Guys quick need trade advice immediatly

[The Foot]

Side a gets Russel Wilson and Doug Baldwin.

Side B gets cam Newton and Jarvis Landry.

Which side you want on your team.

 

[obxyankeefan]

B for me. especially if it is a keeper or dynasty. While Wilson is more consistent, I tend to think that Newton has more upside. Landry the longer he is in Cleveland the more they will use him for short yardage passing, so his receptions should continue to be in the 80-90+ range.

 

[femurov]

Probably need the scoring system on this one. I'm leaning A right now. I think Wilson will be a stud for years to come.

 

[broncosmitty]

If it's PPR I take B.


If it isn't, I still take B.

 

[broncosmitty]

I wouldn't trade for either QB personally.

But Wilson needs mobility a lot more than Newton based on size.

 

[Yellow Fuzzies]

I like the A side.

 

[averagejoe]

Honestly, sometimes an offense is good because the defense gets them the ball and/or gives them good field position. The losses that Seattle's D suffered this offseason, I think it trickles down to the offense. Seriously.

I'm not saying the Seattle D will be terrible, but Wilson was already running for his life to keep plays alive when the offense had the luxury of a stingy defense. Yet the offense only held the ball (TOP) 29:19 which ranks 24th.

Hope this makes sense?

 

[Bandit]

A for me. Rather have Wilson than Cam by a landslide. Cam is just not a good passer. And you know what you're going to get from Baldwin 80 receptions, close to 1000 yards and 7 or 8 touchdowns while Landry is a bit of a mystery going to a new situation.

 

[TREFF]

A for me, don't trust Can any further than I can throw him

 

[TKOSpikes]

Gimme the Hawks combo. Lots of new pieces for side B.

 

[Barilko]

Wilson/Baldwin pretty solid combo

 

[SteelersPride]

side a

 

[leftypower]

Have to agree on the SEA combo. ... but that oline really scares the heck out of me. Not many QB can be Fran Tarkenton for multiple yrs - and he's already run for his life several now - with Carroll not showing any interest in putting some $$ into protection front of him. ....
If he stays on his feet, it's a very good deal, if not you lose on both the QB and WR - your risk is on upside which clearly belongs to the Wilson/Baldwin duo.

 

[SteelersPride]

h

t

 

[leftypower]

t

Ahh, hit the wrong button but already fixed it. ... a capital T back at ya. ....

 

[SteelersPride]

Ahh, hit the wrong button but already fixed it. ... a capital T back at ya. ....

lol

 

[RobBase]

Tough one. Baldwin is eh. Wilson has the higher upside but Seattle is prone to terrible offensive performances, and they have an unproven run game to go along with their aging D.

So I go w B. Cam ain't pretty but he has bigger potential in the long run. Better team imo.

Landry and Baldwin are a wash tho Landry has the upside factor.

 

[SteelersPride]

Tough one. Baldwin is eh. Wilson has the higher upside but Seattle is prone to terrible offensive performances, and they have an unproven run game to go along with their aging D.

So I go w B. Cam ain't pretty but he has bigger potential in the long run.

Landry and Baldwin are a wash tho Landry has the upside factor.

baldwin balling past 2 years

 

[RobBase]

baldwin balling past 2 years

I had him two years ago and traded high. He had 20 less receptions and failed to reach 1000 yards last season. He's also turning 30. Best days behind him I think.

 

[TREFF]

Tough one. Baldwin is eh. Wilson has the higher upside but Seattle is prone to terrible offensive performances, and they have an unproven run game to go along with their aging D.

So I go w B. Cam ain't pretty but he has bigger potential in the long run. Better team imo.

Landry and Baldwin are a wash tho Landry has the upside factor.

Not seeing an upside factor to Landry..he is exactly what he's shown to be. A very good slot style WR..nothing more, no matter where he's at, or who's throwing the ball, that not upside, that's bumping the ceiling with nowhere to go but sideways or down. Get a real passing system around Baldwin, dude might just joint the elite class