year and has the most hardware.

whiskey · Jan 16, 2017

NEhomer said:
I compare it to Tiger and Jack.

Rodgers has played the game at a higher level than Brady for periods of time but overall, Brady's more consistent year to year and has the most hardware.

Yeah, I think that's fair. Rodgers has those "holy shit, how did he just do that???" moments where you say "no other guy in the NFL can put the ball there, where he just threw that ball", but it's fair to say that Rodgers isn't quite as consistent as Brady, I would agree with that statement.

Brady doesn't have to attempt to make the throws Rodgers does. Is it the offensive playcalling? Who can say. It's a completely different animal. But on the surface, I agree with the analogy and the premise that you've put forth here.

cowboys5xsbs · Jan 16, 2017

Rodgers is just plain ridiculous. Apparently he drew that last play up in the huddle. I honestly believe Rodgers has one of the most accurate arms of all time. The placement he has with balls is crazy.

NEhomer · Jan 16, 2017

Yeah, a couple of Rodger's throws yesterday were ridiculous.

Malibu · Jan 16, 2017

SDPaddlefish said:
Q: In addition to being for the NFC Championship, is the Packers-Falcons game also to decide which QB will be the league MVP?

Voted on a while ago. Just hasn't been announced. Peace.

rmilia1 · Jan 16, 2017

Yet neither of them was the best QB in the league this year

sonnyblack65 · Jan 16, 2017

DirtDirtDirt said:
Tom Brady plays with a Top 5 defense most of his career

Aaron Rodgers has to overcome is own awful defense every postseason

Not in the same class

Its not like Brady is a game manger and doesn't put up the no#s. Only player to have 3 seasons over 4800 yards and 50 tds . His td/int is sic and about the same as Rodgers if you compare to stats from when Rodgers came into league vs Brady's no# in those years. You saw rodgers was trying to catch Brady as most td's w/o an int or most passes w/o a TD which Brady still holds. Brady is the no#2 guy behind Brees with most consecutive games with a TD, only unanimous MVP , If they win this weekend , that will be 11 AFCG and 7 SB's easily the GOAT, Montana is no#2. Rodgers is young and still has another 6-7 years and could very well end up as the GOAT, but not at any convo now

Malibu · Jan 16, 2017

Brady needs everything to be perfect for him to succeed. He needs his 5 yard pass open or he will throw ducks deep that are caught luckily by his teammates. That last throw by Rodgers is something Brady isn't capable of doing. There hasn't been one game I have ever watched Brady and said wow. Does nothing to impress me and that goes for Manning as well during his career. Guys like Elway and Rodgers are head and shoulders better when it comes to playmaking and turning garbage into something great. Peace.

LambeauLegs · Jan 16, 2017

Does Phill Simms know anything about football?

redseat · Jan 16, 2017

Great Dayne said:
That's what the experts are saying now. It's not even close and other than last season it wasn't close for the last 3-4 years. He belongs in another league above the NFL.

It's hilarious how a few weeks ago everyone was saying he was washed up and couldn't win games (reporters, espn,cbs etc, not posters here)... Then the Pack go on a run, "oh, he's the best there is out there".

sonnyblack65 · Jan 16, 2017

whiskey said:
Yeah, I think that's fair. Rodgers has those "holy shit, how did he just do that???" moments where you say "no other guy in the NFL can put the ball there, where he just threw that ball", but it's fair to say that Rodgers isn't quite as consistent as Brady, I would agree with that statement.

Brady doesn't have to attempt to make the throws Rodgers does. Is it the offensive playcalling? Who can say. It's a completely different animal. But on the surface, I agree with the analogy and the premise that you've put forth here.

If you have no time on the clock and need a huge play, Rodgers is the best. They should have his pic next to Hail Mary pass

redseat · Jan 16, 2017

NorthCoastSteelersFan said:
Brady is one of the best pocket passers of all time...he's phenomenal, as long as he isn't pressured...but he's not mobile enough to be considered the greatest QB.

He has gotten better as of late outside of the pocket but yes, Rodgers is better than him at that.

RobBase · Jan 16, 2017

Brady was doing it long before the NFL helped Rodgers out by making the starting field position the 25. A 35 yard drive for a winning FG isn't super impressive.

redseat · Jan 16, 2017

LambeauLegs · Jan 16, 2017

sonnyblack65 said:
If you have no time on the clock and need a huge play, Rodgers is the best. They should have his pic next to Hail Mary pass

Take a minute and go google Hail Mary and see what comes up

DHoey · Jan 16, 2017

cowboys5xsbs said:
Rodgers is just plain ridiculous. Apparently he drew that last play up in the huddle. I honestly believe Rodgers has one of the most accurate arms of all time. The placement he has with balls is crazy.

Ya....like right into his mouth!

:dhd:

DHoey · Jan 16, 2017

LambeauLegs said:
Take a minute and go google Hail Mary and see what comes up

Golden Tate?

rmilia1 · Jan 16, 2017

DirtDirtDirt said:
Agreed, especially at home, that offense is unstoppable. Total in this game is 60.5

Crazy

That's too low

whiskey · Jan 16, 2017

rmilia1 said:
That's too low

Final score is going to be 38-35. whoever has the ball last wins.

sonnyblack65 · Jan 16, 2017

Malibu said:
Brady needs everything to be perfect for him to succeed. He needs his 5 yard pass open or he will throw ducks deep that are caught luckily by his teammates. That last throw by Rodgers is something Brady isn't capable of doing. There hasn't been one game I have ever watched Brady and said wow. Does nothing to impress me and that goes for Manning as well during his career. Guys like Elway and Rodgers are head and shoulders better when it comes to playmaking and turning garbage into something great. Peace.

Must excite you to see Brady in his 11th AFCG game. The 2 years he didn't start , they missed the playoffs so he needs everything to be perfect for him to succed.

. What a fucking clown you are Peace

Rodgers and Brady are the two best QBs of all time...

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Surprise Motherfucker

Well-Known Member

PEACE

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

PEACE

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

★★★★★

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Similar threads