Give Me Your Top 10 QBs For This Year

[Manster7588]

I'm also taking Alex Smith, Case Keenum, or even Andy Dalton. Hell, you could argue pretty well that Josh McCown and even Tyrod Taylor are better QBs.

You're not on the Browns scouting staff are you? I mean if you are it will go a long way in explaining the Browns QB situation they've been stuck in.

 

[Danny Ocho]

TOP 10 QUARTERBACKS
(1) Aaron Rodgers
(2) Tom Brady
(3) Ben Roethlisberger
(4) Russell Wilson
(5) Drew Brees
(6) Matt Ryan
(7) Carson Wentz
(8) Derek Carr
(9) Kirk Cousins
(10) Matthew Stafford

 

[Across The Field]

He had shitty WR's both his years in the league. 3-1 TD/INT ratio is way better than those other guys, outside of Smith. I hope you're right though. I'll gladly take an L on this one.

If his years were flipped around I'd be inclined to believe you, but it seems pretty clear he was a flash in the pan and came back to earth last year. Also, since when does he have a 3-1 TD/INT ratio?

 

[Across The Field]

You're not on the Browns scouting staff are you? I mean if you are it will go a long way in explaining the Browns QB situation they've been stuck in.

Yeah, Dak is sweet. Check out what he did last year when Zeke wasn't there to bail him out.

 

[ericd7633]

If his years were flipped around I'd be inclined to believe you, but it seems pretty clear he was a flash in the pan and came back to earth last year. Also, since when does he have a 3-1 TD/INT ratio?

And his back to earth year was about the 15th-18th best QB in the league. And I have him 15th. You could argue him at 16th/17th and I would be fine, but I gave my reasonings why I'm down on Smith.

He has 45 TD's and 17 INT's in his career. 2.65 - 1, I guess then. For some reason I thought he had 15 INT's in his career.

 

[Fountain City Blues]

where is fn mahomes

Top 5... in fantasy

 

[Manster7588]

Yeah, Dak is sweet. Check out what he did last year when Zeke wasn't there to bail him out.

The offense had a lot more issues than just Zeke being out. OL was a mess, and Dez had a bad case of the drops. With all that he wasn't a QB.

If he sits somewhere between 2016 and 17 he will be a top 10 QB.

 

[PDay8810]

Yeah, Dak is sweet. Check out what he did last year when Zeke wasn't there to bail him out.

3-3 without Zeke and 5-4 with Zeke not counting the last meaningless game when philly sat their starters
23 TD's and 4 Ints his rookie season...you're right that's 5-1 TD to Int ratio
Last season 22 TD's and 13 INTs along with 32 sacks and a 62.9% comp % ...also had a league best QBR rating at 109.9 when the other team blitzed while Dez lead the league in drops isn't the trash you seem to think.

Capital I when you run your mouth about Dak.
Stupid is a terrible way to go through life and you show it well talking here.

 

[megalodon30]

1. Brady
2. Rodgers
3. Brees
4. Wentz
5. Roethlisberger
6. Ryan
7. Wilson
8. Stafford
9. Goff
10. Jimmy G

 

[broncosmitty]

Well we aren't talkin fantasy football for this thread.

Slip Lil Rusty in there somewhere then.

 

[broncosmitty]

But Jimmy G somehow makes your list? I can accept Wentz not being on peoples top 10 list. Hell, he is a second year QB going into his third and coming off a torn ACL so it could be jumping the gun to consider him elite. However... I find it laughable that Jimmy G makes any top 10 list.

Why?

He's been in the League longer than Wentz. Played more preseason games. Practiced more. Has never lost a start. Has a fully functioning knee...


Sorry, I'm not an Iggles fan, Im not obligated to see his situation thru rose colored glasses. Homer.

 

[Ricky Roma]

Put on a much, much better show than Garoppolo did.

