Indrid Cold
Member In Black
The Clipper was seriously screwed on his raw numbers as a righty in old Yankee Stadium....probably the only guys who had it worse were the Senators players (like Goose Goslin). Of course, Joe would have been about 10% as famous playing anywhere else except maybe for the Bosox or Cubbies, so being a Yank worked out in his favor in the end.Interestingly, both players have 55.6 WAA. But yeah, having 13.7 more WAR than DiMaggio isn't really a point in his favor considering he had nearly 4000 more plate appearances.
Kaline may have had a better career (at least in terms of longevity), but I think DiMaggio was easily the better player.