QB Rankings 17-19: Next Three QBs

[MHSL82]

Pretty straight forward. Right now, given their current age, not past prime (Peyton) or future prime (Luck), for 2015, who is the next best QB in the NFL? (List of the voted QBs so far below.) If you believe either of those two will be the best NFL QB next year, vote for them, of course. Assume health (besides age or current known issues) and average to above average supporting cast.

Remember, this is for this coming year only.

QB Rankings 1: Aaron Rodgers
QB Rankings 2: Peyton Manning
QB Rankings 3: Andrew Luck
QB Rankings 4: Ben Roethlisberger
QB Rankings 5: Tony Romo
QB Rankings 6: Tom Brady
QB Rankings 7: Philip Rivers
QB Rankings 8: Drew Brees
QB Rankings 9: Joe Flacco
QB Rankings 10: Matt Ryan
QB Rankings 11: Russell Wilson
QB Rankings 12: Matthew Stafford
QB Rankings 13: Carson Palmer
QB Rankings 14: Eli Manning
QB Rankings 15: Alex Smith

Cam Newton rounded out the Top Half of the League over Ryan Tannehill (3) and Teddy Bridgewater (2). Jay Cutler (1) and Colin Kaepernick (1) also received a vote. QB Rankings 16: Cam Newton

To speed things up, I have narrowed the options to those receiving most votes in past polls. In no particular order, Jay Cutler, Nick Foles, Ryan Tannehill, and Teddy Bridgewater have received significantly more votes than Blake Bortles, Derek Carr, Andy Dalton, and Colin Kaepernick.

Teddy Bridgewater was far enough behind the third highest vote-getter, so I didn't provide an option for him to be 17th, just 18th or 19th. I also didn't have room for Nick Foles/Ryan Tannehil/Teddy Bridgewater option. So specify if you feel that's better than all other options.

 

[HammerDown]

@MHSL82 why not just do a poll with all QBs and allow the voter to select three?

 

[Manster7588]

@MHSL82 why not just do a poll with all QBs and allow the voter to select three?

Thats to easy

 

[MHSL82]

@MHSL82 why not just do a poll with all QBs and allow the voter to select three?

That was my original thought, but I thought we'd have a four way tie or couldn't figure out who was 17th versus 18th, etc. I figured if someone received a 11th best vote, a few 12th best, etc., they should have an upper edge to get in. These four were significantly more voted for than the next four.

Next round, I am doing it your way, because there is no real separation there. And a tie for 20/21st is better than 17/18th in my mind.

If we have a tie with the way it is now, I will vote. If there is a three-way tie and me voting would change it to make it to a two way tie, then I'll figure something out.

 

[MHSL82]

Two more days to vote...

 

[Wolvie]

That was my original thought, but I thought we'd have a four way tie or couldn't figure out who was 17th versus 18th, etc. I figured if someone received a 11th best vote, a few 12th best, etc., they should have an upper edge to get in. These four were significantly more voted for than the next four.

Next round, I am doing it your way, because there is no real separation there. And a tie for 20/21st is better than 17/18th in my mind.

If we have a tie with the way it is now, I will vote. If there is a three-way tie and me voting would change it to make it to a two way tie, then I'll figure something out.

Looks like you're gonna have a four way tie anyways

 

[MHSL82]

Looks like you're gonna have a four way tie anyways

Then, I would simply break the tie. I haven't voted yet. I would probably vote for whoever is in the majority if not a tie.