This Guy or That Guy

[FaCe-LeE-uS]

Got a couple of questions for you gentlemen... All based on standard scoring/redraft leagues (standard default settings).

1. Melvin Gordon or Dalvin Cook
2. Derrick Henry or Kenyan Drake
3. AJ Green or Devante Adams
4. Doug Baldwin or Tyreek Hill

 

[MilkSpiller22]

Cook
Henry
Green
Baldwin

the hardest ones for me was Henry over drake and Baldwin over Hill

Miami has proven that they care more about the young back... And i fear Ballage will become the number one sooner or later

Henry doesn't have that fear of losing the number one spot, even though at this point it looks like he is in a 50/50 committee...

I dont like Seattle's offense, never have... but always have been proven wrong about Russell wilson... Seattle really has not much receiving talent... so baldwin should still be that number one...

KC has a new QB, New offense, and more Receiving talent... who knows if Hill will remain the number one... then again he really never was, he is just a freak of nature with speed...

 

[HaroldSeattle]

Cook
Henry
Adams
Hill

Cook vs Gordan was close, could of gone either way. Think Cook has a higher ceiling.....if he stays healthy.

Not to excited about Henry, but don't think Drake remains a workhorse for the Dolphins. So easy choose.

Adam with Rogers over Green with Dalton . Packers have a better offense easily.

Was hard not to go with Baldwin, but Hill is younger, so went with him.

 

[SmokingMonkey]

Baldwin over Hill, projecting more volume for Doug

Adams over Green, like Harold said, it's the QB you're buying here, not the WR

Henry over Drake, coin toss really just personal preference

Cook over Gordon, minny wants a workhorse and cook will get his. Injury concern for both, imo.

 

[SmokingMonkey]

Really both of those RB questions are preference, imo.

Pros and cons on both sides

 

[SteelersPride]

Got a couple of questions for you gentlemen... All based on standard scoring/redraft leagues (standard default settings).

1. Melvin Gordon or Dalvin Cook
2. Derrick Henry or Kenyan Drake
3. AJ Green or Devante Adams
4. Doug Baldwin or Tyreek Hill

gordon-cant deny the volume and no injury risk
drake-hes at least the starter
wow the green adams is a tough one, i think adams explodes but i still say AJ
baldwin hes been good and theres no comp for targets IMHO

 

[Bandit]

1. I'll take Gordon even though I have a vested interest in both of them being good.

2. Henry because he's going to get the majority of the 1st and 2nd down work and all the goal line work. Drake kind of fell into the job last year and I'm not sure he keeps it.

3. Adams. Green always seems to get overdrafted to me.

4. Baldwin. I'll take the consistency any day and like Steelers said, there's no competition for targets there at all.

 

[averagejoe]

Cook
Henry
Adams
Hill

 

[HaroldSeattle]

Cook
Henry
Adams
Hill

Great minds and all.....

 

[TREFF]

Cook
Drake
Adams
Hill

My only deviation from most others is Drake over Henry. I'm guessing the Titans slam their heads against the wall with Dion Lewis longer than they should, costing Henry far too many touches. I do think Drake can hold out this year as the main guy in Miami. If this were dynasty, I'd pick Henry, I have concerns about Drake past this season. Henry should only continue to gain value as the Dion Lewis experiment withers

 

[TKOSpikes]

Gordon
Henry
Green
Baldwin

 

[Stomp]

1. Melvin Gordon or Dalvin Cook - Love Cook, but Gordon is safe
2. Derrick Henry or Kenyan Drake - No contest in this one for me
3. AJ Green or Devante Adams - Would start considering both of these guys in the 3rd very slight edge to Green
4. Doug Baldwin or Tyreek Hill - Hill by a mile Andy Reid is the best offensive mind in the NFL and i don't like the direction the Seahawks are heading in.

 

[femurov]

1. Melvin Gordon or Dalvin Cook
2. Derrick Henry or Kenyan Drake
3. AJ Green or Devante Adams
4. Doug Baldwin or Tyreek Hill

I usually prefer the safer picks to the boom or bust type, but I had to stray from that for Hill. I'm high on Baldwin, too, though.

 

[FaCe-LeE-uS]

Great replies gents. Knew I could count on you guys.

Tallying up... Looks like we have some ties

1. Gordon 5 - Cook 5

2. Henry 7 - Drake 3

3. Adams 6 - Green 4

4. Baldwin 5 - Hill 5

 

[FaCe-LeE-uS]

Miscount! Looks like Adams & Green is tied as well.

 

[eaglesnut]

Gordon.
That's a team that started to hit on all cylinders. He's their workhorse.

Henry.
He will get the bulk of the work. Not concerned about a split.

Green.
Tough one. Adams just isn't as talented as Green and Green is due. But that's not very convincing reasoning honestly. Does Adams really have top 3 potential? I'm hesitant to make that claim.

Hill.
Chiefs offense pointing up. Seahawks offense pointing down.

 

[The Foot]

Cook - never was a big Gordon fsn
Henry - dont like drake. Ballage the rb they drafted can catch out of the back field and can do everything drake can do but do it a little better.
Green
Hill this is not even close in my opinion. Plus i tbin baldwin is just a product of Russell Wilson. I wouldn't be surprised if brandon Marshall sees a come back with a great accurate qb

 

[SteelersPride]

Cook - never was a big Gordon fsn
Henry - dont like drake. Ballage the rb they drafted can catch out of the back field and can do everything drake can do but do it a little better.
Green
Hill this is not even close in my opinion. Plus i tbin baldwin is just a product of Russell Wilson. I wouldn't be surprised if brandon Marshall sees a come back with a great accurate qb

Uh oh

 

[averagejoe]

Great replies gents. Knew I could count on you guys.

Tallying up... Looks like we have some ties

1. Gordon 5 - Cook 5

2. Henry 7 - Drake 3

3. Adams 6 - Green 4

4. Baldwin 5 - Hill 5

I would not be upset to own any of these guys except for Drake. Actually think @The Foot Is spot on here. Wow. Did I just agree with Foot?

 

[femurov]

I have a couple of this guy or that guys. I was thinking that we should just have one thread for all these debates and I thought that this was going to be the one. Should I start a separate thread or just add to this one?