Trent Dilfer vs Jimmy Garoppolo playoff stats

SteelersPride · Jan 22, 2020

msgkings322 said:
Even if he has a shitty game in the SB, he still had a very good year and is clearly a very good quarterback. Not great or elite (as of now), but very good. The numbers show this.

Up to now every game he's had to come through, under pressure, he has. That narrative will take a hit if he has a bad SB. But he will still be a good QB.

just asking a question. How do you feel about trubisky?

msgkings322 · Jan 22, 2020

SteelersPride said:
just asking a question. How do you feel about trubisky?

He blows obviously. He had some numbers last year, but I have eyes and so do you. His numbers over his career are far worse than JG and he's not a winner. JG is.

SteelersPride · Jan 22, 2020

msgkings322 said:
He blows obviously. He had some numbers last year, but I have eyes and so do you. His numbers over his career are far worse than JG and he's not a winner. JG is.

but whose to say that couldnt happen here? last year the numbers were great.......again, small sample size....

msgkings322 · Jan 22, 2020

SteelersPride said:
but whose to say that couldnt happen here? last year the numbers were great.......again, small sample size....

They might. Don't bet on it.

Again, you have eyes. The numbers are there. The wins are there. There are about 24 teams that would rather have JG as their QB than who they got (including your Steelers). Big facts.

SteelersPride · Jan 22, 2020

For comparison sake

TRUBS

msgkings322 said:
They might. Don't bet on it.

Again, you have eyes. The numbers are there. The wins are there. There are about 22 teams that would rather have JG as their QB than who they got. Big facts.

not disagreeing but your hypothesizing. The wins and numbers were there for mitch too

msgkings322 · Jan 22, 2020

SteelersPride said:
For comparison sake

TRUBS

not disagreeing but your hypothesizing. The wins and numbers were there for mitch too

Nope. JG's numbers are better and were better than Trubs after his first 30 starts.

But sure, JG = Trubisky. You're a genius.

SteelersPride · Jan 22, 2020

msgkings322 said:
Nope. JG's numbers are better and were better than Trubs after his first 30 starts.

But sure, JG = Trubisky. You're a genius.

Or twist what I said we can continue to do that. Or put words in my mouth again.

Robotech · Jan 22, 2020

SteelersPride said:
but whose to say that couldnt happen here? last year the numbers were great.......again, small sample size....

I have only watched maybe 3 Trubisky games, but the sense I get is that he's just not very ambitious as a passer. Jimmy G averages almost 2 more yards gained per pass attempt compared to Mitch. For this season, Jimmy was 2.3 yards per pass attempt better than Mitch. It sure looks like Jimmy throws the deep ball better.

msgkings322 · Jan 22, 2020

Robotech said:
I have only watched maybe 3 Trubisky games, but the sense I get is that he's just not very ambitious as a passer. Jimmy G averages almost 2 more yards gained per pass attempt compared to Mitch. For this season, Jimmy was 2.3 yards per pass attempt better than Mitch. It sure looks like Jimmy throws the deep ball better.

He does almost everything better, come on man. SteelerPride has his mind made up, and also seems to be just sticking to a take just so he doesn't have to admit he was going too far.

JG could have a 22-28 253 yds 2 TD 0 INT Super Bowl and this guy will just say 'well, we still don't really know if he's good, it was just one playoff game'

Then he has a good 2020 season, like this one, and this dude will say 'well, I mean, he's only really been QB for 2 full years, let's see if he..."

You get the picture.

Robotech · Jan 22, 2020

msgkings322 said:
Nope. JG's numbers are better and were better than Trubs after his first 30 starts.

But sure, JG = Trubisky. You're a genius.

Yeah, Jimmy's simply better. Both the eye test and the numbers confirm it.

msgkings322 · Jan 22, 2020

Robotech said:
Yeah, Jimmy's simply better. Both the eye test and the numbers confirm it.

I mean, I don't think it's controversial to say JG is a good QB, late top 10. Just common sense.

Robotech · Jan 22, 2020

msgkings322 said:
I mean, I don't think it's controversial to say JG is a good QB, late top 10. Just common sense.

