1990 to Present Draft QF 3 : Milk vs Shane

[Nosferatu]

MILK

OFFENSE
QB - Brett Favre
RB - Chris Johnson
RB - Jerome Bettis
WR - Terrell Owens
WR - Andre Johnson
WR - T.Y. Hilton
TE - Tony Gonzalez
LT - Jake Long
LG - Logan Mankins
C - Ryan Kalil
RG - Jahri Evans
RT - Willie Anderson

DEFENSE
DE - Hugh Douglas
DT - Geno Atkins
DT - Cortez Kennedy
DE - John Abraham
OLB - Jessie Armstead
MLB - Jeremiah Trotter
OLB - Julian Peterson
CB - Marcus Peters
CB - Chris McAlister
CB - Dominque Rodgers-Cromartie
SS - Troy Polamalu
FS - Brian Dawkins

VS

SHANE

OFFENSE
QB - Steve McNair
FB - Mike Tolbert
RB - LaDainian Tomlinson
WR - Isaac Bruce
WR - Herman Moore
TE - Shannon Sharpe
TE - Ben Coates
LT - Jonathan Ogden
LG - Kris Dielman
C - Tom Nalen
RG - Shawn Andrews
RT - Erik Williams

DEFENSE
DE - Justin Smith
NT - Pat Williams
DE - Haloti Ngata
OLB - Jason Gildon
ILB - NaVorro Bowman
ILB - Patrick Willis
OLB - Clay Matthews
CB - Champ Bailey
CB - Antoine Winfield
CB - Deltha O'Neal
SS - Darren Woodson
FS - Bob Sanders

 

[Nosferatu]

MILK - 6
SHANE - 4

VOTED - Shane, Mebert, WLK, 500, Milk, Femur, Nos, UK, Pride, Sushi

 

[Nosferatu]

I think Milk has a dangerous offense and I love his safeties but I dont see him getting pressure on Mcnair. Mcnair was underrated and I think he perfect to run this offense. He had a dual threat guy alongside of him in LT. He has the deep threat guy with Bruce and big possession WR with Moore but most importantly he has two dangerous TE's. He also has a legit blocking for him. My defense can get pressure on Favre and force him into making mistakes which he prone to do. I just dont think CJ is a good matchup against my front 7 which is pretty solid. Having a feisty Champ on TO will make the difference in this one, probably rattle him some. I think my offense is too much for his defense and his CB's can matchup with my weapons for 4 quarters in this one.

FROM SHANE

 

[Mebert]

Shane

 

[wlk3]

I think shane pulls it out with a better oline...

 

[Pack 500]

Shane

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Man, am I shocked... I really don't get how I am going to lose this match... Shane, I liked your team, but in no way is it better than mine...

I am not a brett Favre fan, but I don't see how he is not the third best QB in this mock...

My duo RB is unstoppable as I have the best and fastest speed back in this mock paired with the best power back in this mock... Neither are top backs in this mock, but together, that is unstoppable!!!

I have the best TE in football, and 2 of the best WRs in this mock... And TY Hilton is one of the better speed receivers in this mock...

My offensive line is not great, but it is solid throughout...

In no way can he stop my offense... Also, I don't see where his defense is better than mine... Cant put up pressure?? John Abraham is one of the better sack guys in this mock, and my DTs are one of the best in this mock... Not to mention Troy Polamalu is known for that jump play to get his own sacks as well...

My secondary is anchored by the 2nd and third best safety in this mock... My CBs are not a strength, but in no way are they a liability...

 

[femurov]

Milk

 

[Shanemansj13]

Man, am I shocked... I really don't get how I am going to lose this match... Shane, I liked your team, but in no way is it better than mine...

I am not a brett Favre fan, but I don't see how he is not the third best QB in this mock...

My duo RB is unstoppable as I have the best and fastest speed back in this mock paired with the best power back in this mock... Neither are top backs in this mock, but together, that is unstoppable!!!

I have the best TE in football, and 2 of the best WRs in this mock... And TY Hilton is one of the better speed receivers in this mock...

My offensive line is not great, but it is solid throughout...

In no way can he stop my offense... Also, I don't see where his defense is better than mine... Cant put up pressure?? John Abraham is one of the better sack guys in this mock, and my DTs are one of the best in this mock... Not to mention Troy Polamalu is known for that jump play to get his own sacks as well...

My secondary is anchored by the 2nd and third best safety in this mock... My CBs are not a strength, but in no way are they a liability...

Idk I think your LB's and CB's are average or below average for this mock. I also have Sharpe and Coates, basically at top 3 and top 5 in this mock. My WR's are underrated and you have matchup problems.

Manning, Brady and Rodgers are all better than Favre and it isnt close. IMO your LB's are the issue with my TE's and I have some pretty nasty LB's and a better overall secondary. My o-line is pretty good too. I see Hugh Douglas basically sitting out this one lol

 

[Nosferatu]

Milk

 

[UK Cowboy]

This is a really tough one to call. I like McNair, but Favre is certainly better, and his weapons really fit his style, T.O. and Gonzalez would cause major problems in the middle of the field, which would tie up the safeties. Shane has a guy in Champ who can match up, but Winfield, while a good and tough player, would have major trouble trying to check the bigger Johnson or T.O. I also don't see any pass rush for Shane outside Matthews.
Milk has a better pass rush, but Shane has an excellent OLine. With McNair, he would be playing more of a ball control game IMO, but his D wouldn't make enough stops for that to work. A really great game

Milk

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Idk I think your LB's and CB's are average or below average for this mock. I also have Sharpe and Coates, basically at top 3 and top 5 in this mock. My WR's are underrated and you have matchup problems.

Manning, Brady and Rodgers are all better than Favre and it isnt close. IMO your LB's are the issue with my TE's and I have some pretty nasty LB's and a better overall secondary. My o-line is pretty good too. I see Hugh Douglas basically sitting out this one lol

your right... i for some reason always forget about Rodgers... But i do think favre is close to Rodgers...

I will agree that my LBs and CBs are my team's weakness... but my safeties hide my CBs well...

 

[SteelersPride]

i got milk all day.

Now why can a 5t in ngata play DE here? im confused? i cant put freeney at DE in a 3-4 but a 5t can play DE?

 

[SteelersPride]

your right... i for some reason always forget about Rodgers... But i do think favre is close to Rodgers...

I will agree that my LBs and CBs are my team's weakness... but my safeties hide my CBs well...

yup

 

[MilkSpiller22]

i guess i counted myself out too soon... After seeing pack pick against his boy Brett favre, i thought that i had no chance of winning...

 

[CitySushi]

I got Milk here by a narrow margin.

 

[SteelersPride]

two quickies for milk swings the game

 

[CitySushi]

i got milk all day.

Now why can a 5t in ngata play DE here? im confused? i cant put freeney at DE in a 3-4 but a 5t can play DE?

Haloti is 6'4, 340lbs.

Freeney is 6'1, 268lbs.

DE's in a 3/4 almost act like defensive tackles, since you have an OLB pass rush. Put it this way, could you play Freeney as a DT in a 4-3? Probably not because he's not big enough to get a push up front. IMO.

 

[SteelersPride]

Haloti is 6'4, 340lbs.

Freeney is 6'1, 268lbs.

DE's in a 3/4 almost act like defensive tackles, since you have an OLB pass rush. Put it this way, could you play Freeney as a DT in a 4-3? Probably not because he's not big enough to get a push up front. IMO.

 

[CitySushi]

????