Yup....there wasn't any part of JG's game or stats that you can question...nothing that stood out except that he took over a 1-10 team and led them to 6-10. Nobody is sure what SF has around them, so it's only fair to say that he totally elevated the play around him at this point. That is a mark of greatness. Watson's TD % alone, was stupid...he'll never come close to that....and that alone made his stats pop out moreso, but he also had one of the best receivers in the game.

Simply put, if you think it's ridiculous to put JG in any top 10 list of QB's because of the limited playing time, I believe it's equally ridiculous to include D. Watson.

 

[Across The Field]

And his back to earth year was about the 15th-18th best QB in the league. And I have him 15th. You could argue him at 16th/17th and I would be fine, but I gave my reasonings why I'm down on Smith.

He has 45 TD's and 17 INT's in his career. 2.65 - 1, I guess then. For some reason I thought he had 15 INT's in his career.

He was awful when Zeke was suspended, and again, he lost 3 of his top 4 receivers. Terrence Williams is a nice 2nd or 3rd WR, but not a #1. Dak will not be top 18 this year, unless someone suddenly turns into a star that isn't in that receiving group. Losing Witten is going to hurt a lot more than you realize.

 

[Across The Field]

3-3 without Zeke and 5-4 with Zeke not counting the last meaningless game when philly sat their starters
23 TD's and 4 Ints his rookie season...you're right that's 5-1 TD to Int ratio
Last season 22 TD's and 13 INTs along with 32 sacks and a 62.9% comp % ...also had a league best QBR rating at 109.9 when the other team blitzed while Dez lead the league in drops isn't the trash you seem to think.

Capital I when you run your mouth about Dak.
Stupid is a terrible way to go through life and you show it well talking here.

Team record isn't what we're talking about. Again, he lost 3 of his top 4 receivers. Not going to be a good year for Dak.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

He was awful when Zeke was suspended, and again, he lost 3 of his top 4 receivers. Terrence Williams is a nice 2nd or 3rd WR, but not a #1. Dak will not be top 18 this year, unless someone suddenly turns into a star that isn't in that receiving group. Losing Witten is going to hurt a lot more than you realize.

Terrance Williams isnt even a Top 4 on a good team

 

[PDay8810]

Team record isn't what we're talking about. Again, he lost 3 of his top 4 receivers. Not going to be a good year for Dak.

LOL...It's not what YOU'RE talking about NOW

and who is this 3rd WR you keep running your mouth about?

Dallas will be more than fine at wide receiver. I will even say they will be a top 10 offence this year

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

LOL...It's not what YOU'RE talking about NOW

and who is this 3rd WR you keep running your mouth about?

Dallas will be more than fine at wide receiver. I will even say they will be a top 10 offence this year

I dont know how you draw that conclusion, but good luck

 

[FaCe-LeE-uS]

LOL...It's not what YOU'RE talking about NOW

and who is this 3rd WR you keep running your mouth about?

Dallas will be more than fine at wide receiver. I will even say they will be a top 10 offence this year

I've got Dallas at 9-7, primarily hinging on the success of their offense. If Dak can play game manager with success then I could see 10 wins. But he's not going to be a top 10 QB.

 

[ericd7633]

He was awful when Zeke was suspended, and again, he lost 3 of his top 4 receivers. Terrence Williams is a nice 2nd or 3rd WR, but not a #1. Dak will not be top 18 this year, unless someone suddenly turns into a star that isn't in that receiving group. Losing Witten is going to hurt a lot more than you realize.

His receivers weren't any good in 2016 either or are the same guys for this season. Minus Witten. I hope Dak sucks, that would make me lmao all year. I just don't think he will.

 

[PDay8810]

I've got Dallas at 9-7, primarily hinging on the success of their offense. If Dak can play game manager with success then I could see 10 wins. But he's not going to be a top 10 QB.

Other than the three I mentioned in this thread, I'm not sure who will be a top 10 QB. I give Dak as good a chance as many listed in this thread. We'll see how this all turns out soon enough.