- Thread starter
- #1
mcnabb7542
Resident Fake Asian!
Candid Coaches: The most overrated and underrated coaches in college football
Over rated:
Saban
Harbs
Kelly
Herman
Over rated:
Saban
Harbs
Kelly
Herman
Damn you!Underrated:
InB4 Alaska Guy!
Stupid list among people who don't understand getting to top schools is part of it.
Normal people don't give a fuck that Jim Harbaugh won a conference championship with San Diego St, yet if he was still coaching there, he would have made this list at the top of the under-rated. He gets the over-rated part because he's now at Michigan, and he hasn't done shit. So it's not when you are having success at shit schools that matters, it's what you are able to do on the big stage.
San Diego not San Diego State, why is that important? Well it does mean that Harbaugh has yet to win a FBS conference championship
he never won one at Stanford either, always was 2nd fiddle to Oregon
Calling Saban overrated is a little ridiculous
Brian Kelly would have been overrated a year ago, he's never won any sort of big game either but he's nowhere near as highly regarded after last year's disaster
big fan of the underrated list though
Shitty list or this guy would be on the underrated part.
Doesn't he have the textbook look of an offensive lineman?Rockin the Texas Western hat no less.
Stupid list among people who don't understand getting to top schools is part of it.
Normal people don't give a fuck that Jim Harbaugh won a conference championship with San Diego St, yet if he was still coaching there, he would have made this list at the top of the under-rated. He gets the over-rated part because he's now at Michigan, and he hasn't done shit. So it's not when you are having success at shit schools that matters, it's what you are able to do on the big stage.
Stupid list among people who don't understand getting to top schools is part of it.
Normal people don't give a fuck that Jim Harbaugh won a conference championship with San Diego St, yet if he was still coaching there, he would have made this list at the top of the under-rated. He gets the over-rated part because he's now at Michigan, and he hasn't done shit. So it's not when you are having success at shit schools that matters, it's what you are able to do on the big stage.
Doesn't he have the textbook look of an offensive lineman?
They'll wear Texas Western uniforms every few years. Mainly in hoops though. Tried to get a BB game with Kentucky in the Baltimore area in 2016 to celebrate the 50th year. Kentucky didn't want to play it. Guess it wasn't lucrative enough because they'd have damn sure kicked our ass.
I think he's a very good coach with an enormous ego. So far he hasn't been able to get a superstar at QB or any skill position. His overall record at Michigan is good compared with his most recent predecessors. Until he is able to beat Ohio St he will remain as just very good but not great.
I should have also added that calling Saban overrated is ridiculous considering the number of NC's he's won at Alabama. He appears to be having a bad recruiting season for 2018, but we'll wait until signing day before we judge that.