- Thread starter
- #81
dbldwn711
Well-Known Member
"How can I make this about Tom Brady"
Hahaha
"Gurley almost won MVP!"
-- Dirt
"How can I make this about Tom Brady"
Your Robin baby
WCO/Andy Reid offense, from which Shurmur derives his offense.And how does that correlate to Shurmur being some wizard of RB receptions?
WCO/Andy Reid offense, from which Shurmur derives his offense.
Although the "wizard" part is just your strawman as far as I know.
Back to the OP's poll, it's definitely the Browns if the talent means anything. They're better on both sides of the ball. The only reason to pick the Giants is if you just do not trust Hue to do anything as a HC which is not totally unfounded.
Statistically, Eli is not better than Tyrod. @Across The Field nailed it on the head a couple posts ago. And you could pretty easily argue his numbers the past two years are probably depressed to a degree due to the absence of Watkins or Watkins playing on a bum foot.A bit overstated, unless we are turning Mayfield into an immediate star, which by the way I think is possible
No matter your thoughts on Eli, he is absolutely better than Tyrod Taylor
A healthy WR corps of Beckham, Engram and Shepard is at least as good, and quite possibly better than Jarvis Landry and Josh Gordon, and that 2nd year TE
The Joe Thomas hit, with the Solder and Hernandez upgrades, should make the Olines comparable
Barkley/James Stewart/Wayne Gallman is gonna be better than Hyde and Duke Johnson
Defensively? We will see, the Giants had a horrible season, but still have a lot of talent that formed one of the better units the season before
Statistically, Eli is not better than Tyrod. @Across The Field nailed it on the head a couple posts ago. And you could pretty easily argue his numbers the past two years are probably depressed to a degree due to the absence of Watkins or Watkins playing on a bum foot.
He's not inaccurate. Where are you getting that?Yuk, sorry, I just think Tyrod Taylor is pretty awful, as in-accurate a QB ive seen in a long time......Maybe that atrocious performance in that playoff game is still fresh
He's not inaccurate. Where are you getting that?
Fair enough, but I don't think the numbers really back you up on that one. Even if you are right however, Mayfield looks like the real deal to me so it may not even matter.My Eyeballs
By almost no qualifying measure is this true, nor has it been for 2-3 years.A bit overstated, unless we are turning Mayfield into an immediate star, which by the way I think is possible
No matter your thoughts on Eli, he is absolutely better than Tyrod Taylor
A healthy WR corps of Beckham, Engram and Shepard is at least as good, and quite possibly better than Jarvis Landry and Josh Gordon, and that 2nd year TE
The Joe Thomas hit, with the Solder and Hernandez upgrades, should make the Olines comparable
Barkley/James Stewart/Wayne Gallman is gonna be better than Hyde and Duke Johnson
Defensively? We will see, the Giants had a horrible season, but still have a lot of talent that formed one of the better units the season before
Fair enough, but I don't think the numbers really back you up on that one.
If you took the Browns roster and put them in Giants jerseys, they'd be looked at as a playoff team. If you took the Giants and put them in Browns jerseys, they're looking at the #1 pick in 2019.
By almost no qualifying measure is this true, nor has it been for 2-3 years.