Top 25 Programs of the CFP Era

[Across The Field]

Oklahoma State and Florida have more of a case then Michigan does. I even said earlier I'd be okay flipping Florida and UGA, but still keeping them ahead of Houston and Boise State.

I'm pretty obviously not just focusing on one season. Not sure what makes you say that?

I've pointed out that for 2/3 of the CFP era, michigan has finished ranked and UGA has finished unranked. You only focus on UGA's one good year and michigan's one bad year, even though in that timeframe michigan has faced a tougher schedule full of significantly more elite teams.

 

[7Samurai13]

3 year span same win total but Oregon has 1 more loss (NCG)
but consider Oregon won their play off game and didn't suffer the worst loss of all playoff games played to date.

Your playoff win was against arguably the worst team to ever make it into the playoffs.

Michigan State T5, 6, unranked
Oregon 2, 19, unranked

 

[ericd7633]

7th and 8th is minimal
5 places with basically the same overall record but Oregons actual playoff resume is better is favoritism and bias

You think I'm pro favor for MSU? LOL. okay?

 

[ericd7633]

I've pointed out that for 2/3 of the CFP era, michigan has finished ranked and UGA has finished unranked. You only focus on UGA's one good year and michigan's one bad year, even though in that timeframe michigan has faced a tougher schedule full of significantly more elite teams.

I'm focusing on all years. Which includes a Michigan season at 5-7. That record is why UGA is tied for 10th in winning % and Michigan is 20th in winning % among P5 teams.

 

[Olyduck]

Did you see the Quack Attack's record last year? They're the suckiest sucks that ever sucked.

last I checked 4 wins was better than 3

 

[Wamu]

last I checked 4 wins was better than 3

Last I checked all of Oregon's 1,234 different uniforms are hideous.

 

[Olyduck]

You think I'm pro favor for MSU? LOL. okay?

I don't see a justification for both teams having 26 wins with Oregon having 1 more loss in 1 more game played.
Oregon having won their playoff game and played in the NCG while Michigan State lost theirs in arguably the worst loss of all 6 playoff games played so far but their ranking falls 5 spots apart

 

[Olyduck]

Last I checked all of Oregon's 1,234 different uniforms are hideous.

nothing to do with the argument. changing the subject is usually what happens when you have no argument.
also not all of them are hideous

 

[Wamu]

nothing to do with the argument. changing the subject is usually what happens when you have no argument.
also not all of them are hideous

Who's arguing? I'm laughing @ you because you seem to be taking my Quack Attack trolling a bit too seriously. Shit I figured you had a sense of humor since your mascot is Donald Duck.

 

[Across The Field]

I'm focusing on all years. Which includes a Michigan season at 5-7. That record is why UGA is tied for 10th in winning % and Michigan is 20th in winning % among P5 teams.

Georgia's weaker schedule with a small fraction of the elite teams michigan has faced is why UGA is tied for 10th in winning % and michigan is 20th. Overall, 2 ranked seasons (both in or right outside the top 10) >> one top 10 season and two unranked years. Both have two double-digit win seasons. Georgia's second one was so pathetically weak they didn't even finish ranked. You're looking at it the way Boise fans say why they're better than almost every P5 team in the last 10 years - racking up wins over inferior opponents.

 

[ericd7633]

I don't see a justification for both teams having 26 wins with Oregon having 1 more loss in 1 more game played.
Oregon having won their playoff game and played in the NCG while Michigan State lost theirs in arguably the worst loss of all 6 playoff games played so far but their ranking falls 5 spots apart

I personally didn't take into account MOL in the CFP. Whether or not that should be a factor is up to debate, but like I said, I didn't factor it. Michigan State also played in a NY6 bowl on top of making the CFP.

 

[ericd7633]

Georgia's weaker schedule with a small fraction of the elite teams michigan has faced is why UGA is tied for 10th in winning % and michigan is 20th. Overall, 2 ranked seasons (both in or right outside the top 10) >> one top 10 season and two unranked years. Both have two double-digit win seasons. Georgia's second one was so pathetically weak they didn't even finish ranked. You're looking at it the way Boise fans say why they're better than almost every P5 team in the last 10 years - racking up wins over inferior opponents.

UGA is tied for 10th in winning %. I have them at 15th. I took that all into account. If Michigan would have been even a top 50ish team in 2014, they'd be above UGA. Even if you averaged out where each team finished in the Massey Composite, UGA still had a better 3 year stretch.

 

[Olyduck]

Who's arguing? I'm laughing @ you because you seem to be taking my Quack Attack trolling a bit too seriously. Shit I figured you had a sense of humor since your mascot is Donald Duck.

false. the mascot is a likeness but not actually Donald Duck.

 

[7Samurai13]

false. the mascot is a likeness but not actually Donald Duck.

Correct, it's direct cheap rip off.

Should have stuck with RoboDuck

 

[Olyduck]

Correct, it's direct cheap rip off.

Should have stuck with RoboDuck

not at all. Oregon AD or pres had a friendship with Walt and they had an agreement to use a similar likeness to Donald

 

[7Samurai13]

not at all. Oregon AD or pres had a friendship with Walt and they had an agreement to use a similar likeness to Donald

Doesn't make it any less than a knock off. You only changed the colors.

 

[Across The Field]

UGA is tied for 10th in winning %. I have them at 15th. I took that all into account. If Michigan would have been even a top 50ish team in 2014, they'd be above UGA. Even if you averaged out where each team finished in the Massey Composite, UGA still had a better 3 year stretch.

Right, like I said, you're only focused on one year instead of two.

 

[Olyduck]

Doesn't make it any less than a knock off. You only changed the colors.

walt designed him so I still don't really see it as a knock off. colors height and design are different

 

[Wamu]

From Wikipedia...

Beginning in 1940, cartoon drawings of Puddles in student publications began to resemble Donald Duck, and by 1947, Walt Disney was aware of the issue. Capitalizing on his friendship w/ a Disney cartoonist, Oregon AD Leo Harris met Disney & reached an informal handshake agreement that granted Oregon permission to use Donald as it's sports mascot, naming him Ronald Duck.

 

[ericd7633]

Right, like I said, you're only focused on one year instead of two.

Or you're just focusing on two instead of three.