Keeper help Appreciated!

[DirtDirtDirt]

Roto/27 rounds

Get to keep just 4

Corey Seager - 21st Round (Lock)
Tommy Pham - 27th round (loving him a lot)
Andrew Benediti - 20th round
Jonathan Schoop - 18th round
Alex Bregman - 23rd round
Travis Shaw - 25th round
Yoan Moncada - 17th round


Thanks for any help

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Roto/27 rounds

Get to keep just 4

Corey Seager - 21st Round (Lock)
Tommy Pham - 27th round (loving him a lot)
Andrew Benediti - 20th round
Jonathan Schoop - 18th round
Alex Bregman - 23rd round
Travis Shaw - 25th round
Yoan Moncada - 17th round


Thanks for any help

pretty easily Seager, Schoop, and Bregman

the 4th is the only question... and it depends on inflation.... If Moncada would remain a 17th round pick NEXT year, then I would take him, otherwise Benetendi...

if you start more than 3 OF(not including DH or U) then I would keep benetendi over Moncada no matter what...

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

pretty easily Seager, Schoop, and Bregman

the 4th is the only question... and it depends on inflation.... If Moncada would remain a 17th round pick NEXT year, then I would take him, otherwise Benetendi...

if you start more than 3 OF(not including DH or U) then I would keep benetendi over Moncada no matter what...

I do start 4

Not a buyer on Tommy Pham?

 

[MilkSpiller22]

I do start 4

Not a buyer on Tommy Pham?

I like him... But benetendi has the higher ceiling and probably the higher floor as well... why would you keep Pham with those choices?? value is irrelevant here...

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

My biggest dilemma with Moncada, do you think he projects as MUCH higher than the 17th round in drafts this season?

Ive seen some mocks that have him in the 10th-12th round range, and not sure if Im getting the best value there

 

[MilkSpiller22]

My biggest dilemma with Moncada, do you think he projects as MUCH higher than the 17th round in drafts this season?

Ive seen some mocks that have him in the 10th-12th round range, and not sure if Im getting the best value there

for him, it is all about the future... a 17th round pick for a potential STUD, is great... as long as it stays a 17th round... and with the rest of your keepers you can take the risk... But, yea, I wouldn't expect anything better than 6th round value from him THIS season... the thing to remember though, is that he is playing 2B and may play some SS... premium fantasy postions, you are more willing to spend on...

BUT with that said the 3 definite keepers are all MI too, so you are in no need for that premium position... and Bregman plays 3B too...

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

for him, it is all about the future... a 17th round pick for a potential STUD, is great... as long as it stays a 17th round... and with the rest of your keepers you can take the risk... But, yea, I wouldn't expect anything better than 6th round value from him THIS season... the thing to remember though, is that he is playing 2B and may play some SS... premium fantasy postions, you are more willing to spend on...

BUT with that said the 3 definite keepers are all MI too, so you are in no need for that premium position... and Bregman plays 3B too...

Thanks, yes, he stays a 17 rounder this season, 4 round penalty each season, I kept him last season as a 21st rounder, 13th rounder next year, etc.etc.etc.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Oh I see what you were saying

The answer is NO on Moncada, 13th rounder NEXT season, 17 this season

I mis-understood

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Oh I see what you were saying

The answer is NO on Moncada, 13th rounder NEXT season, 17 this season

I mis-understood

If he is a 13th next season, I would not keep him at 17th this season... Would rather keep Benintendi...

 

[TKOSpikes]

Seager and Bregman definite locks.
Schoop and Benintendi would be my choices.

 

[thedddd]

Due to the keeper and draft pick model I agree with TKOSpikes post above.