TOM BRADY or PEYTON MANNING

[Rock Strongo]

i'll take the one who can still throw a football.

 

[PatsFan2003]

I think Brady controlled the flow of the game better (when they were in their prime) but a lot of that can be on the system/offense, which is true. Brady went down and Cassell stepped in (Matt fucking Cassell) and did great. Brady got suspended, no problem plug in Jimmy G. Oh he went down? No problem plug in Brissett.

Manning just ran his own thing which I don't think is necessarily all great. I remember Dungy or someone basically told him to come off the field on 4th down to punt and he was like, "Nah everyone just stay on" and converted it. The problem with Manning a lot of times is he'd run hurry up and just storm down the field and then the TOP was so fucking lopsided his defense would tire out.

They both played in relatively shit divisions. I dunno, when Manning went down the Colts just sucked ass completely. Brady went down and the Pats were like, "Eh whatever."

I always go Manning personally but it's so close it really doesn't matter.

Cassell didn't do great. He had some good games and was generally ok. There's a reason they didn't make the playoffs. They lost to all the good teams.

 

[Voltaire26]

Both were/are great, I would take either one ... if I had to pick Brady (probably being a Michigan fan has something to do with it). You can't go wrong with Peyton either. Should have been a poll.

 

[Rex Racer]

You'd have to really hate the Patriots to pick "Captain One and Done" over Brady.

 

[megalodon30]

Tebow.

 

[Great Dayne]

So we're having a battle for who's second best behind Aaron Rodgers. I'll take Manning if we're starting from scratch with an average head coach and average team around him.

 

[pitman]

Ask your self, if you swap the two who has more Super Bowls. I'll take Manning

 

[SteelersPride]

aaron rodgers

 

[jarntt]

Peyton. Just a better player

 

[Great Dayne]

aaron rodgers

this is like when they compare Kobe vs Lebron but we all know MJ is the true GOAT. I guess some people on these boards like to find out who wins second place.

 

[Great Dayne]

Tebow.

This is obvious, I mean Tebow did win his first game in the playoffs as a rookie and had a better performance than Manning did in his first game in the postseason with the Broncos the following year as they lost their first game.

Godgers>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Tebow>>>>Manning>>>>>>>>>>Brady

 

[NWPATSFAN]

this is like when they compare Kobe vs Lebron but we all know MJ is the true GOAT. I guess some people on these boards like to find out who wins second place.

Do you like it when AR grabs the back of your head?

 

[Great Dayne]

Do you like it when AR grabs the back of your head?

I like it when the Cheatriots fans whine like little bitches and say their God or team never cheated.

Next please

 

[megalodon30]

Tebow did win his first game in the playoffs as a rookie

 

[sonnyblack65]

this is like when they compare Kobe vs Lebron but we all know MJ is the true GOAT. I guess some people on these boards like to find out who wins second place.

I concur Rodgers is the Steph Curry of QB's

 

[NWPATSFAN]

I like it when the Cheatriots fans whine like little bitches and say their God or team never cheated.

Next please

I'm not judging but all I hear from you is gag gag gag.

 

[GNG]

Who you taking?

(sorry, feeling nostalgic)

Aaron Rodgers.

 

[Great Dayne]

I concur Rodgers is the Steph Curry of QB's

MJ is who every tries to be in the NBA while Rodgers is who every QB aspires to be in the NFL. Both are unattainable as they set the bar to high. Everyone else is fighting for second place.

 

[sonnyblack65]

MJ is who every tries to be in the NBA while Rodgers is who every QB aspires to be in the NFL. Both are unattainable as they set the bar to high. Everyone else is fighting for second place.

Aspire for what ? His no#s aren't staggering, 1 championship PM and Brady both have had 5k seasons and 50 yd seasons, your guy hasn't sniffed either. He is fun to watch like a Steph Curry, makes those long 3 pt shots( Hail Mary's) I know your insecure because this is a 100x rehashed PM vs Brady threw 1 ring guys need not apply

 

[Great Dayne]

I'm not judging but all I hear from you is gag gag gag.

Sexual innuendos and ad hominems means one lacks the mental capacity to substantiate their claims or refute claims of another individual. I appreciate your contributions to this thread as I'm so many others do as well.