Rank Em

tlance · Jul 24, 2016

SteelersPride said:
tlance and harold

who would your keepers be

It would definitely be Johnson and a WR, just not sure which.
Evans gives you 2 years, but Warkins provides the best value this year with round 7. I would be choosing between those 2, because I think you are splitting hairs when projecting output this season. There have been really compelling cases made for all 3, so it comes down to your gut, and that sounds to me like Yours is saying Evans.

tlance · Jul 24, 2016

averagejoe said:
Excellent point.
Checked my distribution numbers.
While Tampa was fairly consistent with other NFL teams in throwing to the WR position (51% of passes went to the WR), only 26% of TD passes went to a Tampa WR, which was the 4th-lowest WR TD percentage in the NFL.

My guess would be that Winston being a rookie was a big part. I read somewhere (if I am remembering right) that TB had an extremely low passing % in the red zone and went jumbo or goalline more than most. I would think that Winston would have more opportunity in year 2, but even if not, Evans should still be in the field in most jumbo packages.

TKOSpikes · Jul 25, 2016

TREFF said:
Nor did he last year, for the most part. Was last year a bad blip, or was his rookie year the fluke? He didn't come through as the #1 very often in VJAX's absence is all that is known

Actually, his best games last year came when VJax was out.

I feel like I remember VJax and Winston getting a lot of training camp/preseason together, and I remember being worried about Evans for that reason.... could be wrong.

I suspect Evans will be more like his second half, than his first half.

TREFF · Jul 25, 2016

TKOSpikes said:
Actually, his best games last year came when VJax was out.

I feel like I remember VJax and Winston getting a lot of training camp/preseason together, and I remember being worried about Evans for that reason.... could be wrong.

I suspect Evans will be more like his second half, than his first half.

True, yet so did a couple of his worst ones. .he's an enigma of sorts, hard to finger. .another reason why with similar options, I'd go another route

ehb5 · Jul 25, 2016

I'm confused. Evans didn't have a bad year last year. Fantasy wise he was a little underwhelming due to a lack of TDs but I think he played pretty well. If he regresses to the mean on TDs you should be looking at a very good fantasy WR for 2 years.

SteelersPride · Aug 7, 2016

OK after lots of debate where do we go

i have tohave them in by sunday night

david johnson-3
thomas rawls-3
sammy watkins-7
ty hilton-5
mike evans-4

can keep the draft year, plus two additional years
1 full PPR
Have already kept hilton and watkins 1 year

i know weve gone on and on

im thinking david johnson and evans
due to the +2 years

TKOSpikes · Aug 7, 2016

Johnson and Rawls (assuming it's R3 and 4?)

Sorry if already mentioned.... is this a 2 WR and flex or 3 WR?
A 3 WR league would bump Rawls for me, in which case I guess I'd take Evans ONLY because of the extra year.

SteelersPride · Aug 7, 2016

TKOSpikes said:
Johnson and Rawls (assuming it's R3 and 4?)

Sorry if already mentioned.... is this a 2 WR and flex or 3 WR?
A 3 WR league would bump Rawls for me, in which case I guess I'd take Evans ONLY because of the extra year.

2RB, 3WR, and a flex...........

12 teams

pickings are slim

TKOSpikes · Aug 7, 2016

SteelersPride said:
2RB, 3WR, and a flex...........

12 teams

pickings are slim

Yeah... geez! Tough choices. I guess that bumps Rawls for me, but I'd be pulling my hair out if I were you.

Evans... keep him longer, but PPR hurts his value, imo.
Watkins... offense is scary, one year lost, but three round difference might make him the best choice.
Hilton... kind of stuck in the middle of the other two, better value to Evans, more catches than both, but double digit TD seems tougher than it does with the others.

Sorry... probably just making it harder on you

SteelersPride · Aug 7, 2016

I know it's rough call, Rawls injury hurts his value, and him not being a ppr back,

Watkins injury scares me, plus he has been hurt plus I used him once, when he plays he's a no doubt top 5-7 guy....

Hilton with luck is a monster but can only use for 1 year

Evans had 68, 74 catches I think bw 70-80 is reasonable with I high ypc .,.. :noidea:

SteelersPride · Aug 7, 2016

TKOSpikes said:
Yeah... geez! Tough choices. I guess that bumps Rawls for me, but I'd be pulling my hair out if I were you.

Evans... keep him longer, but PPR hurts his value, imo.
Watkins... offense is scary, one year lost, but three round difference might make him the best choice.
Hilton... kind of stuck in the middle of the other two, better value to Evans, more catches than both, but double digit TD seems tougher than it does with the others.

Sorry... probably just making it harder on you

sad thing is...... I have aj green, devante Parker, Sanu, Chris ivory, Arian foster, tyrod Taylor...... in a league that size..... and can't use em

MilkSpiller22 · Aug 7, 2016

I am not a huge Watkins fan, but with a 3 WR+ flex league and a 7th round value, he is my definite keep....

then IMO it comes down to David Johnson, Mike evans and TY hilton...

without round value I rank them

1. Johnson
2. Evans
3. Hilton

since all are within 1 or 2 rounds, i would go with who i like best which for me would be Johnson....

So i would be keeping Watkins and Johnson...

eaglesnut · Aug 8, 2016

Watkin's last 6 games
6-158-2
3-109-1
5-81-1
5-111-2
5-84-0
11-136-0

Huge uptick in targets started around then. That should continue.

Rank Em

tlance

Kyrie Hater

tlance

Kyrie Hater

TKOSpikes

Well-Known Member

TREFF

Fantasy Football Guru--??

ehb5

HTTR

SteelersPride

Well-Known Member

TKOSpikes

Well-Known Member

SteelersPride

Well-Known Member

TKOSpikes

Well-Known Member

SteelersPride

Well-Known Member

SteelersPride

Well-Known Member

MilkSpiller22

Gorilla

eaglesnut

Well-Known Member

Similar threads