Giants GM says if you've got a top pick you need to

[rmilia1]

Be able to picture that guy making the Hall of Fame .

In this draft who could you see doing that??

 

[Sharkonabicycle]

Hmm Barkley and Nelson are the easy discussions to have since they are the best players in the class by a decent margin IMO to boot.

I don't see any of the QBs coming close. Darnold has confidence and turnover issues, Rosen needs to mature and could be Bortles #2, Allen is WAY to raw, if you can't complete 60%+ of your passes in college good luck in the NFL. Who is the other guy? uhhh... oh yah Mayfield... meh.

Probably the QB with the best shot is if a contender (Pittsburgh, New England, even San Diego, top 5 D, etc.) selects one late. None of the QBs that are getting taken early are immediate starting material IMO. They all need to sit. I guess if the Giants take someone that gives them a legit shot too since Eli will start this year, but the Giants team is terrible and OBJ will prob. walk after this year to FA.

 

[shopson67]

Be able to picture that guy making the Hall of Fame .

In this draft who could you see doing that??

Like their recent early 1st rounders Apple and Flowers?

 

[Fountain City Blues]

This is hysterical coming from the Giants

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Barkley
Nelson
Chubb

And if i had to bet, at least one of the QB's


I only want Barkley or one of the QB's

 

[Fountain City Blues]

For shits and giggles

I’d throw a dart at Roquan Smith and Derwin James I guess. Nelson maybe? It’s all kind of absurd.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

Like their recent early 1st rounders Apple and Flowers?

Well, our GM was working in Carolina for those picks

 

[rmilia1]

Like their recent early 1st rounders Apple and Flowers?

Yeah I was more talking to the idea not who said it lol

 

[shopson67]

Yeah I was more talking to the idea not who said it lol

It's true to a point, in that you always need to pick the best players possible. However, if you let your self be blinded by upside instead of real production, you get some horrible busts as a result.

 

[fordman84]

The reality is this draft will see more guys not drafted in the 1st round end up making the HOF than guys drafted in the first round. I know the odds are that way, but still what will happen.

 

[jarntt]

I think Michael Dickson (Texas) has a chance to make the HOF. Maybe the Giants take him at #2?

 

[jarntt]

Be able to picture that guy making the Hall of Fame .

In this draft who could you see doing that??

I'll get back to you after pick #19 with my unbiased choice

 

[Fountain City Blues]

It's true to a point, in that you always need to pick the best players possible. However, if you let your self be blinded by upside instead of real production, you get some horrible busts as a result.

Josh Allen dislikes this

 

[Fountain City Blues]

This is hysterical coming from the Giants

>Create huge shitstorm by implying you will trade a potential HOF talent at WR

>Immediately turns around and acts like they're drafting a HOF'er at 2, can make the playoffs with a zombified Eli Manning, and trade Odell while doing so.

>Imply they won't take a QB despite the above

>Proceeds to act like this totally makes sense

 

[Fountain City Blues]

For as much as I like Chubb, I get the impression looking at his college career and athletic profile he will probably just be pretty good. Still super valuable, but I doubt HOF potential is there.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

>Create huge shitstorm by implying you will trade a potential HOF talent at WR

>Immediately turns around and acts like they're drafting a HOF'er at 2, can make the playoffs with a zombified Eli Manning, and trade Odell while doing so.

>Imply they won't take a QB despite the above

>Proceeds to act like this totally makes sense

Perfect! Exactly how we want it

Keep all possibilities open with the star WR, publicly demand a kings ransom

Dont tip your hand at all about your intentions with the #2 pick, toss out smoke screens left and right


Its all good from my perspective

 

[Iggloo]

Possible guys:

Barkley
Nelson
Rosen
Roquon Smith (if he landed with a 4-3 team that put him at WLB).

 

[fordman84]

Perfect! Exactly how we want it

Keep all possibilities open with the star WR, publicly demand a kings ransom

Dont tip your hand at all about your intentions with the #2 pick, toss out smoke screens left and right


Its all good from my perspective

...and in the end fuck it up because your talent evaluation is shit, and karma is a bitch mr Mara.

 

[DirtDirtDirt]

...and in the end fuck it up because your talent evaluation is shit, and karma is a bitch mr Mara.

This is only so funny cause you're a Cowboys fan

 

[4down20]

Minkah Fitzpatrick - has the skills to do it, but more importantly has the work ethic and drive to make it happen.