He has performed like a top 10 QB this season. Does that make him a top 10 QB? Maybe. But even if Jimmy really were just a mediocre QB, as long as he performs like a top 10 QB, everyone is happy.

msgkings322 · Jan 22, 2020

Robotech said:
He has performed like a top 10 QB this season. Does that make him a top 10 QB? Maybe. But even if Jimmy really were just a mediocre QB, as long as he performs like a top 10 QB, everyone is happy.

It's a trick, he's really mediocre he just performs well

Robotech · Jan 22, 2020

msgkings322 said:
It's a trick, he's really mediocre he just performs well

I mean if you're a terrible QB, but you play like a good QB, does it really matter that you're really terrible?

Robotech · Jan 22, 2020

msgkings322 said:
It's a trick, he's really mediocre he just performs well

Jimmy G is basically Trent Dilfer with much better job performance ratings.

Pattersonca65 · Jan 23, 2020

SteelersPride said:
And the pats thought so Much of jimmy they dumped Him. We can do hypotheticals all day. One started and won a Super Bowl. Jimmy has his chance, And a good one at that

The Pat's didnt dump him. He was going to be a free agent at the end of the season and they would have lost him for nothing.

Peter Gozintite · Jan 23, 2020

Dilfer is better, and JimmyG is also not as good

handicappers · Jan 23, 2020

msgkings322 said:
End thread, drop mic.

msgkings322 said:
6 years. Around two seasons worth of starts. Dude.

msgkings322 said:
So Dilfer was better, obviously

msgkings322 said:
Did you read the article Rock posted on page 1 of this thread? It wasn't one game.

msgkings322 said:
He cut and pasted the text dude LOL

Post #15 in this thread

msgkings322 said:
Yeah he probably made all those simple statistics up

Man your agenda will not be shifted. Whatever.

msgkings322 said:
No, you have your mind made up. It's fine, it's just sports chatter.

msgkings322 said:
Even if he has a shitty game in the SB, he still had a very good year and is clearly a very good quarterback. Not great or elite (as of now), but very good. The numbers show this.

Up to now every game he's had to come through, under pressure, he has. That narrative will take a hit if he has a bad SB. But he will still be a good QB.

msgkings322 said:
He blows obviously. He had some numbers last year, but I have eyes and so do you. His numbers over his career are far worse than JG and he's not a winner. JG is.

msgkings322 said:
They might. Don't bet on it.

Again, you have eyes. The numbers are there. The wins are there. There are about 24 teams that would rather have JG as their QB than who they got (including your Steelers). Big facts.

msgkings322 said:
Nope. JG's numbers are better and were better than Trubs after his first 30 starts.

But sure, JG = Trubisky. You're a genius.

msgkings322 said:
He does almost everything better, come on man. SteelerPride has his mind made up, and also seems to be just sticking to a take just so he doesn't have to admit he was going too far.

JG could have a 22-28 253 yds 2 TD 0 INT Super Bowl and this guy will just say 'well, we still don't really know if he's good, it was just one playoff game'

Then he has a good 2020 season, like this one, and this dude will say 'well, I mean, he's only really been QB for 2 full years, let's see if he..."

You get the picture.

msgkings322 said:
I mean, I don't think it's controversial to say JG is a good QB, late top 10. Just common sense.

msgkings322 said:
It's a trick, he's really mediocre he just performs well

Guess the thread didn't end after all. You picked up the mic within seconds.

NinerSickness · Jan 23, 2020

How did Mahomes & Jimmy each fare against top-10 passing defenses?

HaroldSeattle · Jan 23, 2020

Robotech said:
All this stuff screams game manager. LOL.

13 QBs played the full 16 games this season. Jimmy G being one of them. Yet Jimmy G ranks 19th in attempted passes. Which means their are QBs who played fewer games but still surpassed Jimmy in attempted passes. Why you think that happened? 20 QBs played in 14 or more games. Seems to me his passing was on a leash. You know like most game managers. It hasn't just been during the playoffs.

handicappers · Jan 23, 2020

hopefully there will be 1000 yards passing in the super bowl. That, I'll watch.

Trent Dilfer vs Jimmy Garoppolo playoff stats

Well-Known Member

Throbbing Member

Well-Known Member

Throbbing Member

Well-Known Member

Throbbing Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Throbbing Member

Well-Known Member

Throbbing Member

Well-Known Member

Throbbing Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

NO!...but yes.

FAT STACKS BITCHES

Well-Known Member

Administrator

FAT STACKS BITCHES

Similar threads