Alright you RB lovers...

[MilkSpiller22]

D1..offer away, I've still got him

Nah. D1 is a no. But would have definitely wanted him in D2

 

[TREFF]

Nah. D1 is a no. But would have definitely wanted him in D2

Lol..see what i mean?

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Lol..see what i mean?

But D1 is a non ppr with 2 WR+ flex. In a 3 WR + flex WR depth is more important. So I would love many high end potential guys on my bench.

 

[TREFF]

But D1 is a non ppr with 2 WR+ flex. In a 3 WR + flex WR depth is more important. So I would love many high end potential guys on my bench.

True but the relevant comparative situation is our D1, 14 team, 18 spot roster vs EHB's 12 team, 32 spot roster, not D2 . Even factoring in ppr vs non ppr, the need for WR depth is comparable

 

[MilkSpiller22]

True but the relevant comparative situation is our D1, 14 team, 18 spot roster vs EHB's 12 team, 32 spot roster, not D2 . Even factoring in ppr vs non ppr, the need for WR depth is comparable

Disagree. Because his league is ppr and 3 WR+ flex. The 3 WR format is a game changer because you don't hoard RB as much. You just can't, you need WR depth

 

[ehb5]

Well, in D1, i basically got him as a throw in with Maclin for my Malcolm Mitchell. Unless something crazy gets dropped during round 5 of our draft, I'll be hanging into him for a little while. Until about the time of Randy Moss, it used to be a 3 year rule for receivers. . as in, don't expect much for about 3 years. Maybe he's one of those?

Could be. Worries me that they have diggs, thielen, and floyd now though. No easy path to playing time to figure it out.

 

[TREFF]

Could be. Worries me that they have diggs, thielen, and floyd now though. No easy path to playing time to figure it out.

As a first round pick, he really should've never let Theilen see the field to begin with

 

[ehb5]

Alright crisis averted was able to land tyrod for treadwell and a 3rd. Thanks for all the responses and help everybody

 

[TREFF]

Alright crisis averted was able to land tyrod for treadwell and a 3rd. Thanks for all the responses and help everybody

Wow..i don't know about the value of a third and how your drafts usually go, but seems like a great deal for you to me

 

[ehb5]

Wow..i don't know about the value of a third and how your drafts usually go, but seems like a great deal for you to me

I think it could be a win win. I need the qb and he certainly doesn't. Treadwell may be off to a rocky start but at least he has the potential to be worth much more than Taylor. I'm happy though.

 

[Stomp]

I hate to give up on Treadwell so quickly but I need the QB and I dont really trust him.

He's only 21 not many wide receivers that are that age doing much of anything at the NFL level. Give him some time.

 

[eaglesnut]

I agree. Ideally Id pick up somebody else but there are really only 6 teams with at least 3 QBs on roster. (I figure I need to target those teams since I cant really send a QB of any value back)

One of them has Eli, Mariota, and Luck but is incredibly difficult to trade with so I dont have much hope there.
One of them has Stafford, Dalton, and Siemian, but thats reliant on Siemian actually being the starter in DEN.
One of them has Kirk, Dak, and Rivers. He might be my best hope but so far I havent been able to get anywhere.
One of them has Cam, Smith, and Watson. I may try for Smith here. Watson will likely be pricier.
One of them has Bradford, Tyrod, Wentz, Kizer, Ryan, and Hackenburg. Ive had talks with him but I think Id have to give up Paul Perkins for Tyrod which might be a bit more than I want to give up.
One of them has Hoyer, Goff, Tannehill, Flacco, and Trubisky but has asked for downright ridiculous offers for Goff and Hoyer so Ive pretty much given up here.

Try to get Eli. Is that guy scared of injury to his other two? Ask him if he is and then ask him which guy he's most worried about getting injured and then trade for him.

The guy with Wentz and Ryan should be pretty comfortable moving Tyrod or Bradford. I'd try for Bradford, the offense has no where to go but up and he was actually 20/5 last year as it was. Perkins has too much upside to swing right now I would think.

 

[eaglesnut]

Alright crisis averted was able to land tyrod for treadwell and a 3rd. Thanks for all the responses and help everybody

Tyrod will get you through the year at least. And you are set at WR anyway. Might be kicking yourself in 3-5 years though if Treadwell ever lives up to the hype.

 

[SmokingMonkey]

i think you made out great here - yea, Treadwell could turn into something great, but you had some top notch WR depth, and Tyrod could be your legit starter for a few seasons until you can get that 10yr guy at QB

 

[Brees#1]

For some reason I have the cards bouncing back with an easy schedule, so I would do the trade.

 

[eaglesnut]

For some reason I have the cards bouncing back with an easy schedule, so I would do the trade.

Some reason other than the easy schedule? Like what?