Your All Time Favorite Players

[Nosferatu]

Who is your all time favorite player in each of the big four not from your favorite teams who you've seen play...

Mine

MLB - Tony Gwynn
NFL - Lester Hayes
NHL - Guy Lafleur
NBA - Julius Erving

 

[navamind]

NFL - Brian Westbrook
MLB - Chase Utley
NHL - Brett Hull
NBA - Karl Malone

 

[HammerDown]

NFL - Steve Mcnair
MLB - Ken Caminiti (Tony Gwynn being a very close second)
NHL - Jordan Tutu
NBA - Magic Johnson

 

[obxyankeefan]

MLB. Paul Molitor

NFL. Roger Staubach

NHL. Wayne Gretzky

NBA. David Robinson

 

[TDs3nOut]

John Elway
David Thompson/Hakeem Olajuwon
Ivan Rodriguez
Don't watch hockey (I'm straight).

 

[da55bums]

NFL-Nolan Cromwell
NBA-Magic Johnson
MLB-Steve Garvey
NHL-Luke Robitaille

so you watch figure skating?

 

[Nosferatu]

NFL - Steve Mcnair
MLB - Ken Caminiti (Tony Gwynn being a very close second)
NHL - Jordan Tutu
NBA - Magic Johnson

Hammer you didn't follow the rules...

 

[Nosferatu]

John Elway
David Thompson/Hakeem Olajuwon
Ivan Rodriguez
Don't watch hockey (I'm straight).

So you don't watch the best sport to see live? And that makes you straight?

 

[TDs3nOut]

Hammer you didn't follow the rules...

LOL I didn't read your rules well enough to follow them myself, so I'll revise my list, though I still can't come up with a figure skater/ wrestler:

Marcus Allen
Hakeem Olajuwon
George Brett

 

[DragonfromTO]

NFL-Nolan Cromwell
NBA-Magic Johnson
MLB-Steve Garvey
NHL-Luke Robitaille

so you watch figure skating?

Lucky Luc was such an interesting player. Dude had basically only one skill that was even at an NHL level (putting the puck in the net) and he turned it into a Hall of Fame career. He was pretty close to the worst skater in the league for his entire 19 year career, but hockey isn't just a race.

 

[Nosferatu]

LOL I didn't read your rules well enough to follow them myself, so I'll revise my list, though I still can't come up with a figure skater/ wrestler:

Marcus Allen
Hakeem Olajuwon
George Brett

So you still included Hakeem? LOL

 

[TDs3nOut]

So you still included Hakeem? LOL

Eh, he played at UH before I went there and he played a lot of games against my Nuggets.

 

[Nosferatu]

Eh, he played at UH before I went there and he played a lot of games against my Nuggets.

Fair enough, best center i've ever seen play...

 

[Southieinnc]

MLB - Sandy Koufax, Threw a no-hitter on a day that Marichal pitched a 1-hitter against him
NBA - Larry Bird , Had to love the Bird - Magic golden years
NFL - Steve Grogan, walked over to the Pittsburgh side of the line and spit in Jack Lamberts face!
NHL - I'm just a fair-weather hockey fan.

 

[TDs3nOut]

MLB - Sandy Koufax, Threw a no-hitter on a day that Marichal pitched a 1-hitter against him
NBA - Larry Bird , Had to love the Bird - Magic golden years
NFL - Steve Grogan, walked over to the Pittsburgh side of the line and spit in Jack Lamberts face!
NHL - I'm just a fair-weather hockey fan.

^ flagrant rules violations

 

[DragonfromTO]

MLB - Craig Biggio (all-time would be Ron Santo, but I'm too young to have seen him live)
NHL - Mike Bossy (patterned my whole game after him, only with a LH shot)
NBA - Chris Dudley (obviously not an all star, but smart and type 1 diabetic)
NFL - Roger Craig

 

[DragonfromTO]

MLB - Sandy Koufax, Threw a no-hitter on a day that Marichal pitched a 1-hitter against him
NBA - Larry Bird , Had to love the Bird - Magic golden years
NFL - Steve Grogan, walked over to the Pittsburgh side of the line and spit in Jack Lamberts face!
NHL - I'm just a fair-weather hockey fan.

Marichal gave up 4 runs in 5.1 innings when Koufax no-hit the Giants. It was Bob Hendley of the Cubs that threw the one hitter against Koufax's perfect game.

 

[ChicagoIrish]

MLB- Craig Biggio
NFL- Peyton Manning
NHL- Claude Giroux
NBA- Allen Iverson

 

[broncosmitty]

Here are Mine

MLB - Alan Trammell/Matt Nokes/Don Kelly/ Don Mattingly/ Lenny Dykstra/Barry Bonds
NFL - Barry Sanders/Chris Spielman/Randy Moss/ Ronnie Lott
NHL - Steve Chaisson(God rest his soul)/Nick Lidstrom/Juri Fischer/Kirk Maltby
NBA - Dennis Rodman

 

[ChicagoIrish]

Here are Mine

MLB - Alan Trammell/Matt Nokes/Don Kelly/ Don Mattingly/ Lenny Dykstra/Barry Bonds
NFL - Barry Sanders/Chris Spielman/Randy Moss/ Ronnie Lott
NHL - Steve Chaisson(God rest his soul)/Nick Lidstrom/Juri Fischer/Kirk Maltby
NBA - Dennis Rodman

Favorite players not from your team.