Who would you rather have?

romeo212000 · Oct 22, 2018

PPR

Coleman, and Thielen

Or

CMac, and OBJ

If offered the Coleman owner would have Coleman and Ito.

TREFF · Oct 23, 2018

Would rather have CMac and OBJ..not that Thielen isnt great, and I would rather have Thielen than OBJ, but only by the slimmest of margins, and Coleman isnt enough, in a ppr, to make up for CMac.
Hope he doesn't accept

tlance · Oct 23, 2018

romeo212000 said:
PPR

Coleman, and Thielen

Or

CMac, and OBJ

If offered the Coleman owner would have Coleman and Ito.

Agree with Treff.

Would rather have CMac and OBJ pretty easily.

YourFriendGannon · Oct 23, 2018

I kind of view Beckham as a sell high, and Coleman a buy low in the sense of the nearly even timeshare with Ito situation thusfar. And even I'm hard pressed to say I'd want the Thielen/Coleman side. I'm not sure having Ito would factor into my thinking in a trade with stakes that high, but it's a pointless trade in most circumstances anyway unless you're a trade-a-holic type.

romeo212000 · Oct 23, 2018

TREFF said:
Would rather have CMac and OBJ..not that Thielen isnt great, and I would rather have Thielen than OBJ, but only by the slimmest of margins, and Coleman isnt enough, in a ppr, to make up for CMac.
Hope he doesn't accept

I haven’t offered it.

TKOSpikes · Oct 23, 2018

romeo212000 said:
PPR

Coleman, and Thielen

Or

CMac, and OBJ

If offered the Coleman owner would have Coleman and Ito.

CMC, OBJ

TREFF · Oct 23, 2018

romeo212000 said:
I haven’t offered it.

For some reason I read "I offered" instead of "if offered". My bad.

Than don't

romeo212000 · Oct 23, 2018

YourFriendGannon said:
I kind of view Beckham as a sell high, and Coleman a buy low in the sense of the nearly even timeshare with Ito situation thusfar. And even I'm hard pressed to say I'd want the Thielen/Coleman side. I'm not sure having Ito would factor into my thinking in a trade with stakes that high, but it's a pointless trade in most circumstances anyway unless you're a trade-a-holic type.

Not a trade-aholic. Just trying to figure out how to better my situation. My starting WR is loaded with OBJ and Hill, but after that there’s a lot of inconsistency with Fuller, Agholor, and Westbrook. I have one great RB and then a lot of question marks with Hyde, Collins, J. Allen, and Ito. So the way I look at it is I either need to upgrade at RB or add a third borderline WR1. Just trying to figure out how to make my team better.

MilkSpiller22 · Oct 23, 2018

ill be the opposite of everyone... I would rather have thielen/coleman...

the giants pass attack scares me, and although Beckham CAN have the great games, he will probably be very inconsistent... at least very inconsistent for an elite guy... Thielen is the new Eric Decker(in that he is the most consistent player in football), but puts up elite numbers in this consistency...

and although I think CMAC is better than Coleman, CMAC will never be a TD monster because he doesn't break the long ones, and he will always have Cam as the QB who will vulture TDs... It wont be surprising to me to see Coleman get more TDs than CMAC...

so overall I think getting Thielen is worth the deal... He has the consistency to be productive every week, and the eliteness to win you the weeks...

SteelersPride · Oct 23, 2018

cmac and OBJ all day

Bandit · Oct 23, 2018

I'm with the consensus on the CMAC/OBJ side of things

Barilko · Oct 23, 2018

Easy OBJ and Cmac. However i do like ..Thielen as well

wildturkey · Oct 24, 2018

Thielan is clearly a better own than OBJ imo but Coleman doesn't move the needle enough over Cmac. Cmac is a pretty frustrating player this year because 1) He never finds the endzone and 2) The Panthers use him in weird ways. Like he'll run well for a spell and then never run him again. He's effective out of routes, but they rarely throw to him in routes instead he has to make something out of nothing on a dump off. And they don't seem to use him ever (run or pass) around the goal line even though he's on the field just begging for a sweep or pop pass. But he still somehow usually manages to get you 10 pts every week with his combined yardage so he's got a high floor. Coleman just doesn't do enough every week consistently to overcome that.

Sam Sportboy · Oct 24, 2018

CMac?Beckham fer me...............

Who would you rather have?

romeo212000

Self-proclaimed Asshole

TREFF

Fantasy Football Guru--??

tlance

Kyrie Hater

YourFriendGannon

Well-Known Member

romeo212000

Self-proclaimed Asshole

TKOSpikes

Well-Known Member

TREFF

Fantasy Football Guru--??

romeo212000

Self-proclaimed Asshole

MilkSpiller22

Gorilla

SteelersPride

Well-Known Member

Bandit

RIP to the real Bandit

Barilko

Probably at hockey or some dam concert you tell me

wildturkey

Well-Known Member

Sam Sportboy

Can't all be winners kid

Similar threads