Who is better in 5 years, Trout or Harper?

Beggs · May 29, 2012

I've been a big fan of trout for a few years. He has been getting better at the plate every month since having a rough time after being brought up. We really havent had enough time to completely evaluate harper, but he hits for power, and has a hell of an arm.

Who is your bet to be the better player?

hokiehi21 · May 30, 2012

Bryce! But I'm not biased or anything.

DaBoltsNIsles · May 31, 2012

The simple fact that Trout was a 25th round pick says the Angels win this one. They got Trombo in the 18th round. Talk about great scouting.

powerchord86 · Jun 1, 2012

This could be a big argument for years to come.

The next Mantle vs. Mays discussion.

romeo212000 · Jun 3, 2012

Trout's a total douche bag. The jury's still out on Harper for me.

TexasMan · Jun 19, 2012

powerchord86 said:
This could be a big argument for years to come.

The next Mantle vs. Mays discussion.

or Aaron v Clemente

raptorlife4 · Jun 19, 2012

Ill take Lawrie

black francis · Sep 20, 2017

Trout

Voltaire26 · Sep 20, 2017

powerchord86 said:
This could be a big argument for years to come.

The next Mantle vs. Mays discussion.

Willie Mays ... both were great.

TexasMan said:
or Aaron v Clemente

Roberto Clemente ... classier person as well.

Trout v. Harper

Same as Aaron v Clemente ... Trout is better and classier!!!

navamind · Sep 21, 2017

Domonic Brown

The Derski · Sep 21, 2017

I think the douche bag label definitely goes to Harper 5 years later.

DirtDirtDirt · Sep 21, 2017

Trout
Harpers' playing style is gonna lead to a lot of DL stints

Rock Strongo · Sep 21, 2017

lars anderson

navamind · Sep 21, 2017

raptorlife4 said:
Ill take Lawrie

lol

Mondo Jay · Sep 21, 2017

Voltaire26 said:
Willie Mays ... both were great.

Roberto Clemente ... classier person as well.

Trout v. Harper

Same as Aaron v Clemente ... Trout is better and classier!!!

How is Clemente "classier" than Aaron?

tducey · Sep 21, 2017

Might have took Harper back then but it's Trout now.

JohnU · Sep 21, 2017

Neither.

Voltaire26 · Sep 21, 2017

Mondo Jay said:
How is Clemente "classier" than Aaron?

For some reason, I have always disliked Aaron, and I have always thought of Clemente as pure class. It's just a personal thing ... Hank Aaron v Tommy Aaron - I'm going with Tommy!

Mondo Jay · Sep 21, 2017

Voltaire26 said:
For some reason, I have always disliked Aaron, and I have always thought of Clemente as pure class. It's just a personal thing ... Hank Aaron v Tommy Aaron - I'm going with Tommy!

I can't imagine disliking Aaron. Personally, I love Clemente as a person and as a force for good (philanthropy), but unless it is a greenie thing with Hank, he seems to have been a great player and ambassador for the game.

It seems you would rather not elaborate on your feelings about HA. I will respect that.

Naturally, these are personal opinions of mine...

Nosferatu · Sep 21, 2017

Voltaire26 said:
Willie Mays ... both were great.

Roberto Clemente ... classier person as well.

Trout v. Harper

Same as Aaron v Clemente ... Trout is better and classier!!!

As much as I like Clemente there is no way he was a better player than Aaron.

I do agree with both points on Trout.

Who is better in 5 years, Trout or Harper?

Nipples of a God

DC sports are cursed

PLAYOFFS OR BUST!!

Tolerator

Self-proclaimed Asshole

mfw reading SportsHoopla

Long Time Member

Well-Known Member

Detroit Born and Raised

Well-Known Member

No Fat Chicks

Well-Known Member

My mind spits with an enormous kickback.

Well-Known Member

Wine Mafia

Sports discussion

Aristocratic Hoosier

Detroit Born and Raised

Wine Mafia

Faith, Hope & Love

Similar threads