SoonerAlum
Oklahoman By Choice
Goldbug,
I won't try to convince you because I don't believe you want to be convinced. I will, however, discuss your points.
Josh's performance as a QB coach has zero bearing on Riley's performance as an OC. I don't think anyone here would deny Heupel's ability as both a Heisman runner up and NC winning QB. But those have nothing to do with the job he did in charge of an offense that, since he took over, showed an inherent ability to get any kind of traction.
A list of wins and losses are useless without any supporting data. Why did they lose the games? Crap defense? Injuries to key players? The HC deciding to repunt? (Sorry, I couldn't resist.) I have no idea why they lost those games. And yet I can cut and paste tens of dozens of posts from game threads and this board where the vast majority of us, watching games with our own eyes, placed many of the 13 losses during Josh's four years as OC squarely at his feet. Add to that the INCREDIBLE drop off at the QB position since Josh started splitting duties...
I see this move as a positive because the last time OU took a risk on a young coach from outside the program, it worked out pretty well. I go back to the statement that a Power 5 OC who is at the top of his game would come to OU for a year, MAYBE two. That would make things worse, not better. How is anyone else better than Riley?
My three cents. If you want Bob gone, great. However, he isn't leaving yet and so I say give change a chance.
I won't try to convince you because I don't believe you want to be convinced. I will, however, discuss your points.
Josh's performance as a QB coach has zero bearing on Riley's performance as an OC. I don't think anyone here would deny Heupel's ability as both a Heisman runner up and NC winning QB. But those have nothing to do with the job he did in charge of an offense that, since he took over, showed an inherent ability to get any kind of traction.
A list of wins and losses are useless without any supporting data. Why did they lose the games? Crap defense? Injuries to key players? The HC deciding to repunt? (Sorry, I couldn't resist.) I have no idea why they lost those games. And yet I can cut and paste tens of dozens of posts from game threads and this board where the vast majority of us, watching games with our own eyes, placed many of the 13 losses during Josh's four years as OC squarely at his feet. Add to that the INCREDIBLE drop off at the QB position since Josh started splitting duties...
I see this move as a positive because the last time OU took a risk on a young coach from outside the program, it worked out pretty well. I go back to the statement that a Power 5 OC who is at the top of his game would come to OU for a year, MAYBE two. That would make things worse, not better. How is anyone else better than Riley?
My three cents. If you want Bob gone, great. However, he isn't leaving yet and so I say give change a chance.