Trade - what u think

The Foot · Sep 21, 2018

Side 1
Matt Breada
Doug Baldwin
Jordon Reed

Side 2
Gronk
Shady
Sean Lee

Which side you want on your team?

SmokingMonkey · Sep 21, 2018

Side 1, Lee is prob in his last yr, and reports I've read said he's looked slow out there so far, but I didn't recall seeing him play much vs giants

SteelersPride · Sep 21, 2018

irrelevant without seeing teams again foot come on

Sam Sportboy · Sep 21, 2018

The Foot said:
Side 1
Matt Breada
Doug Baldwin
Jordon Reed

Side 2
Gronk
Shady
Sean Lee

Which side you want on your team?

Not knowing who else is on the teams you freaking goofball, I'd say Side 1 by a mile IMO.

SteelersPride · Sep 21, 2018

Sam Sportboy said:
Not knowing who else is on the teams you freaking goofball, I'd say Side 1 by a mile IMO.

at value side 1

averagejoe · Sep 21, 2018

Gronk > Jordon Reed
Shady > Matt Breada
Doug Baldwin > Sean Lee

Side 2 by default
Also think Breida is a 2018 flash. Don't trust him going forward.
Shady is disappointing, but if this is dynasty, he still may a have a few years left.
Everyone in Buffalo will be fired at the end of the year so he may have new life in 2019.

Bandit · Sep 21, 2018

Side 1 by a landslide if this is your dynasty league. Redraft a little closer but still side 1. I'd rather have Matt Breida right now than even a healthy Shady. I never thought I would type that sentence. LOL.

HaroldSeattle · Sep 21, 2018

Side 1

SteelersPride · Sep 21, 2018

breidas had 1 game......all this hype

RobBase · Sep 21, 2018

Side 2.

TREFF · Sep 21, 2018

SteelersPride said:
breidas had 1 game......all this hype

Actually he's had 18 games, at 5.1 per clip, and the Shanny history to back him up...and is leading the league in rushing..and is only 23.

Shady is 30, with no hope in sight, and bunged up ribs to boot.
Baldwin makes up the difference between Gronk and Reed, Lee is irrelevant.
Pretty easy call

Barilko · Sep 21, 2018

This^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

SteelersPride · Sep 21, 2018

TREFF said:
Actually he's had 18 games, at 5.1 per clip, and the Shanny history to back him up...and is leading the league in rushing..and is only 23.

Shady is 30, with no hope in sight, and bunged up ribs to boot.
Baldwin makes up the difference between Gronk and Reed, Lee is irrelevant.
Pretty easy call

ok again, this season, one big game, and if shanny thought he was the guy, he wouldnt of signed a FA........not saying he cant be good or great, but i dont see the evidence, his ypc is in limiting action...........derrick henry had a good YPC too, but now everyones going away from him

TREFF · Sep 21, 2018

SteelersPride said:
ok again, this season, one big game, and if shanny thought he was the guy, he wouldnt of signed a FA........not saying he cant be good or great, but i dont see the evidence, his ypc is in limiting action...........derrick henry had a good YPC too, but now everyones going away from him

Sure there's the distinct possibility of him hitting a wall. There's also the possibility he's the next Freeman. Regardless, a 30 year old RB on a bad team in a dynasty league, you should actively be trying to get value for him anyways.

SteelersPride · Sep 22, 2018

TREFF said:
Sure there's the distinct possibility of him hitting a wall. There's also the possibility he's the next Freeman. Regardless, a 30 year old RB on a bad team in a dynasty league, you should actively be trying to get value for him anyways.

i agree, for value

TREFF · Sep 22, 2018

SteelersPride said:
i agree, for value

and just what kind of value do you think a 30 year old RB, signed to Buffalo for this year plus two more, averaging 30 yards a game, with a nagging injury, is going to bring? And we're not even touching on the potential for his off field crap to still blow up all over him.

His worth is in name only at this point.

SteelersPride · Sep 22, 2018

TREFF said:
and just what kind of value do you think a 30 year old RB, signed to Buffalo for this year plus two more, averaging 30 yards a game, with a nagging injury, is going to bring? And we're not even touching on the potential for his off field crap to still blow up all over him.

His worth is in name only at this point.

i think it depends on dynasty vs redraft, i can see this is gonna end in an argument so im gonna let it go......

TREFF · Sep 22, 2018

SteelersPride said:
i think it depends on dynasty vs redraft, i can see this is gonna end in an argument so im gonna let it go......

Naw, debate..not argument. Civil, no worries.

And Foot's questions are always about his dynasty (which he calls keeper, but they keep everyone, so it's a dynasty). But, honestly, genuinely curious what you would consider for value for a 30 year old RB in a dynasty situation, even if we discount Buffalo sucking, the rib injury, the off field whatever? Just a fair question, I won't debate the merits of your answer, just curious as to your thoughts on what fair value might be. Might come in handy in future negotiations

SteelersPride · Sep 22, 2018

TREFF said:
Naw, debate..not argument. Civil, no worries.

And Foot's questions are always about his dynasty (which he calls keeper, but they keep everyone, so it's a dynasty). But, honestly, genuinely curious what you would consider for value for a 30 year old RB in a dynasty situation, even if we discount Buffalo sucking, the rib injury, the off field whatever? Just a fair question, I won't debate the merits of your answer, just curious as to your thoughts on what fair value might be. Might come in handy in future negotiations

In that case I’m gonna get back to u with my opinions. Which are foot or milkian. And cause me to get bit in he ass! Just on a phone now would rather type. If I don’t answer I forget just tag me :suds:

SteelersPride · Sep 22, 2018

TREFF said:
Naw, debate..not argument. Civil, no worries.

And Foot's questions are always about his dynasty (which he calls keeper, but they keep everyone, so it's a dynasty). But, honestly, genuinely curious what you would consider for value for a 30 year old RB in a dynasty situation, even if we discount Buffalo sucking, the rib injury, the off field whatever? Just a fair question, I won't debate the merits of your answer, just curious as to your thoughts on what fair value might be. Might come in handy in future negotiations

I guess my opinion is always holding on to vets to long, i think when healthy shady is all they got, hes got to get heavily involved in that offense, especially in a ppr format. Long term no, not great value but maybe 1-2 years. Breida the coaching staff IMHO has alreayd deemed not the guy they want, he may force their hand. BUt i wanna see more the 1 game. i know he has a high YPC, but alot of back ups do. I wouldnt be dumping shady for him just yet. IMHO its impossible to get fair compensation for shady now because hes hurt. If you think hes gonna be hurt all year, then by all means sell for whatever you can get. BUt if he gets healthy i can see a shit load of dink and dunks ala mcaffrey. I dunno am i even making sense? and by all means debate,

Trade - what u think

Well-Known Member

MLS....come to STL!!!

Well-Known Member

Can't all be winners kid

Well-Known Member

You fell victim to one of the classic blunders.

RIP to the real Bandit

Administrator

Well-Known Member

★★★★★

Fantasy Football Guru--??

Probably at hockey or some dam concert you tell me

Well-Known Member

Fantasy Football Guru--??

Well-Known Member

Fantasy Football Guru--??

Well-Known Member

Fantasy Football Guru--??

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Similar threads